Haffner's Way, Part 2: How the Sargent Street plan changed, and the fuel tank layout still in the file
A 2023 layout showed 190,000 gallons of fuel tanks. It was never originally filed and is part of the 2026 application, so it was not withdrawn. A variance and a lot combination were, and the road has been redrawn three times. Nothing in writing says what the lots are for.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
The Sargent Street site has been before Gloucester boards for years, and the plan has changed shape more than once. Energy North Inc. now seeks approval of a private road and two industrial lots with no named use. In 2023 a layout for the same land showed 190,000 gallons of fuel tanks. This second report traces what was filed, changed and withdrawn.
Dates come from city meeting records and the application in the Planning Board's shared folder. Where the city's files are not posted, we say so.
The company's attorney told the Planning Board on Oct. 1 that the fuel plan "was an old plan" and is "off the table." That statement is not in writing, and the 2023 report is still part of the application.
A land use restriction (an Activity and Use Limitation) is recorded on the site. A March 5, 2002 filing classifies the cleanup under state rules (release tracking numbers 3-20653 and 3-10981). The restriction bars homes, schools, daycare and recreation, and requires paved areas to stay intact.
A geotechnical report for Energy North shows a layout with 80,000 gallons of heating oil, 20,000 gallons of diesel and three 30,000 gallon propane tanks, 190,000 gallons in all. It was never originally filed with the city. It is part of Energy North's Aug. 13, 2026 filing, so it was not withdrawn.
An Approval Not Required plan is filed to combine five parcels.
The Zoning Board of Appeals opens a hearing for the site and continues it to March 27.
The Zoning Board continues the case to April 24.
The variance request is withdrawn, 4 to 0.
The lot combination plan is withdrawn.
A preliminary subdivision plan shows an unnamed street and two stormwater basins.
The plan is revised: a 740 foot "School House Road Extension" and one waiver.
The Planning Board gives preliminary approval with conditions in about 11 minutes, with no public comment.
The definitive plan is filed as Haffner's Way: 753 feet of road, two lots, one basin.
The hearing is not held because of a noticing error.
17 people speak and none support the plan. The Board votes unanimously to order an outside peer review, and a parcel on Millett Street is dropped. The hearing is continued to Nov. 5.
The Conservation Commission votes 4 to 0 for a peer review.
The Commission continues the case without a hearing, to Nov. 18.
Conservation Commission, 5:30 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well.
Planning Board, 5 p.m. The board continued the hearing to this date on Nov. 5. The place is on the city's agenda, which the city posts 48 hours ahead.
The three versions of the road
| Version | Date | Name | Length | Basins | Waivers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preliminary | Dec. 2025 | Unnamed Street | Not stated here | 2 | Not stated here |
| Revised | March 3, 2026 | School House Road Extension | 740 feet | Not stated here | 1 |
| Definitive | Aug. 13, 2026 | Haffner's Way | 753 feet | 1 | 1 in the letter, 4 described at the hearing |
Why the history matters
Each version asked for less than the last, and none named a use. The first plan with a use, in 2023, showed fuel storage. The question for the Board and the public is whether the use stays unspecified while the road and lots are approved. Part 4 shows how residents framed that question, and Part 5 explains what limits are available.

The April 16 preliminary approval memo and the Zoning Board case file are not in the Planning Board's shared folder, so details of those two steps rest on meeting records.
Questions for the Planning Board
The plan has changed more than once. These are the questions we think the Planning Board should answer, and that residents can ask. Part 7 has the questions for every group.
Planning BoardDecides the road and the lots · 10 questions
- What use is planned for each lot, and will the applicant put it in writing?Part 1
- Will the applicant record a deed restriction that limits use?PositivePart 5
- Which waivers are requested, and why is each one needed?Part 1
- How does a 753 foot dead end road with a 120 foot cul de sac serve fire trucks and emergency access?Part 1
- What will the outside peer review cover, who is the reviewer and when will it be public?Part 3
- Does the traffic study reflect the uses that could be built, not only a light industrial stand in?Part 1
- What conditions can site plan review attach once a use is named?PositivePart 5
- Can approval of the road carry conditions on use, hours or truck routes?PositivePart 5
- Is the site inside the Watershed Protection Overlay District, and what follows if it is?Part 5
- Will the hearing stay open for written answers to the public's questions?Part 4
Mark your calendar
The wetland case is expected on Dec. 2. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda continues its hearing to Dec. 3.
Dates and times come from the City of Gloucester calendar and agendas, checked Nov. 17. The Conservation Commission's revised Nov. 18 agenda asks to continue the Haffner's Way case to Dec. 2, and the city calendar lists a Conservation Commission meeting that day at 5:30 p.m. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda (5 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well, second floor conference room) lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." The city had not yet listed a Dec. 3 meeting, time or place. Call the Planning Division at (978) 325-5230 or check the city calendar before you go. End times are placeholders. Our guide to what to ask is Part 7.
Update, Nov. 17, 2026: The city posted the Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda. It lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." Anything in this story that says the board takes up the case on Nov. 19, or that its date is not yet posted, is out of date.
What we don't know yet
- The reasons recorded for the 2025 withdrawals.
- Why the road grew from 740 to 753 feet between March and August.
- Where the Planning Board meets on Nov. 19. It continued the hearing to that date on Nov. 5, and the city had not posted that night's agenda as of Nov. 14.
Correction: An earlier version of this story listed the 2023 fuel layout in the timeline without saying that it was never originally filed with the city. The layout comes from a geotechnical report that is part of Energy North's Aug. 13, 2026 filing, so it was not withdrawn. The headline and summary were also changed so they no longer suggest the plan moved from fuel tanks to a road. (Nov. 13, 2026)
Correction: An earlier version of this story gave the place of the Planning Board's Nov. 19 Haffner's Way hearing as Gloucester City Hall, and said the dates came from a community group's post. The city has not yet posted the Nov. 19 agenda, which will give the place. The dates and times come from City of Gloucester agendas, and the story now says so. (Nov. 14, 2026)
Sources
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.