ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Tuesday, November 17, 2026Get the Morning Current

Know Before It's Decided

Gloucester Board of Health upholds $1,000 flavored tobacco fines on four stores; a fifth case waits until Dec. 10

The stores said nobody told them Zyn Chill nicotine pouches count as flavored. The board said the state ban has been on the books since 2020 and the health department warned retailers in June. It also approved a Magnolia Avenue septic request with two conditions and heard that a broken sewer outfall pipe near Stage Fort Park should be fixed by Sunday.

Chart: Gloucester's Aug. 19, 2026 tobacco compliance check and its results. 29 stores checked, about 8 found with flavored product, 2 sales to a minor. Board of Health on Nov. 12: 4 fines of $1,000 upheld, 1 appeal continued to Dec. 10, 1 unpaid fine that may rise to $2,000 with a 7 day permit suspension.
The health department's Aug. 19 compliance check and what the Board of Health did about it on Nov. 12, from the city's meeting recording. Votes are from the meeting video until the board's minutes confirm them. Cape Ann Current illustration

Trust Check: Checked against public records

Four Gloucester stores will pay $1,000 each for offering Zyn Chill nicotine pouches for sale. The city's Board of Health voted on Thursday, Nov. 12, to uphold the fines after a two hour round of hearings in which the stores' attorney argued that no one had told them the product counts as flavored. A fifth store's appeal was put off to Dec. 10 so its attorney can see the June email the health department says went to every retailer, and a sixth store that neither paid nor appealed was warned its fine will double.

Three of the board's four members sat: Chair Joseph Rosa, Vice Chair Eric Kaplan and Jesse Dole. Every vote was a voice vote with no vote against heard, from the meeting video. The meeting ran 2 hours 11 minutes.

$1,000fine upheld on each of four stores for offering flavored nicotine pouches for sale
29stores checked by the health department on Aug. 19, about 8 with flavored product and 2 sales to a minor, staff said
June 1, 2020when the Massachusetts ban on flavored tobacco and nicotine products took effect
Nov. 15when repairs to a broken sewer outfall pipe near Stage Fort Park were expected to be done

What happened

  • Four fines upheld: Sunny Variety on Railroad Avenue, Magnolia Variety on Raymond Street, Cape Ann Liquors at Gloucester Crossing and Annie's Variety on Concord Street each keep a $1,000 fine for offering Zyn Chill, a nicotine pouch the board found to be flavored, from the meeting video. Sunny Variety's violation also covered three other products, a countertop display and a permit that was not posted.
  • One continued: Mobil Energy North on Essex Avenue, whose attorney said the store pulled Zyn Chill as soon as it learned which product was at issue, returns Dec. 10.
  • One warned: Speedway on Main Street never paid or appealed its fine. The board voted to send a new notice and, if it is not paid within a week, to raise the fine to $2,000 and propose a seven day suspension of the store's tobacco permit.
  • Septic relief granted: A house on 111R Magnolia Ave. may replace a failed septic system with a conventional leach field 105 feet from its well, where the city rule says 150, on two conditions.
  • Outfall pipe: A broken wastewater outfall about 500 feet off Stage Fort Park was found Nov. 4. The water was treated effluent, not raw sewage, staff said, and repairs were expected to be done by Sunday, Nov. 15.

Why Zyn Chill was the fight

Massachusetts banned the sale of flavored tobacco and nicotine products, including menthol, on June 1, 2020. Gloucester's own Board of Health regulations say the same. The dispute Thursday was over Zyn Chill, a nicotine pouch whose maker markets it as unflavored but which the health department and the regional tobacco program say has a "characterizing flavor," meaning a taste other than tobacco, pointing to the maker's own filings with the federal Food and Drug Administration. The pouch contains a cooling agent. Board members opened a can during the hearing and put a pouch on their tongues to check for themselves.

The director of the North Shore Cape Ann Tobacco Policy Program, which does compliance checks in 60 cities and towns, testified that she and the health director inspected Sunny Variety on July 29 and found Zyn Chill, Zyn Smooth, Crave Clear pouches and Max Clear 3 percent pouches for sale, a countertop display, which state law does not allow, and no Board of Health permit posted. On Aug. 19 the program sent a trained youth into stores across the city. The youth asked for Zyn Chill at Magnolia Variety, Cape Ann Liquors, Annie's Variety, Mobil Energy North and Speedway, saw it on the shelf each time, and was turned away for having no ID each time. Those five stores were cited for offering a flavored product for sale, not for selling to a minor.

What the stores argued

An attorney for the owner of Sunny Variety, Magnolia Variety, Annie's Variety and Cape Ann Liquors said the owner has sold tobacco in the city for about 20 years without a violation, took the products off his shelves within days of the notice and relied on a manufacturer's letter certifying Zyn Chill as unflavored. He said the city never sent a notice naming Zyn Chill as flavored, that the word "chill" is not a flavor the way cinnamon or coffee is, and that for the four youth check stores there was no witness in the room who had personally seen the product on the shelf. He tried to play a video of the July 29 inspection from his phone; the chair said the board could not see or hear it.

Dole asked the owner whether he checks the FDA's searchable tobacco product database, launched in March 2024, when a distributor brings him a new product. The owner said he relies on the compliance letters that come with the products. "If it's a flavored product from the FDA, it's been tested by scientists at the FDA," a board member said. The city's counsel told the board the only question before it was whether the product on the shelf was flavored, not a federal lawsuit the attorney cited or what was on the video.

The senior health inspector said the health department emailed every retailer on June 15, 2026 with a list of nicotine pouches and the unflavored ones highlighted. Zyn Chill was not highlighted. The compliance checks came two months later. The attorney for Mobil Energy North said his client had never seen that email, that its own manufacturer certification is dated June 23, and that upholding a violation the store had no way to see coming was "regulation by surprise." The store's manager said the permit holder's contact at the company has left. The board continued that case to Dec. 10 so the attorney can review the June notice.

For Speedway, the senior health inspector said the store's general manager told her the company sends fines to corporate and corporate was choosing not to pay them in several communities. Staff recommended treating nonpayment as a second violation. The board's motion gives the store a week after a new notice before the fine rises to $2,000 and a seven day permit suspension is proposed, with a chance to appeal.

Across the city, the tobacco program director said, 29 establishments were checked on Aug. 19, about 8 had flavored product and there were only 2 sales to a minor. Most stores have since pulled the products, the chair said.

Magnolia Avenue septic: approved, with a well test every year

The city's sanitarian presented a request from 111R Magnolia Ave., where a septic system installed in the mid 1980s has failed. The only usable soil on the roughly 6.5 acre lot puts a new conventional leach field 105 feet from the house's drinking water well. The city's own rule requires 150 feet, or a nitrogen reducing system between 100 and 150 feet; the state minimum is 100 feet. He said the lot is well over the 4 acre size at which the state would require a nitrogen reducing system, and that the well tested at 2.5 milligrams per liter of nitrate in 1987 and 0.77 now, against a 10 milligram guideline, even with the old system next to it.

One neighbor wrote in opposition, questioning the distance to the lot line and noting that no Title 5 inspection was done when the house changed hands; the sanitarian said the field is 13 feet from the line where 10 is required and the new owners have signed an agreement to upgrade within two years. A second neighbor wrote in support. The board approved the variance by voice vote, from the meeting video, with two conditions suggested by staff: the owners must test the well every year for nitrate, nitrite and fecal coliform, and if the lot is ever divided, any new construction must use a nitrogen reducing system. A board advisor noted that Manchester requires annual testing of every private well, and the chair said the board may look at that.

Staff updates

  • Outfall pipe: The assistant health director said the Division of Marine Fisheries found the broken wastewater outfall on a Nov. 4 site visit, about 500 feet from Stage Fort Park in the Outer Harbor. Samples showed fewer than 100 colony forming units of bacteria and a strong chlorine odor, meaning the discharge was treated. The pipe should have carried it much farther into the bay. Dive teams have been out twice and the city's water and sewer engineer expected repairs done by Nov. 15.
  • Flu shots: The public health nurse said influenza A arrived early this year and remains moderate. She has given about 250 regular doses and about 150 children's doses, plus 174 of the 200 over 65 doses she ordered, and about 90 teachers were vaccinated at the schools. She has 26 over 65 doses and 4 regular doses left and is adding clinics, including at the YMCA and the Fishermen's Partnership.
  • Septic compliance: The department's campaign to find unpermitted or failed systems is now in Ward 5, its largest area, with about 100 first letters sent this week. About 10 failed systems, some of them cesspools, have turned up so far.
  • Food inspections: 44 inspections and 9 reinspections last month found 588 violations; critical ones are fixed on the spot and facility problems get 90 days or more. The adjunct food inspector is on pause until spring to save those hours for the busy season.
  • Youth survey: The Youth Risk Behavior Survey results go to the School Committee in December and then to this board.

What was decided, Nov. 12

ItemVote
Minutes of Oct. 8Approved by voice vote, from the meeting video
111R Magnolia Ave., leach field 105 feet from a well; conditions: annual well test, nitrogen reducing system for any new construction if the lot is dividedApproved by voice vote, from the meeting video
Sunny Variety, Railroad Avenue: Zyn Chill, Zyn Smooth, Crave Clear and Max Clear 3 percent offered for sale, countertop display; $1,000 fineUpheld by voice vote, from the meeting video
Magnolia Variety, Raymond Street: Zyn Chill offered for sale; $1,000 fineUpheld by voice vote, from the meeting video
Cape Ann Liquors, Gloucester Crossing: Zyn Chill offered for sale; $1,000 fineUpheld by voice vote, from the meeting video
Annie's Variety, Concord Street: Zyn Chill offered for sale; $1,000 fineUpheld by voice vote, from the meeting video
Mobil Energy North, Essex Avenue: appeal of a $1,000 fineContinued to Dec. 10 by voice vote, from the meeting video
Speedway, Main Street: unpaid and unappealed $1,000 fineNew notice; $2,000 and a proposed 7 day permit suspension if unpaid in a week, by voice vote, from the meeting video

Three members voting (Rosa, Kaplan and Dole). No count was announced and no vote against was heard. Not yet confirmed by the board's minutes.

What happens next

Dates to watch

  • Sunday, Nov. 15. Target date staff gave for finishing the outfall pipe repair off Stage Fort Park.
  • Thursday, Dec. 10, 5:30 p.m. The board's next meeting: Mobil Energy North's appeal returns, and the board can take up the 2027 meeting schedule, which was in Thursday's packet but not voted on.
  • Written decisions. The city's counsel said staff will put the hearing exhibits in order and the board will issue written decisions on the tobacco appeals.
  • December. The Youth Risk Behavior Survey results go to the School Committee first, then to the Board of Health.

Where to find the records

Earlier coverage: Tonight in Gloucester: five stores appeal flavored tobacco fines, and the zoning board returns to the Maplewood Avenue stormwater fix (Nov. 12), the agenda for this meeting.

How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the meeting online on the city's recording. Votes are as heard on the recording and are labeled from the meeting video until the board's minutes confirm them. These are our meeting notes, not the board's minutes.

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.