Manchester keeps its AAA bond rating, and the raters asked about its reserves
The Finance Committee heard Nov. 12 that the town's first bond rating since 2018 came back AAA, with one note from the raters about reserves, and set its weekly budget meetings for January.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Manchester-by-the-Sea went to the bond market for the first time since 2018 this fall and came back with the same top rating, AAA. The finance director told the Finance Committee on Thursday, Nov. 12 that the rating agency "felt comfortable enough to maintain the AAA," and that the one thing it spent the most time on was the town's reserves.
The committee met four days before the Nov. 16 Special Town Meeting. Most of the two hour meeting went to a new chart of the town's debt and to planning what members would say on the floor Monday night. Here is what a resident would want to know.
What happened
- The AAA rating held. The town's last rating review was in 2018. This one kept the AAA, which keeps the town's borrowing costs at the low end, ahead of bond sales for projects voters already approved.
- The raters pointed at reserves. They told the town they like to see reserves of about 22 percent of the budget, a median figure for towns they rate. Manchester's policy keeps reserves at 8 to 10 percent. The finance director said the town explained that the lower number is on purpose and the agency accepted it, but she suggested the town look at the policy again when it builds next year's budget.
- A new debt chart. The finance director showed the town's debt three ways: bonds already sold, projects approved but not yet bonded, and the two projects on Monday's warrant. The middle high school debt comes off the books at the end of fiscal 2033.
- Budget season starts Jan. 7. The committee will meet every Thursday from Jan. 7 into late March. The town meeting booklet goes to the printer March 26.
- One vote: the committee approved its Oct. 22 minutes, from the meeting video.
The bond rating and the reserve question
The finance director said the rating agency gave the town a short summary of what it looks at and said about 22 percent of budget in reserves is the median it likes to see. Town officials said the figure surprised them. Manchester set its policy at 8 to 10 percent on purpose. Members recalled that reserves were 16.7 percent in fiscal 2018 and that the town chose to bring them down. One member said the agency "didn't say anything" when the town was at that level in 2018 but wondered about the drop since.
The finance director said other towns have built bigger reserves after failed overrides, so they can fund capital projects without a ballot vote. She said the agency called it good that voters here support projects when the time comes, but asked how the town would fund projects if that support ever ended. She told the committee she will send its report along and that the question belongs in the budget discussion this winter. No member proposed a change Thursday.
The raters "felt comfortable enough to maintain the AAA," the finance director said. The reserve level was the one thing they spent the most time on.
From the recording, about 1 hour 30 minutes in. The rating holds for about two years; the town expects to sell bonds in that window.
What the debt chart showed
The finance director's charts split the town's yearly debt payments into three colors: bonds already sold, which fall off over the next few years; projects town meeting approved in April 2025 and April 2026 that have not been bonded yet, including water meter, water and sewer work; and the two projects on the Nov. 16 warrant, the $7.5 million senior and community center and the town's share of the $95.3 million Essex Elementary School.
A member reading the middle color off the chart put it at about $1 million in fiscal 2028, about $2 million in fiscal 2029 and about $2.5 million a year from fiscal 2030 on, approximate figures. The finance director said she would email the charts to members. She recommended keeping new projects on short term notes until each is finished and then deciding how fast to pay down principal before borrowing long term, to keep yearly payments level. She noted the school district borrows for the school itself and bills the two towns each year, so Manchester cannot pay that debt down early on its own.
A member asked for a version of the chart looking back 20 years, saying it would show the town had put off infrastructure spending and is now catching up. The finance director said the capital plan will be laid on top of the debt chart during this year's budget work.
Town meeting prep: what the committee planned to say
- Fire engine (Article 3)The chair planned to remind voters that the town sets local revenue estimates low, that any excess goes to free cash at year end, and that free cash was over $1 million on June 30, which is why the $1,010,927 pumper can be paid in full now.
- School (Article 5)The vice chair planned a short slide presentation on the project, its cost and the average tax bill, including how the state grant works. The Select Board had put off its own recommendation to a meeting right before town meeting.
- Senior center (Article 4)The committee voted 4 to 3 in October not to recommend the article. The chair read a draft explanation and members pared it to the main point: the financing arrangement. The town would pay for the rebuild but own two thirds of the condominium, with the Masons keeping one third. Members agreed to say the majority does not support the proposal "at this time" and is open to a different arrangement later. They dropped a cost per square foot comparison after disagreeing about whether it was fair.
- Motion languageTown staff explained the senior center motion: no money borrowed or spent until $3 million in gifts and donations is in hand, except up to $100,000 for final design and bid documents so the project is ready to go. A $75,000 state earmark could cover part of that. The Masons' agreement calls for construction to start within three years of the April closing.
- If the school failsStaff said the state school building authority votes on the project budget Dec. 9; if either town's vote fails, a second town meeting and ballot would have to happen within 120 days after that.
The first quarter report
The finance director's fiscal 2027 first quarter report drew a few questions. Some department lines looked high after three months because annual bills such as the audit, property insurance and pension are paid in July. Building permit revenue is running below last year. The town clerk's budget is up because of the costs of the special town meeting and special election, including printing and staff time. Assessor salaries are still being paid out of a professional services line while the town uses an interim assessor, so a transfer will be needed later in the year. The finance director said she saw nothing significant to worry about in the next quarter.
Town staff also said the wastewater plant upgrade approved in 2025 has its state approval and should go out to bid in the next few weeks, and that the culvert project has its permit, with the main work about a year away.
What happens next
| Date | What |
|---|---|
| Nov. 16 | Special Town Meeting, 7 p.m., Memorial School (held; results in the Current's town meeting write-up). |
| Dec. 9 | State school building authority votes on the Essex Elementary project budget. |
| Dec. 10 | Ballot votes on the school and senior center debt exclusions, 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., Memorial School. |
| Dec. 21 | Possible joint meeting with the Select Board on the first budget requests, if members are available. |
| Jan. 7 | First weekly Thursday budget meeting; department head reviews begin. |
| Late February | Department reviews done; last four meetings go to capital, retiree benefits and final edits. |
| March 26 | Town meeting booklet to the printer. |
Dates as members and staff set them Nov. 12; the town posts the official schedule in its Agenda Center.
Where to find the records
The agenda is in the town's Agenda Center, where the minutes will be posted, and the meeting is on the town's YouTube channel. The senior center motion wording and every board's recommendation are in the Special Town Meeting report.
Earlier coverage: Manchester Finance Committee votes 3 to 4 against the senior center article (Oct. 23). The senior center forum (Oct. 28). Finance Committee takes up the fire engine, the school and the senior center (Oct. 17). What your property tax pays for in Manchester (Oct. 19). Monday's town meetings: every article on both warrants (Nov. 15).
How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the Nov. 12 Finance Committee meeting online on the town's YouTube channel and read the posted agenda and the town meeting report. These are meeting notes, not minutes; the committee's minutes are the official record. Questions and corrections: [email protected].
Sources
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Finance Committee agenda, Nov. 12, 2026
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Finance Committee meeting, Nov. 12, 2026, recording on the town's YouTube channel
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Agenda Center (minutes when posted)
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Special Town Meeting report, Nov. 16, 2026
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.