Haffner's Way, Part 3: What is in the ground, the wetland next door and the outside review
Records describe nine feet of fill, buried trash and metals, petroleum and PCBs in the top four feet, beside a wetland. The Conservation Commission voted 4 to 0 for an outside review.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Before any road is built on the Sargent Street site, the ground has to be dug, graded and drained. This third report looks at what the records say is in that ground, the wetland beside it and the outside review the Conservation Commission wants.
The land was a junkyard, then a recycling center, then a junkyard again. A cleanup in 2002 left contamination in place under a recorded land use restriction. Energy North Inc. is the applicant for the subdivision; Sargent Street Corp. owns the land.
The restriction allows industrial use only if the pavement and soil stay intact. It bars homes, schools, daycare and recreation. Building a road means breaking that cap.
What the records say is in the ground
| Source | What it found |
|---|---|
| Cleanup records | Petroleum hydrocarbons, PAHs, arsenic, lead and zinc |
| Later work | Metals, PAHs, petroleum, PCBs and some volatile compounds, mostly in the top four feet |
| 2023 Atlas borings | About 9 feet of fill over organic soil |
| 2026 test pits | Trash, car parts, tires, brick, concrete, rebar and pipe. No native soil in several pits. Refusal on buried slabs or bedrock |
| Groundwater | About 4 to 4.6 feet below the surface |
The depth to groundwater matters for the single stormwater basin. Water has to soak into fill that is a few feet above the water table and mixed with debris.
The state cleanup rules
Because the site is under the Massachusetts Contingency Plan, moving more than 20 cubic yards of contaminated soil would trigger a release abatement measure plan filed with MassDEP. The company's attorney put the figure at 30 cubic yards at the hearing, and we have not reconciled the two. The Commission's outside review will not do independent site testing, since the state process governs testing.
The wetland and the Conservation Commission
The Conservation Commission filing is Notice of Intent 028-3159. It covers a road, stormwater system and utilities inside the 100 foot buffer zone of a bordering vegetated wetland listed at 95,637 square feet. No buildings are proposed. The stated purpose is to divide the land so it can be marketed and eventually developed.
On Oct. 7, commissioners voted 4 to 0 for a peer review. They asked for:
- Proof that infiltration basins can work in contaminated soil, and that the steep road drains properly.
- Testing of all soil under the road, whatever the amount dug.
- An independent monitor for excavation work.
- The same groundwater recharge before and after, including a nearby wetland under restoration.
- Copies of every MassDEP filing, and yearly stormwater maintenance reports.
- Shielded, wildlife friendly lighting and plantings between the road and the wetland.
The Commission then continued the case without a hearing on Oct. 21 and Nov. 4, to Nov. 18.
Questions for the Conservation Commission
These are the questions we think the Commission should answer about the ground and the wetland. Part 7 has the questions for every group.
Conservation CommissionReviews work near the wetland · 10 questions
- Can infiltration basins work in fill with groundwater 4 to 4.6 feet down?Part 3
- Will all soil under the road be tested, whatever the amount dug?Part 3
- Who will monitor excavation independently?Part 3
- How will recharge to the wetland stay the same before and after construction?Part 3
- How does the road affect the nearby wetland that is being restored?Part 3
- Will the Commission get copies of every MassDEP filing?Part 3
- How will stormwater systems be maintained, and will yearly reports be filed?Part 3
- What shielded, wildlife friendly lighting and plantings will separate the road from the wetland?PositivePart 3
- Does the filing change if the start of the road moves after Planning Board comments?Part 3
- Could a cleaner, better monitored site improve the wetland's edge over time?PositivePart 3
Mark your calendar
The wetland case is expected on Dec. 2. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda continues its hearing to Dec. 3.
Dates and times come from the City of Gloucester calendar and agendas, checked Nov. 17. The Conservation Commission's revised Nov. 18 agenda asks to continue the Haffner's Way case to Dec. 2, and the city calendar lists a Conservation Commission meeting that day at 5:30 p.m. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda (5 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well, second floor conference room) lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." The city had not yet listed a Dec. 3 meeting, time or place. Call the Planning Division at (978) 325-5230 or check the city calendar before you go. End times are placeholders. Our guide to what to ask is Part 7.
Update, Nov. 17, 2026: The city posted the Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda. It lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." Anything in this story that says the board takes up the case on Nov. 19, or that its date is not yet posted, is out of date.
What we don't know yet
- Who the peer reviewer is, the scope and the cost.
- Whether any soil beyond the 2023 and 2026 samples will be tested before approval.
- Whether the site lies inside the Watershed Protection Overlay (Part 5 explains what it would bar).
Correction: An earlier version of this story gave the place of the Planning Board's Nov. 19 Haffner's Way hearing as Gloucester City Hall, and said the dates came from a community group's post. The city has not yet posted the Nov. 19 agenda, which will give the place. The dates and times come from City of Gloucester agendas, and the story now says so. (Nov. 14, 2026)
Sources
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.