ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Tuesday, November 17, 2026Get the Morning Current

Know Before It's Decided

Does Gloucester and Magnolia need a private waste transfer station? The cost to the city, the risk to the environment and the questions still open

A site for up to 270 tons a day of construction waste at 24 Kondelin Road won a Board of Health assignment in June 2025, but the state construction permit, zoning approvals, site plan review, building permit and operating authorization are all still ahead. The cleanup bond is $10,000, with no cost estimate behind it. How to weigh in, for or against.

Trust Check: Checked against public records

Does a private company's construction waste station belong beside a wooded swamp, a railroad underpass and a single narrow truck route in West Gloucester, and who pays if something goes wrong? The Board of Health found in June 2025 that the site meets the state's tests, and much remains ahead before anything is built. Two public steps are coming on the proposed construction waste transfer station at 24 Kondelin Road in West Gloucester. The Gloucester Conservation Commission takes up the company's wetlands filing on Wednesday, Nov. 18, and the Board of Health's Eastern Waste Service subcommittee is still tracking the 37 conditions attached to the 2025 approval. Ahead of those meetings the Current went back to the city's files on the project. This is what the public record shows, with the sources, and where it is silent.

The short version (maps, a proposal ledger, a decision timeline and the risks are below)

  • The Board of Health assigned the site on June 18, 2025, with 37 conditions. That is one step of several. The state construction permit, City Council zoning approval, Planning Board site plan review, a building permit and a state authorization to operate all remain, and no appeal or building permit has been filed.
  • The approval allows up to 270 tons a day of construction and demolition waste, six days a week, inside a new building of about 11,800 square feet, on 1.5 acres of a 4 acre parcel.
  • The company, Eastern Waste Services LLC, already runs a recycling drop off at the address. In 2022 the state fined it for taking construction waste there without the approvals it needed.
  • A wetlands filing for stormwater work, repaving and a fence has been continued again and again. It is now listed for the Conservation Commission on Wednesday, Nov. 18.

Jump to: The case against | Transportation | Environmental risk | Benefit to Gloucester | How to take part | Email your officials

Why residents are asking whether Gloucester needs this: the case against, in five points

Transportation

538 heavy vehicles a day

Every heavy truck would use one route north on Magnolia Avenue, through a railroad underpass 22 feet wide in an S-curve. The city's own traffic reviewer found that large trucks take up more of the road under the bridge, that transfer trailers fully cross the lane even at 10 miles an hour, and that sight distance is not enough for trucks heading north. Heavy vehicles on that stretch would rise from 389 to 538 a day, about 38 percent.

The Board of Health's decision found the traffic study did not model two heavy trucks meeting there or consider school bus stops. Read the transportation section

Environmental risk

A wooded swamp next door

The site borders a wooded swamp, and about 4,400 square feet of ledge would be blasted behind the building. Manchester-by-the-Sea filed maps of its wells and the state's protection radii and asked the state for a full environmental impact report on May 22, 2025. The wetlands filing goes before the Conservation Commission on Nov. 18.

Federal records also list the site as an active small quantity generator of hazardous waste. Whether that was reviewed is an open question below. Read the risks

The company's record

A $32,337 state penalty

In 2022 MassDEP assessed a $32,337 penalty, with $12,337 suspended, for operating a solid waste facility at 24 Kondelin Road without a site assignment or a state permit. The company consented without admitting or denying. Federal trucking records show 24 roadside inspections in 24 months and a vehicle out of service rate of 30.8 percent, against a national average of 22.26 percent. Read the record

The benefit to Gloucester

Still unanswered

We found no figure for jobs or tax revenue. The company offered a 25 cents a ton community impact fee in 2025, the Board of Health did not adopt it, and the Board of Health's site assignment decision requires no host community agreement. A project description says existing employees would run the station. The only money set aside for the city is a $10,000 yearly cleanup bond. The EDIC reversed its 2023 position without a public reason we could find. See what the EDIC said

Fairness

Why Gloucester?

Would an affluent town like Wellesley, Concord or Cambridge ever allow a private waste transfer station in its borders? Did the company look at any of them, at Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex, or at Georgetown, which already has a large transfer station, or only at property it already owns? Gloucester residents ask whether they get the same protection and representation, and the same demands on the company, as a wealthier town would. See the questions

The company's side. The company says it would serve local contractors and operate inside an enclosed building under 37 conditions. The Board of Health found the site meets the state's tests, and the state Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that it did not expect adverse effects on public health and safety. The EDIC chair said on Nov. 10 that the company is investing $10 million to $15 million.

What is the benefit to Gloucester? Still unanswered

The EDIC, in its own words, on Nov. 10, 2026

What the EDIC chair said
"Investing $10 to $15 million"
"Happy to support" the company "on a large scale economic development, strategic basis"
"Nobody wants the trucks"
"Not interested in EDIC getting into the weeds"
Added Nov. 16, 2026: how other host agreements compare

The company offered a fee, and the Board of Health did not take it. At its June 12, 2025 meeting the board discussed a quarterly community impact fee of 25 cents a ton that Eastern Waste Services put in its closing materials, according to our review of the meeting transcript (auto-generated, speakers unnamed). The board kept the $10,000 payment bond (condition 26) and its June 2025 site assignment decision requires no per ton fee and no host community agreement. Other approvals are still pending. At the 180 to 270 tons a day the company's witness described, on 260 days a year, 25 cents a ton would come to about $11,700 to $17,550 a year. That is our arithmetic, not a figure in the record.

Fees in other towns are mostly written for landfills, which are larger, so the comparison is imperfect. South Hadley's landfill agreement sets the greater of $2 a ton or a share of the tip fee, free disposal of 4,000 to 8,000 tons a year of town waste and $50,000 a year for the public works department. A proposed Seneca Falls, N.Y., agreement sets $4 a ton, 5,000 free tons a year and about $250,000 a year for engineering and wastewater services. The per ton fees we confirmed elsewhere run from 85 cents to $4.

What the record still does not show

What Gloucester receives in return. In the discussion we reviewed, no one gave a figure for jobs or tax revenue to the city. A board member said the company would not want a limit on who can use the site, and that opponents see the facility as serving outsiders.

The chair said the EDIC does not want to take up operational neighborhood issues. That leaves open who speaks for the neighborhood on the trucks.

Source: city recording of the EDIC board meeting, Nov. 10, 2026, and its automatic transcript. Speakers are not named on the recording, and quotes are checked against two transcripts. The board took no vote.

Risks to the community, as the record frames them

Pulling the record together, these are the concerns that come up most. They are concerns raised in the hearing record and the city's reviews. They are not findings that harm will happen. Each card says where the concern came from and what the file shows today.

One narrow underpass for every heavy truck

The underpass on Magnolia Avenue is 22 feet wide in an S-curve. The city's public works director said the road was lowered in 1971 so trucks could fit, which left a dip that floods. The company's expert called two heavy trucks passing a "tight fit" and had not modeled it.

Where it stands

The reviewer's Feb. 2026 draft says trailers fill the lane even at 10 mph. Fixes accepted so far are speed advisories and signs.

More trucks on the same road

The EDIC's own June 2025 minutes estimate 130 to 140 truck entries a day, one every four to five minutes at peak. An expert for an abutting party said added truck trips would nearly double traffic (98 percent). The reviewer puts heavy vehicles at 389 a day now and 538 with the station.

Where it stands

Capped at 149 added diesel trips a day over a year, with quarterly self reports to the Board of Health.

Children, walkers and cyclists

The decision says the traffic study did not consider school bus stops on Magnolia and Essex avenues or bus traffic to West Parish School, and did not analyze people on foot or bike.

Where it stands

On Oct. 8, 2026 the board ordered the unanswered part of condition 18 on walkers and cyclists answered.

Water and wetlands

Manchester-by-the-Sea filed maps of its wells and the state's protection radii, and asked for a full environmental impact report on May 22, 2025. Private wells sit on nearby Kondelin Road lots; one is owned by the applicant. The decision attached conditions on groundwater and soil.

Where it stands

The Board of Health told the Conservation Commission on Oct. 8, 2026 that the outside wetlands review skipped conditions 20, 24, 30, 31 and 32 and asked for them to be assessed.

Litter, odor, noise, pests

The decision found these manageable with conditions: enclosed building, closed doors, hours, and a cleanup fund the city can draw on with 48 hours notice. The decision notes the city is ultimately responsible for litter on Kondelin Road and Magnolia Avenue.

Where it stands

Depends on enforcement by the Board of Health and a third party inspector once the station is built.

Blasting and construction

Plans call for removing about 4,400 square feet of ledge behind the building.

Where it stands

The board accepted the company's blasting study (condition 19) on Oct. 8, 2026.

Compliance depends on self reports

The company was fined by the state in 2022 for taking construction waste without approvals. Most of the 37 conditions are tracked by reports the company submits.

Where it stands

In May 2026 the company counted 4 conditions in compliance, 2 completed, 8 in process and 23 not yet due. These are the company's counts, not the board's findings.

What the record weighs for Gloucester

The record does not answer that question, and the Board of Health did not try to. Its decision asks whether the site meets the state's site assignment criteria, not whether the city wants the station. What the file does show is who has spoken for it and against it.

The case made for it. The company told the state the station would serve local contractors and would not touch the city's curbside contracts. It says at least eight haulers rent and empty construction containers on Cape Ann, but nothing serves homeowners and small contractors with smaller loads, and the nearest transfer stations are in Peabody (21 miles) and Georgetown (28 miles). It points to the state's goal of cutting disposal of construction debris by 260,000 tons by 2030 and to limited disposal capacity in Massachusetts. The state Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that it did not expect adverse effects on public health and safety. On June 2, 2025 the Gloucester Economic Development and Industrial Corporation (EDIC) voted unanimously to send a letter supporting the site, with conditions. The decision also gives residents a Saturday recycling drop off (condition 13).

Other points in its favor. The record shows these, and each is the company's claim or a condition of the approval, not a measured result.

  • Only site of its kind on Cape Ann. The company's application says no construction debris transfer station exists in Gloucester or on Cape Ann. Hauling to Peabody (21 miles) or Georgetown (28 miles) is the alternative it names. It did not put a number on time or money saved.
  • A regulated operation in place of an unapproved one. The state found the company took in construction debris from about 2017 to 2022 without the approvals it needed. The 2025 approval puts the site under 37 conditions, including handling waste inside a building, truck logs, load checks and regular reports to the board.
  • Road cleanup that does not exist now. A magnet sweep truck must run Kondelin Road and Magnolia Avenue daily (condition 25), and the $10,000 bond gives the city money for cleanup on 48 hours' notice (condition 26).
  • Stormwater upgrades. The application says the company would upgrade catch basins and add treatment while adding no paved area, and calls this a fix for existing site conditions.
  • A Saturday drop off for residents. Residential recycling is limited to Saturdays (condition 13).
  • A local trucking employer, but no new jobs expected. Federal records list 17 trucks and 14 drivers at 24 Kondelin Road. A project description in the company's filings says existing employees would run the station and no additional employees were anticipated.
  • Recycling goals. The company says an enclosed building supports the state goal of cutting construction debris disposal.

The case made against it. In 2023 the city told the state that its own solid waste needs are met by its municipal contract and that it saw no need for the station. The city asked the company to show a "critical need." The company answered that the city has no contracts for construction debris. The City of Gloucester, three ten-citizen groups, the EDIC and the Manchester-by-the-Sea Board of Health all took part in the hearings as parties. The board's own findings point to the single truck route, the railroad underpass, school bus stops, and a wooded swamp on the site's edge.

The EDIC changed its position
October 2023

The Gloucester Economic Development and Industrial Corporation (EDIC) told the state the site is neither suitable for waste services nor compatible with its plan to bring professional jobs to the Cape Ann Industrial Park. It cited a 2019 survey of park businesses.

June 2, 2025

The EDIC voted unanimously to send a letter supporting the site, with conditions. We did not find its reasons in the records we read. At the 2025 hearings its chair questioned the city's expert about conditions such as trip reporting and leachate.

Sources: EDIC comment letter, Oct. 17, 2023 (hearing Exhibit 16); EDIC minutes, June 2, 2025.

What the EDIC said on Nov. 10, 2026. The board took no vote and spent about five minutes on the company, according to the city's recording and its automatic transcript. Speakers are not named on the recording, so we attribute remarks to board members. The member who chaired the meeting called the expansion "challenging" and said there is a lot of community opposition, mostly over trucks in the neighborhood. He said part of the opposition is a sense that the facility serves outsiders more than local contractors. He said the EDIC took part in the hearings as a voice for business and economic development, that the company is investing $10 million to $15 million, and that the EDIC does not want to get into operational neighborhood issues because it is a volunteer board. He said the company has not yet received its state DEP permit and still has city permits to obtain. Another member said the company would not want a limit on who can use the site. We have not seen the $10 million to $15 million figure in any filing.

What the record does not show. The only investment figure we found is the EDIC chair's spoken estimate of $10 million to $15 million on Nov. 10, which we have not seen in a filing. We found no figure for jobs or tax revenue the city would receive. The only fee we found is a 25 cents a ton offer from 2025 that the board did not adopt. We found no estimate of what road wear or enforcement would cost the city. We found no study of whether local contractors or homeowners would pay less. Who benefits depends partly on where the loads come from, and the approval does not limit that.

After the approval: who enforces, who pays, and what happens when the company leaves

When a private company runs a construction and demolition transfer station, the city does not run it. Gloucester becomes the host community, a regulator of some things, and a customer of others. The record shows how that works here, and where it is silent.

Who can say no later. The Board of Health decided the site assignment under state rules. The state, not the city, issues the construction and operating permits still ahead, and the state permit can set limits that a city cannot easily change once it is in place. The conditions the city did write are enforceable only if someone checks them. Most rely on reports the company files itself, and the city's tools for proving an odor, dust or noise complaint inside a private property line are limited. The record does not say who at City Hall would measure one.

Who pays for the wear. The company's own filings name 538 heavy vehicles a day on the road. The $10,000 bond covers cleanup of debris, not worn pavement, repairs after a bridge strike or extra police and fire coverage. We found no host community agreement in the public record, the kind of contract in which a company agrees in advance to pay a host city for road upkeep, inspections or a fee. Without one, the questions of who repairs Magnolia Avenue and who pays the Fire Department are open.

Fire. Stored piles of dry wood, dust and mixed debris can burn, and batteries in mixed debris are a known cause of fires at waste facilities. The permit tracker lists an emergency vehicle access plan for the Fire Department and city engineering. The record we read does not show a fire load review, a water supply review or a cost estimate for the equipment and training a large debris fire would require.

When the company leaves. The record shows no closure plan, no money set aside for removing waste and restoring the site, and no one named to take over if the operator fails or sells. The 2022 state order states that its terms bind successors, which covers that order only. The one financial guarantee in the file is the $10,000 bond, renewed each year. If a pile of debris is left behind next to a wooded wetland and a drinking water protection area, the record does not say who would pay to remove it.

Home values and the tax base. The record has no study of how a transfer station would affect nearby home values, no estimate of added property tax from the building, and no comparison with what the site pays now. Neighbors on the streets that lead to the site would see the trucks, and the record does not say whether anyone has asked an assessor or an appraiser what that could mean. If values fell, the city would collect less from those homes, and a lower assessment on the station site itself would not make up the difference. Today there is no number to say which way it goes.

What happens when the company leaves?

Who can answer

Board of Health, City Solicitor, Mayor's office, MassDEP

Questions
  • Is anyone asking what happens when Eastern Waste Services leaves, sells or fails, and how is the city planning for it?
  • Is there any money set aside to remove waste and restore the site, beyond the $10,000 bond?
  • Who would pay to clear a full building of debris, and who would hold the site meanwhile?
  • Would the conditions and the bond pass to a new owner, and who would the city call?

Home values and the tax base

Who can answer

City Assessor, Mayor's office, City Council

Questions
  • Has anyone looked at the effect on home values near Kondelin Road and along the truck route, or is the area simply being asked to host the station?
  • What property tax would the new building add, and could lower values nearby cancel it out?
  • Would residents be able to seek lower assessments if values fell, and what would that cost the city?

Fire and emergency response

Who can answer

Fire Chief, Public Works, Building Department

Questions
  • Has the Fire Chief reviewed the fire load of stored wood, dust and mixed debris, and the battery risk?
  • Is there enough water supply nearby for a large debris fire, and what would the response cost the city?
  • Who pays for specialized training and equipment?

Who enforces, and who pays?

Who can answer

Board of Health, Mayor's office, City Council, the company

Questions
  • Who would measure odor, dust or noise if neighbors complain, and with what equipment?
  • Can the city ask for a host community agreement now, and what would it cover?
  • If the state permit sets limits the city dislikes, what can Gloucester still do?

What is pending now, and where it stands

The Board of Health approved the station in June 2025, but approval was the start of a long list of follow up steps. Nothing has been denied. Several items are still open, and the one with a date on it is the Conservation Commission on Nov. 18.

Item Status Where it stands
Board of Health site assignment, 37 conditions Approved June 18, 2025. The board says it cannot add conditions now, only enforce these
MassDEP site suitability Approved Positive determination, Apr. 3, 2025
State environmental review Decided Mar. 27, 2023: a full impact report was not required. Manchester-by-the-Sea asked for more review on May 22, 2025. The state denied the request in Oct. 2025, and no appeal was filed, the city solicitor's tracker says
Blasting study (condition 19) Accepted Oct. 8, 2026. The board can reopen it if later permits show blasting is not feasible
Traffic study (condition 18) Pending Filed Nov. 2025. Reopened Oct. 8, 2026 on people walking and biking
Wetlands filing, Conservation Commission Pending Continued on Oct. 7, Oct. 21 and Nov. 4. Listed for Nov. 18
Soil testing (condition 20) Pending Outstanding. A licensed site professional has been hired, the company's attorney said
Hazardous materials and asbestos plan (condition 30) Pending A draft is on file. The board has not approved it
Truck trip data (condition 12) Pending Logs since last July had not been turned in, the subcommittee said Oct. 6
Waste ban compliance plan Pending A draft was submitted in April 2026. State review: not found
Fence on city property Pending City cease and desist, Apr. 16. A new fence on the property line was approved, and a corrected decision awaits recording, the company's attorney said
State permit to construct (MassDEP) Not yet filed The city solicitor's tracker lists it as not filed, with the prerequisite conditions outstanding. The state takes about 120 days from a complete application, then a 30 day public comment period
Zoning approval, City Council Not yet filed A special permit or a modification of an existing one, after the state construction permit. A separate special permit may be needed to remove more than 50 cubic yards of rock
Site plan review, Planning Board Outstanding Required under the zoning ordinance (section 5.8), likely alongside the special permit. The Planning Board has 45 days to act once the application is on its agenda
State authorization to operate (MassDEP) Not yet filed Comes after construction, with proof of financial assurance for closure and post closure costs
Building permit Not yet filed The fence must come down first, per the company's report. The tracker lists it after the zoning approvals
Appeal of the 2025 decision None filed The deadline passed July 27, 2025, per the city solicitor's tracker
The 2023 and 2024 proposals Replaced 325 tons and a 15,750 square foot building became 270 tons and 11,800 square feet in June 2024

Steps still ahead before anything is built. The city solicitor's permit tracker sets the main sequence, and the decision's conditions fill in the rest. Only the first step has a date.

  1. Wetlands ruling. The Conservation Commission hears the filing Nov. 18. It has not ruled. A stormwater connection application to Public Works is also not filed.
  2. Fence off city property. Condition 5 requires it before a building permit.
  3. Board of Health prerequisites. Soil testing and the blasting study (conditions 19 and 20) come before the company applies to the state to build. The blasting study is accepted and soil testing is outstanding. The tracker also lists an emergency vehicle access plan for the Fire Department and city engineering, and the traffic study, the hazardous materials and asbestos plan and the truck trip data are pending.
  4. State approval to construct. The company has not filed. The state takes about 120 days from a complete application, sends a draft decision to the Board of Health, and opens a 30 day public comment period. It may hold a public hearing.
  5. Local zoning approvals. The City Council issues a special permit, and the Planning Board reviews the site plan. A separate special permit may be needed to remove more than 50 cubic yards of rock.
  6. Building permit. The Building Department issues it. It is not yet filed.
  7. Construction and occupancy permit.
  8. State approval to operate. It requires proof that the facility was built as approved and that financial assurance for closure is in place. The Board of Health then monitors compliance with the site assignment.

The sections below explain each step, starting with what is and is not in place at the site today.

What is, and is not, in place at the site

The building is the core of the plan. The company applied to build a new facility, and the decision requires it to be built in substantial compliance with the filed plans (condition 4), with all waste handled inside the building. The approval is written around that building, and we found nothing that lets it stand without one. A changed plan, such as a smaller building, a different owner or a different use, could mean going back to the Board of Health. The record does not say how the board would treat that.

No building has been built, as far as the records show. The city solicitor's permit tracker lists the state construction permit, the Planning Board's site plan review, the City Council's zoning approval and the building permit as not yet filed. The company's May 7, 2026 report to the Board of Health describes only preconstruction site prep and says the fence has to come down before a building permit can be issued. The state approval to operate comes only after construction, and the wetlands filing is unresolved.

The material would be construction and demolition debris. The company's application lists concrete, brick, asphalt, masonry, plaster, drywall, metal, lumber and wood. That includes loads already partly sorted elsewhere, leftovers from sorting plants (residuals), and bulky cleanout items such as furniture and carpet. The application lists no hazardous waste. Condition 8 bars yard waste, food waste, household trash and compostables. Asbestos handling waits on a plan the board has not yet approved (condition 30).

The loads would come from a wide area that the approval does not limit. The application says there is no drop off for homeowners and small contractors on Cape Ann, and puts the nearest transfer stations in Georgetown (28 miles) and Peabody (21 miles). The traffic study split inbound trucks among Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea by population. We found no limit on where loads may come from and no count by town. At the June 4, 2025 hearing the company's witness was asked whether it would check that customers live in Gloucester or restrict access to the city or other Cape towns, and said it would not. Outbound trailers were assumed to go to disposal sites south and west via Route 128.

How the daily tonnage compares with Cape Ann's own debris

The company's witness testified that the station would handle about 180 tons a day normally and up to 270 at the maximum, and said the greater Cape area could sustain that. We compared that with the state average. In 2024, Massachusetts disposed of 1,710,000 tons of non-municipal solid waste, a category MassDEP says grew primarily because of construction and demolition debris. Divided by the state's 2024 population of 7,138,560, that is about 0.24 tons per resident. At that rate the four Cape Ann towns, with 46,886 residents in 2024 estimates (Gloucester 30,544, Rockport 7,099, Essex 3,771, Manchester-by-the-Sea 5,472), would dispose of about 11,200 tons a year, or about 43 tons on each weekday. The company's 180 to 270 tons a day, on a five day week of 260 days, is about 46,800 to 70,200 tons a year, roughly 4 to 6 times that.

This is our arithmetic, not a finding in the record. It uses a statewide average of all non-municipal solid waste, which includes more than construction debris, so it likely overstates what Cape Ann disposes of, and it counts disposal only, not debris that is recycled. Cape Ann may differ from the state average, and the company has not said what share would come from each town or from outside. The company's witness also said at the June 4, 2025 hearing that it would not check where customers live or limit use to Gloucester or Cape Ann. Added Nov. 15, 2026. Updated Nov. 17, 2026 to use 2024 state data in place of 2018 data.

With the status of the site set out, the next question is who is behind the proposal and where it sits.

Who and where

Eastern Waste Services LLC does business as Hiltz Waste Disposal, according to its federal trucking registration, which lists 24 Kondelin Road as its address, 17 trucks and 14 drivers. The company's own website calls the site the Essex County Recycling Center. The board's decision says the company took over the site around 2017. The company's May 7, 2026 report to the Board of Health lists the property owner as a separate company, DLM Properties, LLC.

The site is in the Cape Ann Industrial Park. The decision found no occupied building within 500 feet and no public water supply protection zone at the site. The state Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that no residential or other non industrial zoning lies within 1,100 feet and that the area does not meet the state's environmental justice criteria. At the Oct. 8 Board of Health meeting the company's attorney put the nearest house at about 1,100 feet. A traffic reviewer noted possible future residential areas about 500 feet south.

Green sign reading Hiltz Moving and Storage, Inc.
The sign at the Cape Ann Industrial Park entrance, cropped to the Hiltz name.

Who is behind the name?

Who can answer

The company, through its attorney, and the Secretary of the Commonwealth's business records

Questions
  • The sign says Hiltz Moving and Storage, Inc. The applicant is Eastern Waste Services LLC, which does business as Hiltz Waste Disposal. How are the companies related, and who owns each?
  • Which company would hold the state permits, the bond and the insurance, and which would answer if something went wrong?
  • Can a company that operated without approvals before, according to the state's 2022 order, be trusted to follow 37 conditions that mostly rely on its own reports?
  • What would the city do differently to check, instead of trust?

The company's record with state and federal agencies

Public databases show what follows for Eastern Waste Services LLC, which does business as Hiltz Waste Disposal. We checked them on Nov. 11, 2026. A listing with no violations is a fact about the records, not a finding about the company's practices.

Agency What the record shows Date
MassDEP (state environmental) Administrative consent order with penalty and notice of noncompliance No. 00012892, effective March 10, 2022, for operating a solid waste facility at 24 Kondelin Road without a site assignment from the Board of Health or a state solid waste permit. The penalty was $32,337, with $20,000 payable in six installments and $12,337 suspended on condition of no further violations for a year after the last payment. The company consented without admitting or denying. The state's Energy and Environmental Affairs data portal lists the site as Essex County Recycling Center (facility 368513) with three enforcement actions: notices of noncompliance on Jan. 14, 2002 and April 18, 2017, and this order. The portal also lists seven inspections: Dec. 10, 2001; June 17, 2003 (reinspection); Aug. 15, 2005; Dec. 2, 2018; Oct. 14, 2021; June 3, 2022; and Oct. 31, 2023 (a solid waste visit with limited enforcement potential). Permit records show a solid waste permit entry (SW01-0000007) and a "determination of need for site assignment" (SW17). The portal lists no enforcement action after 2022 and no inspection after Oct. 31, 2023. The entries do not show what each notice cited. Portal checked Nov. 11, 2026; order issued March 10, 2022
EPA (federal environmental) EPA's ECHO database has a facility record for 24 Kondelin Road (registry ID 110071467359; hazardous waste ID MAR000625293; industry code 56211, waste collection). It lists the site as an active small quantity generator ("SQG") of hazardous waste under the federal waste law, which means a registration to produce a limited amount of hazardous waste. It shows no violation in any of the last 12 quarters, no inspections, no informal or formal enforcement actions and $0 in penalties. It lists no Clean Water Act or Clean Air Act permits. The 2022 state order does not appear in it. EPA's RCRAInfo record for the site lists one waste code, F037 (a refinery oil, water and solids separation sludge), and also registers the site in the federal used oil program. Checked Nov. 11, 2026
FMCSA (federal transportation) Interstate for hire trucking company, USDOT 3063127, authorized to haul property, with 17 trucks and 14 drivers. It has no federal safety rating. Its registration was last updated July 1, 2024, and the agency marks it outdated. Data as of Nov. 9, 2026
State transportation We found no separate Massachusetts public record. State roadside inspections feed the federal figures above. Not found

Roadside inspections

24

inspections in 24 months, 16 with violations

Vehicle out of service30.8%
Worse: national average is 22.26%
Driver out of service4.2%
Better: national average is 6.67%

Blue is the company, gray is the national average. A lower rate is better: it means fewer vehicles or drivers were ordered off the road by an inspector. 24 months to Nov. 9, 2026.

Violations

39

violations found in those inspections

  • Vehicle maintenance30
  • Unsafe driving8
  • Driver fitness1
  • Hours of service0

The agency lists no penalties and found no critical violations in investigations. Data as of Oct. 30 to Nov. 10, 2026.

Crashes

2

reportable crashes in 24 months

  • With an injury1
  • Tow away1
  • Fatal0

The data do not say where they happened or who was at fault. 24 months to Nov. 9, 2026.

What the 2022 state order says

The administrative consent order is a signed agreement between MassDEP and the company, effective March 10, 2022. The text below is from the order. The company agreed to it without admitting or denying the facts, and agreed not to contest them for purposes of enforcing the order.

Date What the order says
Sept. 14, 2021 MassDEP receives a complaint that the company was accepting, handling and transferring construction and demolition waste at 24 Kondelin Road
Oct. 14, 2021 MassDEP inspects. It reports mixed construction waste from various contractors dumped on the ground in an open air upper storage yard that is neither enclosed nor covered; a pile of mixed waste of about 150 to 200 cubic yards, including wood, metal, plastic, rubber and house siding; and eight roll off containers of mixed waste
Oct. 14, 2021 Facility personnel tell MassDEP the site accepts construction waste from general contractors and the general public five days a week, pushes it with an excavator into a 100 cubic yard trailer, and sends an average of two such trailers a day, five days a week, to a processing facility in Wilbraham
Jan. 10, 2022 MassDEP issues a notice of enforcement conference
Feb. 1, 2022 Company representatives meet MassDEP
March 10, 2022 The order takes effect

What it found. The Board of Health had not granted a site assignment and MassDEP had not issued a solid waste permit. The company operated the Essex County Recycling Center under a general permit for recycling, which allows only pre-sorted recyclable materials. The order cites two rules: operating a solid waste facility without a site assignment (310 CMR 16.01(8)) and without a state facility permit (310 CMR 19.028). It lists the company's principal offices as Clinton, Connecticut.

What it required. Stop receiving any solid waste, including construction waste, immediately and operate only under the general permit for recycling. Within 30 days, stop storing solid waste and remove all of it, including every container of mixed construction waste. Within 60 days, send MassDEP a written certification of compliance.

The penalty. MassDEP assessed $32,337. The company was to pay $20,000: $7,500 within 30 days, then five payments of $2,500 every 30 days through day 180. MassDEP suspended $12,337, to be demanded only if the company violated the order or the cited rules between the order date and one year after the last payment. Violating the order carries stipulated daily penalties of $250 a day for the first 15 days, $500 a day for days 16 to 30 and $1,000 a day after that.

The state portal lists no enforcement action after this order. The public record does not show whether the installments were paid on schedule, whether the 60 day certification was filed, or whether the suspended amount was ever demanded.

Source: MassDEP Administrative Consent Order with Penalty and Notice of Noncompliance No. 00012892, Eastern Waste Services LLC, effective March 10, 2022. The 2025 approval would allow the kind of activity the order describes, indoors and under 37 conditions.

What "active small quantity generator" means

In the federal EPA database, an Active SQG is an active small quantity generator of hazardous waste, regulated under the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, known as RCRA. EPA sorts every site that produces hazardous waste by how much it makes in a month. In Massachusetts the state environmental agency, MassDEP, runs the matching program under 310 CMR 30.000.

Category Hazardous waste made per month How long it may be stored on site
Very small quantity generator 100 kilograms or less (about 220 pounds) Up to 1,000 kilograms at a time
Small quantity generator More than 100 and under 1,000 kilograms (about 220 to 2,200 pounds) Up to 180 days, or 270 if shipped more than 200 miles, and never more than 6,000 kilograms (about 13,200 pounds)
Large quantity generator 1,000 kilograms or more Up to 90 days, with no cap on amount

"Active" means the site's registration is current in EPA's hazardous waste database. A registered small generator has to notify the government that it produces hazardous waste, renew that notice every four years, and make arrangements with local emergency responders. Hazardous waste here means wastes on EPA's lists or wastes with traits such as toxicity, ignitability, corrosivity or reactivity.

It is a classification, not a violation. The record says the site falls in the middle tier.

What the registration lists. EPA's RCRAInfo detail record for the site (handler ID MAR000625293) lists one hazardous waste code, F037. In EPA's rules, F037 is a listed hazardous waste: sludge from the gravitational separation of oil, water and solids during the storage or treatment of process wastewater and oily cooling wastewater at petroleum refineries. The same record also registers the site in EPA's used oil program, and lists its industry as waste collection. It does not say where the F037 waste came from, how much was made, when, or where it went. A construction waste hauler is not a petroleum refinery, so the code raises a question the public record does not answer.

Sources: U.S. EPA, Categories of Hazardous Waste Generators and Frequent Questions About the Hazardous Waste Generator Regulations; EPA ECHO Detailed Facility Report and RCRAInfo detail view for 24 Kondelin Road; 40 CFR 261.31. Pound figures are conversions from EPA's kilogram thresholds.

A question the EPA record raises. A hazardous waste generator registration is not a violation, and EPA shows none. It does mean the site is registered with the federal government as a place that produces hazardous waste, and the record does not say where the F037 waste came from, how much there was, when it was generated, or why a construction waste hauler's site carries a refinery waste code. The Board of Health's decision lists a hazardous materials and asbestos plan as condition 30, and that plan is still pending. Whether the board, its reviewer or MassDEP looked at the EPA registration while reviewing the plan is not in the public record.

Sources: EPA ECHO facility record; FMCSA SAFER company snapshot and Safety Measurement System profile for USDOT 3063127; MassDEP Administrative Consent Order No. 00012892 (March 10, 2022); MassDEP Energy and Environmental Affairs data portal, facility 368513 (permits, inspections, enforcements). The company's transportation figures cover all its trucks, not only trips to this site.

How Manchester-by-the-Sea is involved

The site is in West Gloucester, but Manchester-by-the-Sea has been a formal party since the 2025 hearings. Its Board of Health took part as an intervening party. On May 22, 2025 it asked the state for further environmental review. Its public works director filed an affidavit on June 3, and the health board filed maps of the town's private wells and a memo on Wolf Trap Brook on June 4.

The water concern is the wooded swamp across Kondelin Road. The decision says evidence showed water from that swamp flows into Wolf Trap Brook, which runs into Manchester-by-the-Sea and eventually reaches the beach south of the site. On the wells, the decision found the facility's waste handling area is more than 500 feet from the town line, so Manchester's private wells do not trigger the state's well distance rule.

Manchester also has a standing seat at the next step. Condition 14 requires the company to send notice of every Gloucester Conservation Commission meeting to the Manchester-by-the-Sea Board of Health, and the town is on the notice list for the wetlands filing.

Maps

The two maps below show where the site sits and the single route its trucks would use.

Where the site is

Zoom and drag. Tap a pin for details. Use Aerial to see the industrial park.

■ Mapped wetland (shaded)━ Wolf Trap Brook (dashed where it runs in a culvert)━ Truck route

The Board of Health decision describes a wooded swamp across Kondelin Road from the site. Water from it flows into Wolf Trap Brook, which runs toward Manchester-by-the-Sea. The shading and the brook come from OpenStreetMap and are approximate. The official wetland lines are in the company's wetlands filing.

  1. Proposed station site, 24 Kondelin Road. Inside the Cape Ann Industrial Park, about 0.6 mile along Kondelin Road from Magnolia Avenue.
  2. Kondelin Road meets Magnolia Avenue. Heavy trucks can only come and go to the north, because Magnolia Avenue south of here carries a 2.5 ton limit.
  3. Route 128 ramps on Essex Avenue. About 2.8 miles by road from the site, measured along the mapped route.

Pins and road lines: OpenStreetMap contributors; the site pin is an address lookup and is approximate. Aerial: MassGIS 2025. Facts: Board of Health site assignment decision, June 18, 2025.

What construction debris is, and what the law says about it

The answers above turn on what the waste is and who regulates it, so here is the law in plain terms.

The short answer: construction and demolition debris, as a category, is ordinary solid waste, not hazardous waste. Parts of it can be hazardous, and the rules are mostly about catching those parts.

How the law defines it. Massachusetts defines construction and demolition waste (C&D) as waste building materials and rubble from the construction, remodeling, repair or demolition of buildings, and it extends to pavements, roads and other structures. A transfer station is defined as a place where solid waste is brought, stored and moved from one vehicle or container to another for treatment or disposal. Hazardous waste is a separate legal category: the state's solid waste rules exclude it, and it is handled under different regulations. Federal pages on C&D landfills say those landfills do not receive hazardous waste unless they are separately permitted for it, and they leave oversight of C&D debris mostly to the states.

When parts of it become hazardous or toxic. "Toxic" is not a label for C&D as a whole. Under federal law, a waste is hazardous if it is on a list or shows a characteristic such as toxicity, which is tested by how much of a poison leaches out. EPA's lead guidance uses a limit of 5 milligrams of lead per liter of leachate. Waste from lead paint work in homes is excluded from the hazardous waste rules by the household waste exclusion, which EPA has applied to contractors working in residences. EPA says waste from non-residential renovations can still be regulated as hazardous. Asbestos is handled under its own federal and state rules rather than the hazardous waste list.

What can be in a load How it is treated Main rule
Concrete, brick, asphalt pavement, metal Recyclable. Banned from disposal and from transfer for disposal State waste bans, since July 1, 2006
Wood, treated or not Banned from landfills only. May be recovered State waste bans, since July 1, 2006
Clean drywall (gypsum wallboard) Banned from disposal. Must be pulled out of mixed loads before processing State waste bans, since July 1, 2011
Asbestos materials "Special waste." A C&D transfer station cannot accept it State asbestos rule (310 CMR 7.15); federal asbestos rule
Lead paint debris Hazardous only above the leachate limit, and homes are excluded Federal hazardous waste rules; state deleading rules
Mercury items (thermostats, fluorescent bulbs), PCBs Mercury items should come out before demolition. PCBs have their own rules EPA guidance; state and federal PCB rules
Furniture, carpet, bulky cleanout Regular solid waste. Mattresses and textiles are banned from disposal State waste bans, since Nov. 1, 2022

What the rules require of a company like this.

  • Separate the banned materials. A C&D facility above 50 tons a day must pull out banned materials as much as it can and meet a minimum recovery rate. The state's guidance sets that rate at 20 percent from Jan. 1, 2025, 23 percent from Jan. 1, 2027 and 25 percent from Jan. 1, 2030. A facility that misses either test may not dispose of its leftover waste and must send it to a facility that meets the standard.
  • Check the loads. The facility files a waste ban plan with the state that covers monitoring incoming loads and handling loads that fail. MassDEP guidance sets a minimum number of vehicle inspections a month by permitted size, a staffer dedicated to the tip floor above 50 tons a day, and a 20 percent by volume action level for mixed banned materials in a C&D load. Lead batteries, appliances, whole tires, mattresses and old monitors are unacceptable in any amount. The guidance's general table would call for at least 8 inspected vehicles a month at a 270 ton facility; we have not confirmed that the table applies to this one.
  • Keep asbestos out. Asbestos work needs a state licensed contractor, a survey before demolition, advance notice to MassDEP, sealed and labeled containers and signed shipping records. Asbestos waste goes only to a landfill approved for it. State guidance says an existing transfer station needs the department's specific approval even to store it temporarily. That is the subject of condition 30, which requires a board approved plan; the company's draft is unapproved.
  • Report. Facilities file annual reports that include their recycling rates.

Who checks. MassDEP can enter and inspect a facility, take samples and review records. It may ask that a load inspection be done in front of its inspector. Violations can bring written notices, consent orders, penalties or referral to the Attorney General, and repeat, willful or serious violations can bring penalties of up to $25,000 a day. Locally, the Board of Health holds the site assignment and wrote 37 conditions, including an independent inspector for two years (condition 33). The state fined this company in 2022 for taking construction waste without the approvals required. We did not find a federal permit or a federal inspection program for a facility of this kind, and the federal asbestos rule is enforced through state and local agencies.

What the record does not show. How the company would screen loads day to day, who the independent inspector would be, where it would send leftover waste, whether the 20 percent recovery rate fits its plan, and whether MassDEP has inspected the site since 2022. Those are fair questions for the Board of Health and MassDEP.

What the approval allows

With that background, this is what the Board of Health actually approved.

Limit What the decision says Cond.
Waste accepted Up to 270 tons a day of construction and demolition waste. No yard waste, food waste, household trash or compostables 7, 8
Hours of operation 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday to Friday; 7 a.m. to noon Saturday; closed Sunday 6
Hours waste can arrive 7 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. weekdays; until 11:30 a.m. Saturday 6
Truck trips Added diesel truck trips capped at 149 a day for one year, with quarterly reports 12
Where waste is handled All inside the building; covered loads only; trucks may not line up on Kondelin Road, Magnolia Avenue or Essex Avenue 9, 10, 21, 22
Residents Residential recycling drop off limited to Saturdays, 7 a.m. to noon 13
Leachate (liquid from stored waste) Double walled tanks with leak alarms; none to the city sewage plant 31, 32
Hazardous materials and asbestos A plan approved by the board before it can operate 30
Road cleanup A $10,000 bond renewed yearly, and a magnet sweep truck on Kondelin and Magnolia 25, 26
Oversight An independent inspector for two years, noise testing at four spots near neighbors, a 24 hour contact line 33, 34, 35, 36

If the company sells or leases the site, condition 3 says the conditions follow any successor. The board was still working out in October how to make that stick, including whether to tie it to the deed.

The proposal ledger: what was asked, what was approved, what is pending

Read left to right: the project as first filed in 2023, as cut back in 2024, as the Board of Health approved it in 2025, and the changes now before other boards. Figures that disagree between city documents are shown as they appear.

Original, 2023Revised, June 2024Approved, June 18, 2025Pending or proposed now, 2026
Waste acceptedState environmental filing (Feb. 2023): construction waste and municipal solid waste. Aug. 2023 application: construction waste plus presorted recyclables.Construction waste only. No municipal solid waste.Construction waste only. No yard waste, food waste, municipal solid waste or compostables (condition 8).No change found in the records we read.
Tons a day350 in the state filing. 325 (101,400 a year) in the Aug. 2023 application.270Hard cap of 270 (condition 7).The city reviewer's Feb. 2026 draft still cites 325. The mismatch is unexplained in the records we read.
Building15,750 square feet in the state filing. 14,200 in the Aug. 2023 application.11,800 square feet, fully enclosed. About 4,400 square feet of ledge to be removed behind it.Built as shown on the submitted plans, and the approval binds any successor (condition 3).Updated plans dated July 7, 2026 are on file with the Conservation Commission. Board minutes mention a possible second tank for liquid waste and a small mechanical room; we have not found them on a plan.
Added truck trips140 a day (70 in, 70 out) in the application. The city's reviewer said the number should be higher, about 182, in Nov. 2023.136 added average daily trips, all diesel (68 each way).No more than 149 added average daily diesel trips over a year, with quarterly reports (condition 12). Reservation system (9). No lines of trucks on public streets (10).Supplemental traffic study filed Nov. 2025. On Oct. 8, 2026 the board ordered the unanswered walking and biking part of condition 18 answered.
HoursNot compared in this review.Not compared in this review.Weekdays 6 a.m. to 6 p.m., Saturday 7 a.m. to noon, closed Sunday. Trucks may unload weekdays 7 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. and Saturday until 11:30 a.m. (condition 6).No change proposed in the records we read.
Property linesNot compared in this review.Not compared in this review.Waivers noted: 75 feet from the north line and 50 feet from the west line.Zoning Board approved a variance for a fence relocation on July 9, 2026, 5 to 0.
Stormwater and wetlandsNot compared in this review.Not compared in this review.Plan includes a treatment device for runoff. Company must file a wetlands notice of intent and apply to the city to connect to the storm drain system (conditions 14 and 15).Notice of intent filed Apr. 2026 (stormwater, repaving, fence). Continued Oct. 7, Oct. 21 and Nov. 4. Next hearing Nov. 18. A fresh stormwater report and construction plan were filed Oct. 22 and 23.
SignsNot applicable.Not applicable.Signs must direct trucks along the approved traffic flow (condition 10).A sign request went to the EDIC on Aug. 11, 2026.

Sources: state environmental notification form and the company's June 10, 2024 revised project description; the company's Aug. 11, 2023 site suitability application; Board of Health decision, June 18, 2025; city reviewer memos; Zoning Board and Conservation Commission records; city project page, all linked below.

The timeline and the decision points

The dates below show how a 2017 recycling drop off became a 37 condition approval, and what is still open. Diamonds mark the decision points.

◆ Decision point● Filing, hearing or report● Next on the calendar

  1. About 2017Eastern Waste Services takes over a recycling drop off at 24 Kondelin Road.
  2. 2017 to 2022The company takes in mixed construction waste without a site assignment or state solid waste permit, the decision says.
  3. Mar. 10, 2022MassDEP consent order. The company must stop taking and storing construction waste.
  4. Mar. 27, 2023Decision pointThe state environmental office rules a full impact report is not required.
  5. Aug. 11, 2023Site suitability application filed: 325 tons a day.
  6. Oct. 17, 2023The Gloucester EDIC, the public body that built the industrial park, writes to the state that the site is neither suitable nor compatible with its vision for the park.
  7. Nov. 16, 2023Board of Health hears its outside reviewer, who says the company's trip estimate looks low and the truck turns on site are tight.
  8. June 10, 2024Revised project: 270 tons a day and an 11,800 square foot building.
  9. Apr. 3, 2025Decision pointMassDEP issues a positive determination of suitability. The Board of Health holds the final local say.
  10. May 7 to June 4, 2025Seven hearing sessions. Manchester-by-the-Sea, the EDIC and abutters take part as parties. Manchester asks the state for a full impact report on May 22.
  11. June 2, 2025The EDIC votes unanimously to send a letter supporting the site, with conditions, reversing its 2023 position.
  12. June 12, 2025Decision pointBoard of Health deliberates. A motion to approve the application as written, with no conditions, is rejected unanimously. Members then work through conditions.
  13. June 18, 2025Decision pointThe board votes to approve the site assignment with 37 conditions. The motion carries; at least one member voted no. Had it failed, the board would have moved to deny.
  14. About late July 2025The 30 day window to appeal closes. No appeal was filed, the city solicitor's tracker says.
  15. Nov. 2025 to Feb. 2026Supplemental traffic study filed, then the city reviewer's draft finds trucks fill both lanes under the Magnolia Avenue bridge.
  16. Apr. 27, 2026Draft waste ban compliance plan submitted Apr. 8. Wetlands notice of intent filed for stormwater work, repaving and a fence.
  17. July 9, 2026Zoning Board approves the fence variance, 5 to 0.
  18. Oct. 8, 2026Decision pointBoard of Health accepts the blasting study (condition 19), reopens part of condition 18 and sends the Conservation Commission a memo listing five conditions its outside review skipped.
  19. Wed., Nov. 18, 2026NextConservation Commission hearing on the notice of intent, 5:30 p.m., Rose Baker Center, 6 Manuel F. Lewis St. The commission continued it on Oct. 7, Oct. 21 and Nov. 4.
  20. Mon., Nov. 30, 2026NextBoard of Health Eastern Waste Services subcommittee, 4:30 p.m., second floor conference room, 3 Pond Road (City Hall Annex), according to the city calendar. No agenda was posted as of Nov. 15.
  21. Not yet scheduledCommission's written order, the state permit to operate, and the Board of Health's sign off on the remaining conditions. None is on an agenda we have seen.

Where the 37 conditions stand

The approval was the first step. The conditions are what the company still has to prove.

On May 7, 2026 the company told the Board of Health that 4 conditions were in compliance, 2 completed, 8 in process and 23 not yet due. Those counts are the company's own report, not a finding by the board. Since then:

  • Condition 19, the blasting study, was accepted Oct. 8, with the right to reopen it if later permits show blasting is not feasible. The plan needs about 4,400 square feet of ledge removed at the south end of the site.
  • Condition 18, the traffic study, was reopened Oct. 8. A board member found that the study never answered the question on people walking and biking on Magnolia and Essex avenues.
  • Condition 20, soil testing, is outstanding. The company's attorney said Oct. 8 that a licensed site professional was hired for a first review and that an older 2017 report had been found. The health director told the subcommittee Oct. 6 that she found no past testing to use as a baseline.
  • Condition 30, hazardous materials and asbestos, has a draft plan on file but the board has not yet approved it.
  • Condition 12, truck counts, requires a year of current truck trip data. The subcommittee said Oct. 6 that logs since last July had not been turned in.
  • The fence: the company reported a city cease and desist letter on April 16 over a fence on city property. On Oct. 8 its attorney said the Zoning Board of Appeals had approved a new fence on the property line and a corrected decision was waiting to be recorded.

The Board of Health has said it cannot add conditions now. It can only enforce the ones in the decision. A condition can lead to rescission, suspension or changes if it is not met (condition 2).

Trucks and the Magnolia Avenue railroad bridge

Every heavy truck has to take one route. The map marks the railroad underpass and the second railroad bridge on it, the school and the Route 128 ramps.

Truck route and bridges

The only way in or out for heavy trucks, from Kondelin Road to Route 128. Tap a pin for details.

  1. Station site, 24 Kondelin Road. Trucks leave the site and travel Kondelin Road to Magnolia Avenue.
  2. Kondelin Road and Magnolia Avenue. Turn north. Heavier vehicles cannot use Magnolia Avenue south of Kondelin Road (2.5 ton limit).
  3. Railroad underpass on Magnolia Avenue. 22 feet wide, in an S-curve. The decision found the company's study did not model two heavy trucks meeting here. OpenStreetMap lists a 13 foot 6 inch height limit for this segment (not confirmed in the hearing record).
  4. Magnolia Avenue meets Essex Avenue (Route 133); rail bridge over Essex Avenue. A second railroad bridge is mapped over Essex Avenue here (OpenStreetMap). It was not discussed in the hearing record we read. Bus stops and the West Gloucester commuter rail station are nearby.
  5. Essex Avenue and Concord Street. One of the eight intersections in the company's traffic study.
  6. West Parish School, Concord Street. The decision says the company's study did not look at school bus stops on Magnolia and Essex avenues or school bus traffic to this school.
  7. Route 128 ramps. Outbound transfer trailers were assumed to head to disposal sites south and west through this interchange.

Route and bridges: OpenStreetMap contributors (road lines and railroad bridge positions are approximate). Route description: Board of Health decision, June 18, 2025, and the company's traffic impact and access study (Exhibit 1C). Aerial: MassGIS 2025.

The state decision caps added diesel truck trips at 149 a day. The company's traffic study estimated 136 added trips. The city's reviewer wrote in January 2025 that the 2023 estimate was 70 vehicles in and 70 out, so trips appear to be counted one way. That would be roughly 75 round trips, not 149 loads. We did not find a count of loads in the documents we read.

The city's reviewer, February 2026 draft on the supplemental traffic study 389 to 538heavy vehicles a day on that stretch, about 38 percent more
Trucks fill the lane under the bridge.Large trucks take up more of the road under the railroad bridge on Magnolia Avenue. Transfer trailers fully cross the lane even at 10 miles an hour.
Sight distance is short for trucks heading north.It is enough for trucks heading south and not enough for trucks heading north.
One crash near the bridge in five years.Police records show one crash near the bridge in that time.
The fixes accepted are signs and a speed advisory.The reviewer accepted the company's proposed fixes: a 10 mile an hour advisory speed both ways, road narrowing signs, curve and alignment signs.

An advisory speed asks drivers to slow down. It is not a posted limit. Source: Weston and Sampson peer review of the supplemental traffic study, draft, Feb. 5, 2026.

The Board of Health's decision said it was concerned about the limits of the traffic study but did not find a danger to public safety. In January 2025 the reviewer also noted that the company had not given the share of trips using each Route 128 ramp, and that most trips other than transfer trailers were expected to use Essex Avenue, Concord Street and Route 128, with more of the construction waste trips possibly heading west and north.

Clearance, strikes, the road and who pays

Trucks pass under the railroad bridges, not over them, so the issues are clearance, lane width and bridge strikes, plus wear on the road itself. Two questions the record leaves open: whether the company would pay for signs, markings and repairs, and who owns and inspects the bridges.

  • Clearance and strikes. We found no study of bridge strikes or of the clearance under the underpass or the Essex Avenue rail bridge for the trucks that would use them, and no strike history. The signed height at the Magnolia Avenue underpass is 13 feet 6 inches, according to expert testimony on May 29, 2025. The company's traffic study measured intersection delays, sight distance and crash data. Condition 18 adds modeling of trucks passing in the S-curve, school bus stops, walkers and cyclists, local crash data and a look at traffic calming. None of those items is a pavement analysis or a bridge strike review. Condition 18 refers to the Magnolia Avenue structure as the MBTA underpass, but the record we read does not say who owns or inspects either bridge. The city does limit weight elsewhere on the route: Magnolia Avenue south of Kondelin Road has a 2.5 ton limit.
  • Money for roads. The conditions require a $10,000 payment bond, renewed yearly, so the city can pay to clean up debris on nearby roads (condition 26), and a magnet sweep truck on Kondelin Road and Magnolia Avenue (condition 25). The company's traffic study found no planned roadway improvements and, as far as we found, offered none. The traffic calming analysis in condition 18 could lead to proposals, but nothing in the record says who would pay for them.
  • The $10,000 figure has no cost estimate behind it. The record does not say whether it is enough. It contains no estimate of what debris removal, extra sweeping or road repair would cost the city, and no explanation of how the figure was chosen. It comes from the city's Director of Public Works, who asked for it in pre-filed testimony on May 12, 2025, and he asked for it alongside weekly street sweeping by the company. The decision orders a daily magnet sweep truck instead (condition 25). The bond is a yearly ceiling on what the city can draw, not a measure of cost, and condition 26 does not say what happens when a cleanup costs more. A payment bond is a guarantee, usually bought from a surety company, that money will be available if the company does not pay. We have not seen the bond itself, so its terms, and whether the city would deal with the company or with a surety, are not known.
The city's Public Works director on debris and cost

In pre-filed testimony sent to the state on May 12, 2025, the city's Director of Public Works said construction and demolition debris has littered Kondelin Road, and that people have dumped loads beside the road when they could not get into the facility. The city tried to identify them with a camera in the trees at the site. In one instance, he testified, a person dumped debris, saw the camera, returned to the site and cut down the tree to destroy it.

He said enforcing litter rules is difficult and time consuming and costs the city a great deal. He asked the board to make the company sweep the full length of Kondelin Road weekly and keep a $10,000 bond so the city could pay for cleanup on 48 hours' notice.

Who pays. The decision does not explain why a $10,000 yearly ceiling was chosen or what happens when a cleanup costs more. We found no estimate of the city's costs for cleanup, enforcement or road repair. The testimony ties the dumping to people who could not get into the facility. It does not say who they were, and it does not find that the company dumped the debris.

Source: pre-filed testimony of the city's Director of Public Works, May 12, 2025; decision conditions 25 and 26.

Questions that still need answers

The public records we read could not answer the questions below. This story is built only from public documents, and we did not contact the offices or the company, so each question stays open until the office that holds the answer responds. They are grouped by who could answer them.

Can the approved plan change?

Who can answer

Gloucester Board of Health and its subcommittee

Questions
  • Could the approved plan change, with a smaller building, a new owner or a new tenant, without a new hearing?
  • Which tonnage governs: 270 tons a day, or the 325 in the reviewer's draft?
  • When are the truck logs, soil results and hazardous materials plan due, and who reviews them?

Wetlands and the water that leaves the site

Who can answer

Gloucester Conservation Commission, Nov. 18

Questions
  • Will the commission issue an order on Nov. 18, and what does its outside reviewer say about the conditions it did not examine?
  • Does the filing address the wooded swamp that drains toward Manchester-by-the-Sea?
  • How is the fence on city property settled?

Is anything happening on the site today?

Who can answer

Gloucester Building Department and the mayor's office

Questions
  • Has any site work or demolition permit been issued while the building permit is not filed?
  • Is construction waste coming in now, and under what authority?
  • What would the city receive in taxes or fees, and what would road wear and enforcement cost it?

What is the benefit to Gloucester?

Who can answer

City Council, the Mayor's office, the EDIC and the company

Questions
  • If the company pays property tax and nothing more, what is the benefit to Gloucester of allowing the site?
  • Is the company investing anything beyond taxes in roads, safety, cleanliness or infrastructure, or has it offered to?
  • Why has the benefit to Gloucester not been addressed in the record, by the board, the city or the company?
  • If the answer is nothing beyond jobs that already exist and taxes, what would justify the cost and risk to neighbors?

Why Gloucester, and not somewhere else?

Who can answer

City Council, Planning Board, the Mayor's office and the company

Questions
  • Would an affluent community like Wellesley, Concord or Cambridge ever allow a private transfer station inside its borders? If not, why is West Gloucester being asked?
  • Did the company look at a site in any of those towns, in Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex, or in Georgetown, which already has a large waste transfer station? Or only at property it already owns?
  • What would those communities require before saying yes, such as investment, fees or infrastructure, and has Gloucester asked for the same?
  • Can the company buy or lease property somewhere else, away from a wooded swamp and a one road route? Why is it proposing the site it already owns?
  • Does Gloucester ask as much of the company as a wealthier town would, and do its residents get the same protection and representation?

What happens if the site is sold?

Who can answer

City Solicitor, Board of Health, MassDEP and the company

Questions
  • What restrictions does the city place on a future sale? Can another company buy the site and keep operating what this company does?
  • Do the site assignment, the 37 conditions and the bond pass automatically to a new owner, and who tells the city?
  • Could the city require that the approval end on a sale, so a new owner must apply again and show what it will invest?
  • If the company will not invest in the community, what keeps the approval from being flipped to another operator?

Is the underpass ready for 538 heavy vehicles?

Who can answer

Public Works, Police, the railroad owner and the company

Questions
  • Transfer trailers fully cross the lane even at 10 miles an hour, so how would two trucks meeting under the bridge work, and who would give way?
  • What warning signs, height signs and lane markings are at the underpass today, and are the lines faded? Who repaints them?
  • Will Magnolia Avenue's markings and signs be upgraded before the first loaded truck, and who pays?
  • Sight distance is not enough for trucks heading north. What stops a driver meeting oncoming traffic on the corner?
  • The accepted fixes are an advisory speed and signs. What happens if drivers ignore them?
  • If the company's study comes back saying Gloucester needs to improve the road, who pays: the company, taxpayers or the state?
  • What would heavier traffic on the route do to home values along it, and has anyone asked?

The bridges and the road

Who can answer

Public Works, the railroad bridge owner and the Mayor

Questions
  • Who owns and inspects the Magnolia Avenue underpass and the Essex Avenue rail bridge?
  • Do inspection reports exist, has either bridge ever been struck, and was the clearance under each checked against the trucks that would use it?
  • What warning signs, height signs and lane markings are in place, and who maintains them?
  • Will the city ask the company to pay for traffic calming, signs, markings or repairs?
  • Was a cost estimate ever done for debris cleanup, sweeping and road repair, and is a $10,000 bond enough?
  • What are the bond's terms, and who would the city deal with to collect?

State permits and inspections

Who can answer

MassDEP Northeast Regional Office

Questions
  • Has the company applied to construct or operate, and under which facility class and recovery rate?
  • Has the state inspected the site or enforced the 2022 order since it was issued?
  • Where would leftover waste go, and does the draft waste ban plan meet the load checking rules?

Where the loads come from

Who can answer

The company, through its attorney

Questions
  • What share of loads would come from each Cape Ann town, and from outside it?
  • What share of trucks would use each route?
  • Is the company willing to cap distance, share truck logs publicly, or help pay for road work?
  • Would it add jobs, and what property tax or fees would it pay the city?

The company's record

Who can answer

MassDEP, EPA's regional office and the company

Questions
  • The federal record for 24 Kondelin Road lists hazardous waste code F037, a refinery oil, water and solids separation sludge. Where did it come from, how much was there, and since when?
  • Has the Board of Health, its reviewer or MassDEP reviewed that registration, and why is it in the company's record?
  • Will the pending hazardous materials plan (condition 30) address it?
  • The 2022 order set $20,000 in six installments and suspended $12,337 for a year after the last payment. Were the installments paid on time, was the 60 day certification of cleanup filed, and was the suspended amount ever demanded?
  • The state portal lists the last MassDEP inspection on Oct. 31, 2023. Has the site been inspected since then?
  • Where did the two reportable truck crashes in the past 24 months happen, and were any near Kondelin Road?

What Manchester-by-the-Sea wants now

Who can answer

Manchester-by-the-Sea Board of Health and public works director

Questions
  • What is the town's position on the 2025 approval and the wetlands filing?
  • Will the town speak on Nov. 18?
  • Does the town see any effect on Wolf Trap Brook or its wells?

The company's side: the Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that it did not expect adverse effects on public health and safety, the board found no adverse effect on wildlife or open space, and the building would be fully enclosed with filtered ventilation.

How to take part, for or against

Nothing here is final. Several approvals are still ahead, and each has a way for residents to be heard.

1. Tell the people who vote or decide. Supporters and opponents can write or call any of them. Short, specific messages that say what you want and why carry the most weight.

Who Why they matter Contact
Your ward councilor The City Council decides the zoning special permit. Ward 5 voters use West Parish Elementary (West Gloucester) and the Magnolia library as polling places. Confirm your own ward on the city's ward and precinct map or with the City Clerk, 9 Dale Ave. Ward 1 Scott Memhard, [email protected], (978) 283-1955. Ward 2 Dylan Benson, [email protected], (978) 675-5597. Ward 3 Marjorie Grace, [email protected], (978) 771-2237. Ward 4 Frank Margiotta, [email protected], (978) 527-8469. Ward 5 Sean Nolan, Council Vice President, [email protected], (978) 375-8381
City councilors at large They vote on the same permit and serve every resident Jason Grow, [email protected], (978) 884-7964. Tony Gross, Council President, [email protected], (978) 491-8898. Patti-Ann Page, [email protected], (978) 590-0190. Hannah Kimberley, [email protected], (978) 996-3850
State representative Andrew Tarr (5th Essex). State lawmakers can press MassDEP and ask about the state permit [email protected], (617) 722-2014, State House Room 39
State senator Bruce E. Tarr (First Essex and Middlesex) [email protected], (617) 722-1600, State House Room 308

Not sure who represents your address? The state's Find My Legislator tool answers it from a street address. Contact details come from the city's City Council page and the Massachusetts Legislature's website.

2. Speak or write at the public steps still ahead.

  • Conservation Commission, Wednesday, Nov. 18, 5:30 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well, 6 Manuel F. Lewis St., and on Zoom. The wetlands filing, number 028-3129, is listed as continued to that date. Written comments go to the commission through the city, and the project's public comment folder is linked from the city's project page. Confirm the time on the city's agenda page.
  • Board of Health and its Eastern Waste Services subcommittee, which meets before each full board meeting. The city calendar lists its next meeting for Mon., Nov. 30 at 4:30 p.m. at 3 Pond Road. Manchester-by-the-Sea's Board of Health is on the company's notice list for the wetlands filing.
  • MassDEP. After the company applies for the state construction permit, the department issues a draft decision and takes public comment for 30 days, and it can hold a hearing. Comments can address the air, water, traffic and waste handling questions that apply to the permit.
  • City Council and Planning Board. Zoning approval and site plan review each require a public hearing, with notice to abutters.
  • Every City Council meeting has a public comment period. The council meets the second and fourth Tuesdays at 6:30 p.m. in City Hall.

Earlier coverage: Gloucester health board accepts Kondelin Road blasting study (Oct. 17); Gloucester health panel to review blasting study (Oct. 5); Conservation Commission, Nov. 4 (Nov. 6). The Sargent Street road plan on the same Nov. 18 agenda is in our Haffner's Way series.

Write to your officials, for or against

Use the tool below to build an email to your city councilors, state representative or state senator. You choose your position, who gets it and your reasons.

Correction: An earlier version of this story said the record showed no fee figure for the city. At its June 12, 2025 meeting the Board of Health discussed a quarterly community impact fee of 25 cents a ton that Eastern Waste Services had offered in its closing materials, according to our review of the transcript. The board kept the $10,000 payment bond instead, and the site assignment decision requires no per ton fee or host community agreement. Other approvals are still pending. (Nov. 16, 2026)

Sources

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.