Gloucester fishing: Why boats throw fish back, and who bans it
A reader called it ludicrous that boats can throw fish back. Here is why it happens and what is allowed here. Norway has banned it since 1987. Europe's own review says its ban fell short. Some Gloucester boats already keep every groundfish, with cameras on deck.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Crosscurrents is where readers have their say. This one started with a comment on our Facebook page. Send yours.
A Cape Ann Current reader wrote: "I've always thought that it is ludicrous to allow discards on a commercial boat."
So we took a look at what discards are, why they happen and what is allowed here.
The short version: U.S. boats are not just allowed to throw some fish back. For some fish, the law makes them. Some Gloucester boats now work a different way. They keep every groundfish, with cameras on deck. A few countries ban throwing fish back, and the results are mixed.
What the words mean
A discard is a fish a boat catches and then puts back over the side. It may be alive or dead.
A zero discard policy is a ban on doing that. Boats have to bring what they catch to the dock, where it gets counted. Europe calls its version a landing obligation.
"Zero" is the goal, not the result. None of these bans covers every kind of fish. None has ended the practice.
NOAA Fisheries sorts discards into two kinds:
- By choice. The crew puts fish back because they are the wrong size or quality, or will not sell for enough.
- By law. The crew has to put fish back because the boat is not allowed to keep them.
If the fish is already dead, why throw it back?
It sounds wasteful, and it is. The fish dies and nobody eats it.
Here is the thinking behind it. Size limits are there to protect young fish. Quotas cap how much of each kind a boat can take. If a boat could keep and sell a fish that is too small or over its limit, there would be money in catching it. Making the crew put it back takes away the payoff.
That leaves two problems. The fish is wasted. And if nobody counts it, the people who set catch limits do not know how many fish really died.
Zero discard policies try to fix both. The fish comes to the dock and gets counted.
Europe added one more guard. Fish below the legal size have to be landed, but they cannot be sold for people to eat. They go to uses such as pet food and fish meal. The aim is to use the fish without making a market for small ones.
How much gets thrown back
A boat may pull up fish that are too small to keep by law. It may catch a kind of fish it has no quota left for. Or the fish may sell for so little that it is not worth the space on board.
Some of those fish live. Many do not.
It adds up. A United Nations study found that boats around the world threw back about 9.1 million metric tons of their catch each year from 2010 to 2014. That is about 20 billion pounds. It works out to about 1 of every 10 fish caught.
What is allowed here
The main U.S. fishing law is the Magnuson-Stevens Act. It tells managers to keep unwanted catch as low as they practically can. It has no ban that covers every boat. For some fish it works the other way: a boat has to put back fish that are too small or over its limit.
Those fish still get counted. NOAA Fisheries estimates how much goes back on trips with no monitor aboard, using what monitors saw on similar trips.
Alaska shows it can go the other way here. Since 1998, boats there have had to keep all the pollock and Pacific cod they catch, with observers on board. In the first year, pollock thrown back fell from 8.2% of the catch to 1.6%. Cod fell from 8.6% to 2.2%. A 2019 review of discard policies around the world called it possibly the clearest success of any it looked at.
New England has something close to a ban for groundfish. Those are fish such as cod, haddock and flounder.
Many groundfish boats belong to sectors. A sector is a group of boats that shares a catch limit. NOAA Fisheries lists 15 sectors for this fishing year. The agency's Northeast office is in Gloucester.
Since a federal change in December 2022, sector boats can sign up for one of two camera programs.
Keep it all. This one is called maximized retention. Boats must keep and land every groundfish that counts against their sector's limit. That includes fish too small to sell the usual way. Cameras record the deck. A monitor meets the boat at the dock and watches the fish come off. Fish dealers must report all of it, small fish included.
It does not cover every kind of fish. Ocean pout and fish that are not groundfish are handled the usual way.
Count what goes back. In the other program, boats still throw back fish they cannot keep. The cameras check that the crew's count is right.
Who has tried to stop it
Other countries have gone further, and some big ones have not. Here is how 15 places handle it.
Tap a column heading to sort. Type in the box to search.
| Place | Started | What boats must do | Good to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Iceland | 1977 | Keep and land the whole catch, with a few exceptions. It began with six kinds of fish. | Small fish count only half against quota. Every catch is weighed at the dock. Haddock thrown back fell from 22% in 1997 to under 1% in 2013. |
| India | 1982 | Do not throw back large amounts of extra catch. | Motor boats have never followed it, a 2019 review says. No counts are kept. |
| New Zealand | 1986 | Keep quota fish that are big enough to sell. Put undersized fish back right away. | One study found real catches were about double what was reported. |
| Norway | 1987 | Bring in about 55 kinds of fish. The ban began with cod and haddock. | Fishing grounds close when boats there catch too many young fish. A boat keeps only 20% of the value of fish over its limit. |
| Russia | 1987 | Do not throw back cod in the Barents Sea, under a deal with Norway. | Russia does not publish counts of fish thrown back there. |
| Faroe Islands | 1994 | Bring all fish ashore, along with heads, guts and liver. Throwing fish back is against the law. | Since 1996, boats that catch several kinds of fish at once are limited by days at sea, not pounds of each fish. |
| Alaska | 1998 | Keep all pollock and Pacific cod. | Observers ride on the boats. Pollock thrown back fell from 8.2% to 1.6% in one year. |
| Chile | 2001 | Keep the catch. Rewritten in 2012 with cameras on boats. | The first version only punished. Crews stopped reporting and kept dumping. |
| European Union | 2015 | Bring in fish that have catch limits. In full force since January 2019. | A 2025 review said it has not worked as hoped. |
| Peru | 2016 | Report the young anchovy in each catch. Boats are no longer fined by the landing for having too many. | The old fine pushed crews to dump small fish at sea, the government says. The season can close when too many young fish are caught. |
| New England | 2022 | No ban for all boats. Boats in one camera program keep every groundfish that counts against their limit. | Cameras watch the deck. A monitor meets the boat at the dock. |
| Argentina | Not listed | Do not throw fish back, by national law. | Trawlers are thought to throw back 25% to 30% of their catch. Checking is weak. |
| China | No ban found | Stay under a cap on young fish in the catch. Use nets with legal mesh. | Almost nothing is thrown back. Small fish are sold for fish meal and fish farm feed. |
| Indonesia, Vietnam and Southeast Asia | No ban found | Laws lean on closed seasons, zones and net sizes. | Very little is thrown back. Small fish go to fish meal, fish paste and the table. |
| Japan | No ban | Stay inside catch limits for some kinds of fish. | One estimate puts fish thrown back at about 14% of the catch. |
Norway: Don't catch them in the first place
Norway banned throwing back cod and haddock in 1987. The ban grew over time. By 2014 it covered about 55 kinds of fish. Fish that are still alive and likely to live can go back.
Its law is written in an unusual way. It bans catching the wrong fish, not just having them on board. So Norway works to keep small fish out of the net.
In the Barents Sea, fishing grounds close when boats there start hauling up too many young cod. The closed areas move as the fish move, often within hours. Trawlers there must use grids in their nets that let small fish swim out.
Norway also takes the profit out of a bad haul without making the crew dump it. Fish over a boat's limit must still be landed. The boat gets 20% of what the fish sells for, to cover the work. The rest pays for fishing patrols and checks.
Has it worked? Norway has no old counts of dumped fish to compare with. But its fisheries officials reported in 2015 that the cod and haddock in the Barents Sea old enough to spawn had grown to four to five times what they were. They say the ban and the steps around it helped. They also credit good ocean conditions and lighter fishing.
Iceland: Make it easy to bring fish in
Iceland started in 1977 with a ban on throwing back six kinds of fish. A 1996 law widened it to the whole catch. Five years before that, Iceland gave each boat its own share of the catch, which owners can buy, sell and trade.
Iceland takes away some of the reasons to dump fish. Undersized fish count only half against a boat's quota. A boat can go up to 5% over its quota and have the extra taken out of next year's share. A boat that catches something it did not plan for can buy quota to cover it.
It also checks. Every catch is weighed at the dock by a certified weigher who works for neither the boat nor the buyer. Drones have watched for dumping since 2021. The names of those caught breaking the ban are made public.
There are exceptions. Crews can release some live fish under a set size. Fish with no value can go back too.
Has it worked? A presentation on Iceland's system to a European fishing advisory group says sampling puts Iceland's discards at about 3% to 5% of the catch. It puts the world average at 10% to 11%. A 2019 review of discard policies found haddock thrown back in Iceland fell from 22% of the catch in 1997 to about a tenth of 1% in 2013. Cod has stayed under 2% since 2001. The review notes that some people in the industry dispute those numbers.
Faroe Islands: Count days, not pounds
In the Faroe Islands, throwing fish back is against the law. The ban dates to fishing reforms in 1994, after the islands' cod and haddock crashed. A newer law took effect Jan. 1, 2020. Under it, all fish must come ashore, along with the heads, guts and liver, so the whole fish gets used.
In 1996 the islands also changed what pushes boats to dump fish. Where boats catch several kinds of fish at once, they are limited by days at sea and not by pounds of each kind. With no quota to run out of, there is less reason to throw a fish back. Areas also close to protect young fish.
Has it worked? Scientists at the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea say dumping in these fisheries is thought to be very small. They also say there are no solid numbers to prove it.
Peru: A fine that backfired
Peru runs one of the world's biggest fisheries, for anchovy. It used to fine boats when more than 10% of a landing was young fish.
Peru dropped that fine in 2016. Its Ministry of Production says the fine gave crews a reason to dump small fish at sea, which also hid the true catch from scientists. Now boats must report young fish, and the season can close when too many are caught.
Not everyone agrees with the change. A 2024 investigation by the Peruvian outlet OjoPublico, published with the Pulitzer Center, said Peru's own sea institute had not recommended it.
Chile, Argentina and New Zealand: Bans on paper
A ban is only as good as the checking behind it.
Chile banned throwing fish back in 2001 and cut the quota of boats caught doing it. Crews stopped reporting, and the dumping went on out of sight. Chile rewrote the law in 2012. It now requires cameras on boats, paid for by the industry.
Argentina's national fishing law bans the practice. Even so, its trawlers are thought to throw back 25% to 30% of what they catch. A 2019 review of discard policies called the checking there weak.
New Zealand has barred boats from throwing back legal sized quota fish since it set up its quota system in 1986. One study cited in that review found the real catch was about double what boats reported.
China, Japan and the rest of Asia: A different problem
China is the world's biggest fishing country. The sources we read describe no ban there on throwing fish back. They describe something else: almost nothing gets thrown back.
The United Nations' fisheries agency says discards in most fisheries in China and Southeast Asia are close to zero. That covers big fishing countries such as Indonesia and Vietnam. Small, low value fish have buyers there. They become fish meal, fish paste and feed for fish farms.
That solves the waste and makes a new worry. A 2019 Greenpeace report found that about half of what China's trawlers catch is small, low value fish, and that much of it is young fish that never got to grow.
India has had a law since 1982 against throwing back large amounts of extra catch. The 2019 review says motor boats have never followed it and nobody keeps count.
Japan has no ban, according to a research paper on its fishing industry. It sets catch limits for some kinds of fish. A Monterey Bay Aquarium report cites an estimate that Japanese boats throw back about 14% of their catch on average.
Russia agreed with Norway in 1987 not to throw back cod in the Barents Sea, researchers at the University of British Columbia report. Russia does not publish counts of fish thrown back there.
Europe: A ban that fell short
The European Union started its ban in 2015. It has been in full force since January 2019. Boats must bring in fish that have catch limits, and those fish count against quota. There are many exemptions.
In June 2025, the European Commission shared an outside review of the ban. The review said the ban "has not reached its full potential."
It gave four main reasons:
- Weak watching. The tools for checking boats and enforcing the ban did not work well.
- Little reason to go along. Fishermen did not gain much by following it.
- Cost. Nets that let unwanted fish escape can also let valuable fish escape. That costs boats money.
- Too many exemptions. There are so many that it is hard to tell what the ban has changed.
Why not make every boat keep everything?
There are trade-offs. Fish nobody wants take up space on board. They use up quota. They cost time and money to handle. And some fish have a good chance of living if they go back fast. Protected animals have to be let go.
The lesson from other countries is that a ban is only one piece. Norway pairs its ban with closed areas and gear that lets small fish escape. Iceland makes it cheaper to land a surprise catch and checks every landing. The Faroe Islands limit days at sea. Peru and Chile found that punishment alone can make dumping worse. Alaska put observers on the boats. Europe's review says a ban with weak checking and many exemptions does not change much.
Close to home
Gloucester boats landed 38.4 million pounds of seafood in 2024, worth $66 million at the dock. We covered that in our story on NOAA's seafood import study. A reader also asked whether NOAA's budget is bigger than U.S. fishing.
One thing these sources do not show is how many pounds of fish Gloucester boats throw back in a year.
Have a question?
Comment on any of our Facebook posts, or send a Crosscurrents entry. You can sign it or stay anonymous.
Sources
- CreditReader comment on a Cape Ann Current Facebook post, November 2026
- RecordFood and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Discards and Bycatch (2010 to 2014 world estimate)
- RecordNOAA Fisheries: National Bycatch Reduction Strategy (the two kinds of discards)
- RecordEuropean Commission: Discarding in fisheries (the landing obligation and undersized fish)
- RecordFood and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Discards in the World's Marine Fisheries, An Update (Norway, Iceland and the Faroe Islands)
- SourceFiskerforum: Real-time monitoring and preventive closures applied to anchovy fishery (Peru, 2026)
- SourcePulitzer Center and OjoPublico: The Sacrifice of Anchoveta, July 14, 2024
- RecordKarp and others: Strategies Used Throughout the World to Manage Fisheries Discards, in The European Landing Obligation (Springer, 2019)
- RecordFood and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Asian fisheries today, low value and trash fish in the Asia-Pacific region
- SourceGreenpeace East Asia: An investigation report into China's marine trash fish fisheries (2019 briefing)
- RecordSea Around Us, University of British Columbia: Reconstruction of Russian fisheries catches in the Barents Sea
- RecordFrontiers in Marine Science: Reconstructed Russian Fisheries Catches in the Barents Sea, 1950 to 2014 (2018)
- SourceMonterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch: Sardines, Japan (report)
- SourceThe Fishing Industry and the Environment in Japan (research paper)
- RecordThorsteinn Hilmarsson: Icelandic fisheries, landing obligation and discards (presentation to the North Sea Advisory Council workshop; undated)
- RecordElementa: The quest for fisheries governance, lessons from the Faroe Islands (2021)
- RecordInternational Council for the Exploration of the Sea: Faroes ecoregion, ecosystem overview
- RecordFaroese Seafood: Fishery legislation and management
- RecordNOAA Fisheries: Discard methodology (groundfish sectors), updated June 15, 2026
- RecordGullestad and others, Norwegian Directorate of Fisheries: The Discard Ban Package (2015)
- RecordEuropean Commission: Independent study highlights some challenges in implementing the landing obligation across EU fisheries, June 16, 2025
- RecordFederal Register: Northeast Multispecies Fishery, Amendment 23, Dec. 9, 2022
- RecordNOAA Fisheries: Fishing Year 2026 Sectors
- RecordNOAA Fisheries: Northeast Multispecies (Groundfish), updated Sept. 22, 2026
- RecordCape Ann Current: Gloucester port: NOAA Fisheries seeks help tracing imported seafood
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.