Essex school team answers residents on size, cost and the curved entrance at its last community meeting before the Nov. 16 vote
The Nov. 4 session at Essex Elementary School was all questions and answers: the 250 student design, a two year construction plan that keeps classes on site, a $180,000 premium for the barrel shaped entrance and what the project would add to an Essex tax bill.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Residents filled the gym at Essex Elementary School on Nov. 4 for the last community meeting on the plan to replace the school, and the project team spent the night answering questions. Nobody voted on anything. The questions were about how big the school needs to be, why it costs what it costs, what the tall curved entrance adds to the bill and what the project means for an Essex tax bill.
What happened
- The building is designed for 250 students in kindergarten through grade 5, the number the state's school building authority set, plus two pre-K classrooms of 15 students each. About 200 students are enrolled now.
- Construction would run from 2028 to 2030 in phases, with students staying in the building the whole time. No modular classrooms and no move to another site.
- The barrel shaped roof over the entrance costs about $180,000 more than a plain pitched roof, about two tenths of a percent of the project, the project team said.
- Essex's share works out to about $118 a year for every $100,000 of a home's assessed value, averaged over a bond of up to 30 years, the district's finance director said.
- Both towns vote on the borrowing at their town meetings Monday, Nov. 16, then at the ballot box Thursday, Dec. 10. (What voters are deciding, with a tax calculator.)
How big the school would be
The superintendent said the design holds pre-K through grade 5, which would bring pre-K back to Essex for the first time since about 2010, when the district moved it to Manchester Memorial Elementary School to save money. The district must serve 3 and 4 year olds with special needs and fills the rest of the seats with tuition paying students. Last year it ran three pre-K classes at Memorial and had enough interest for four. This year it cut back to two because kindergarten enrollment grew and needed the room, which left a waiting list.
The Massachusetts School Building Authority, the state agency that pays part of the cost of school projects it approves, sets the enrollment a district may design for. It gave Essex 250 students, based on a 10 year projection that counts development the town's Planning Board knows about. Enrollment is about 200 now and peaked at about 270 around 2013 to 2014. A resident who works in statistics said a number that small comes with a wide margin of error, and two families moving out could swing it 10 percent. District officials said the building has spaces for art, music and world language that could hold a bubble class for a year or two, and the project team said the site leaves room for about 20 percent more classroom space later if it were ever needed.
The existing school is about 55,000 square feet. The new one would be about 74,000 square feet, a committee member said. The project team said the extra room is mostly small group and flexible space, which principals at newly built schools told the committee is what they run out of first.
Two years of construction with students in the building
The owner's project manager walked through the phasing plan on screen. The construction manager would fence off the front of the site in 2028 and build the academic wing and part of the community wing from September 2028 to July 2029. In the second phase, from summer 2029 to July 2030, part of the old building comes down and the rest of the community wing goes up. After the move in, the rest of the old school is removed and the field, play areas and paving are finished. The slides showed completion in December 2030.
The principal said student safety would be the top concern and that she would work closely with the construction manager on every phase. The committee said it chose that firm partly for its experience building on occupied school sites.
The entrance, the "Taj Mahal" and what it costs
Several residents asked about the two story entrance with its curved wooden roof. One resident said people at the senior center call it too beautiful for an elementary school. The committee had marked the entrance's footprint on the gym floor and said it is about half the size of the hub at Memorial. The principal said the space is not a lobby but a working part of the school: it holds the main stairs, the front and back entrances, and the room for lines of students moving to music, gym and lunch all day. She said the current one door entrance is a safety problem at events, when 200 families pile into a small space, and that the new design gives staff sight lines in every direction.
A committee member said the lobby also lets the school lock off the classroom wing when the community uses the building, including for town meeting, which now sends voters through open classroom areas.
The design team said the premium for the barrel shaped roof, compared with a plain pitched roof, is about $180,000, about two tenths of a percent of the project. When a resident asked for the cost of the whole entrance with its wood and glass, the team said it had not priced that separately because some connecting space would have to be built there either way. A committee member said Memorial's hub likely cost more than what Essex is proposing, that Essex taxpayers helped pay for Manchester's school and that Essex children deserve the same kind of building.
Why it costs what it costs
The construction manager's director of estimating said construction prices have risen about 65 percent since Memorial was built eight or nine years ago, and showed a chart comparing Essex with about ten other elementary schools under construction or about to start, all adjusted to 2028 prices. With site work, he said, Essex is about $1,053 per square foot against an average of $999, and the gap is mostly the site, which is about 50 percent larger than Memorial's because it includes the athletic field and has ledge. Building only, the chart showed Essex at $874 per square foot against an average of about $835. The chart also included a premium for building in phases around an occupied school.
A committee member said the team has already cut about $3 million through value management, for example by replacing some terra cotta tile with masonry block, and that the process continues through final design. The amount the towns approve is a cap; the district can borrow only what the building costs after the state grant is subtracted. The committee said the middle high school and Memorial both came in under their original asks.
The project team also said the state's stretch energy code, which was not in place when Memorial was designed, requires triple glazed windows and more insulation. That adds to the upfront cost but should make the school cheaper to run.
The options the committee turned down
A committee member described the choices studied over three years: repairing the building to current codes for about $53 million with no state aid, adding on to it for about $75 million, moving students to Manchester, and several layouts on the Essex site. She said the repair and addition options would not meet the educational program the state approved and would lose the state grant of about $20 million. (How the $95 million project compares with other new schools.)
What it does to a tax bill
The finance director said the $118 per $100,000 figure is the average yearly cost over the life of the bond, which could run up to 30 years, and ends when the debt is paid. The cost is split by the district's regional agreement, roughly one third Essex and two thirds Manchester. Essex paid about one third of the middle high school and Memorial projects. The middle high school debt is paid off in 2034, so the new payments ramp up as the old ones fall off.
The superintendent said the district would borrow with the advice of a financial adviser and both towns' finance committees, probably starting with short term notes while the market is watched, with the largest borrowing coming in the third year when construction starts. A resident asked whether businesses could be taxed at a higher rate to ease the load on homes. Officials in the room said the Essex Finance Committee looks at that every year, and that with about 90 percent of the town's revenue coming from homes, a split rate would not change the residential bill much. (How the two towns plan to run the night of the votes.)
What happens next
- Tuesday, Nov. 10: the School Building Committee's next business meeting.
- Monday, Nov. 16: Essex Fall Town Meeting at 6:45 p.m. at Essex Elementary School and Manchester's special town meeting at 7 p.m. at Memorial School. The school borrowing needs a two thirds vote at each.
- Thursday, Dec. 10: ballot votes in both towns.
Where to find the records
- Essex Elementary School Building Project, on the district website, with the FAQs and the enrollment study
- Meeting video, on the public access channel
Earlier coverage: A spring revote would add about $4.5 million (Nov. 4), the committee's Oct. 27 meeting; the community meetings schedule (Oct. 26); what voters are deciding Nov. 16 and Dec. 10 (Nov. 9).
How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the meeting online and checked names against the committee roster on the district website. These are our meeting notes, not the committee's minutes.
Sources
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.