Gloucester schools project a $380,864 shortfall this year, even after the $150,000 contingency is spent
The School Committee's Building and Finance Subcommittee heard the chief financial officer's first projection for fiscal 2027 on Nov. 9: salaries about $560,000 over, benefits $214,000 over and a $75,000 legal settlement, and the staff said it is likely to get worse. The subcommittee also voted to raise long term substitute pay Jan. 1 and will take a closer look at bus cameras that ticket drivers who pass stopped buses.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Gloucester's schools are on track to spend $380,864 more than their $55.7 million budget this year, the district's chief financial officer told the School Committee's Building and Finance Subcommittee on Monday, Nov. 9, and that is after using the committee's $150,000 contingency. Asked whether the picture would improve, the staff answer was that it is likely to get worse.
What happened
- The first year end projection for fiscal 2027 shows salaries about $560,000 over budget and benefits about $214,000 over, offset in part by about $340,000 in savings on other regular education costs.
- The subcommittee voted to raise long term substitute pay on Jan. 1, 2027: from $100 to $125 a day for the first 20 days and from $125 to $150 a day after that. Raises for daily substitutes and retired teacher substitutes were put off to July 1 or sooner, pending more data.
- Lighted school bus stop signs would cost $12,000 to $15,000 for the 18 bus fleet. Swing out stop arms are not allowed under state law, staff said. A camera system that tickets drivers who pass stopped buses, at $250 a bus a month, will get a closer look once the new police chief is in place.
- The fiscal 2028 budget calendar runs from Nov. 18 to a public hearing May 12 and a School Committee vote May 26.
Where the money went
Chief Financial Officer Cody Marshall walked the three committee members through the projection. (How the school budget works and what was cut this year.)
The November projection, by category
Fiscal 2027 (July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027), as the chief financial officer presented it Nov. 9. Figures are his rounded estimates.
| Category | Against budget | Why, per the presentation |
|---|---|---|
| Salaries and personnel | about $560,000 over | Summer school, pay scale moves ($162,000 against $100,000 budgeted), special education substitutes and stipends, leave coverage, paraprofessionals, coaches, salaries moved off a cut state grant |
| Employee benefits | about $214,000 over | Unemployment $40,000 over the $80,000 budgeted; health insurance for new hires |
| Special education other expenses | about $100,000 over | Contracted services about $52,000 over, among other costs |
| Legal settlement | $75,000 paid | Members asked for the details of the case without any names |
| Regular education other expenses | about $340,000 under | A $112,850 bus lease payment moved to a city loan order; about $225,000 in expected department savings; supply savings just under $29,000 |
| School choice revenue | down about $75,000 | From about $260,000 to about $185,000 |
| Net, after the $150,000 contingency | $380,864 short | The staff said the number is likely to get worse before it gets better |
Source: the chief financial officer's presentation to the Building and Finance Subcommittee, Nov. 9, 2026, from the city's meeting recording [0:55:18 to 1:17:13]. The full School Committee gets the same update at its next meeting.
Salaries, about $560,000 over. Summer school salaries ran over. Teachers moving up the pay scale for new degrees and credits, budgeted at $100,000 on a multi year average, cost $162,000. Substitutes and stipends for high need special education assignments are about $60,000 over. The district is backfilling parental and medical leaves, added paraprofessionals to meet students' individual education plans, and could not cover athletic coaches from other contingency lines as it has in the past. A state grant that paid some salaries was cut substantially, so those salaries moved to the operating budget. School choice revenue, money that follows students who choose Gloucester from other towns, fell from about $260,000 to about $185,000.
Benefits, about $214,000 over. Unemployment payments to separated employees are $40,000 over the $80,000 budgeted, and new hires added health insurance costs.
Other costs. On the plus side, a bus lease payment of $112,850 was folded into a city loan order, and departments expect about $225,000 in other savings. On the minus side, special education contracted services are about $52,000 over and the district paid a $75,000 legal settlement. Committee members asked for the details of the case without any names.
The $150,000 contingency the committee set aside in the budget is already assumed spent. The district's revolving funds are healthy except transportation, which runs a deficit until athletics reimburses driver costs at the end of each season. Marshall will give the full School Committee the update at its next meeting and then monthly, and the superintendent will raise it with city finance staff at their meeting this week. (Why the special education cushion was already at a record low.)
Paying substitutes more
Superintendent Amy Pasquarello said the district cannot fill substitute jobs, especially long term ones, and a survey of nearby and comparison districts puts Gloucester at the bottom. The district pays $100 a day for a daily substitute, $150 for a retired Gloucester teacher ("teacher emeritus") and $100 to $125 for a long term substitute, who after 21 days writes lesson plans, grades and meets parents. Rockport pays $125 a day. The district paid for 216 long term substitute days in fiscal 2024, 245 in 2025 and 447 in 2026.
Long term substitute days paid by Gloucester schools
Days covered by a long term substitute, by fiscal year, as the staff reported them.
Source: district staff at the Nov. 9 meeting. A long term substitute is one who covers the same class for more than 20 days.
What a substitute is paid per day
| Type | Now | Proposed | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Long term substitute, days 1 to 20 | $100 | $125 | Jan. 1, 2027 (approved by the subcommittee) |
| Long term substitute, day 21 on | $125 | $150 | Jan. 1, 2027 (approved by the subcommittee) |
| Daily substitute | $100 | Not set | July 1, 2027 or sooner, after more data |
| Retired Gloucester teacher (teacher emeritus) | $150 | Not set; one member suggested $175 | July 1, 2027 or sooner, after more data |
| Rockport daily substitute, for comparison | $125 | As stated by Gloucester staff |
The subcommittee's vote on the long term rates is from the meeting video and not yet confirmed by minutes. Pay rates are normally set in the teachers' contract, so the change needs a side agreement with the union.
The staff proposal: raise long term substitutes on Jan. 1 and the daily and emeritus rates on July 1, when the next budget starts. Marshall said the district has spent about $260,000 a year on all substitutes over three years; the full package would cost about $310,000, close to $50,000 more. The Jan. 1 change costs about $4,000 for the rest of this year. Raising the daily rate would cost $35,000 to $40,000 a year, or about $20,000 at most if started in January.
One member argued for doing all of it Jan. 1, saying students are "sitting in auditoriums" when no substitute comes. Another said a $10 raise for retired teachers would not change anyone's mind and suggested $175. The superintendent said she would accept any start date but called the two step plan the responsible one when neither raise was budgeted. The subcommittee approved the long term increase by voice vote and asked for data before deciding the rest: unfilled substitute requests by day and month, how many class days went without a substitute this year and last, and the rates in Essex and Manchester Essex. Because pay is normally set in the teachers' contract, which runs through fiscal 2028, the change would be done by a side agreement with the union, as was done for bus drivers.
Stop arms and bus cameras
Staff came back with two options drivers had asked about. Fully lighted LED stop signs would replace the current signs at $650 to $800 each, about $12,000 to $15,000 for 18 buses, and the district's mechanic may be able to install them. Extender arms that swing about six and a half feet into the oncoming lane are not allowed in Massachusetts, staff said, and would take a change in state law or a Registry of Motor Vehicles waiver; members said that belongs on the list for the city's legislators. Members were split on whether brighter signs help in daylight.
A member described Bus Patrol, a company whose cameras record only while the stop arm is out. Police review each clip, the company issues the ticket under the city's name and collects it, and the city pays $250 a bus only in months when that bus produces a ticket. The member said six Massachusetts communities use it, including Quincy and Peabody, and a one month trial in Middleton found 91 violations. Who would get the fine revenue, the schools or the city, and who signs the contract would need a city ordinance and police time. The subcommittee agreed to wait for the new police chief, ask Quincy and Peabody how they fund it and set up a briefing for the superintendent, chair and CFO. No vote was taken.
The fiscal 2028 budget calendar
- Nov. 18: planning guidelines go to district leaders.
- December: school by school budget meetings.
- February: budget priority presentations.
- March: the superintendent presents the first fiscal 2028 budget.
- April: budget book review.
- May 12: School Committee public hearing. May 26: School Committee vote.
- June: presentation to the City Council's Budget and Finance Committee, then a final School Committee vote at the end of the month.
Members said they hope the mayor's budget number arrives earlier than last year, when it came around April vacation.
What was decided
Votes at the Nov. 9 meeting
| Item | Vote |
|---|---|
| Long term substitute pay, $125 a day for days 1 to 20 and $150 from day 21, starting Jan. 1, 2027 | Approved by voice vote, no count announced, from the meeting video |
| Transfer of $13,500 from a vacant Plum Cove school psychologist salary line to special education contracted services, to pay Merrimack College for a fellow placed at the school | Approved by voice vote, from the meeting video |
| Daily and teacher emeritus substitute rates, bus stop signs, bus cameras | Discussion only; no vote |
Three of the School Committee's members sit on the subcommittee and all three were present. Votes are from the meeting video and not yet confirmed by the subcommittee's minutes.
What happens next
Dates to watch
- Nov. 18. Fiscal 2028 planning guidelines go to district leaders.
- Next School Committee meeting. The chief financial officer presents the fiscal 2027 projection to the full committee, then monthly.
- Jan. 1, 2027. New long term substitute rates take effect, once a side agreement with the teachers' union is signed.
- May 12, 2027. School Committee public hearing on the fiscal 2028 budget.
- May 26, 2027. School Committee vote on the fiscal 2028 budget.
Where to find the records
- Building and Finance Subcommittee agenda, Nov. 9
- Meeting recording, on the city's November 2026 Past Meetings page
- Minutes will be posted with the School Committee's documents once approved.
Earlier coverage: Gloucester's $55.8 million school budget: who decides, what it pays for and what was cut (Nov. 2); Gloucester schools lose 83 students in a year (Nov. 6), the Nov. 4 School Committee meeting; Gloucester schools' special ed cushion to hit record low: $348,382 (Oct. 16).
How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the meeting online and checked names and figures against the agenda and the School Committee roster. These are our meeting notes, not the committee's minutes; votes are labeled from the meeting video until the minutes are posted. Questions or corrections: [email protected].
Sources
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.