ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Tuesday, November 17, 2026Get the Morning Current

Know Before It's Decided

Haffner's Way, Part 4: What 17 speakers and 17 letters asked the Planning Board

Fifteen of 17 letters oppose the plan and none of the speakers supported it. Eleven letters name fuel tanks. Nearly all ask what will be built.

Illustration of overlapping speech bubbles with a question mark, labeled Haffner's Way Part 4.
What residents asked at and after the Oct. 1 hearing. Cape Ann Current illustration

Trust Check: Checked against public records

17speakers at the Oct. 1 hearing
0in favor
17written comments on file by Oct. 15
15of those oppose
11of the 17 letters name the fuel tanks
3city councilors wrote as private citizens

Seventeen people spoke to the Planning Board on Oct. 1 about a road and two lots that Energy North Inc. wants to build off Sargent Street. None spoke in favor. Seventeen written comments were on file by Oct. 15. This fourth report sorts what they asked, without naming residents.

Fifteen of the 17 letters oppose the plan. One poses eight questions without taking a position. One, from the Cleveland Street Committee dated Sept. 15, said it would accept redevelopment only with no connection to Sargent Street, a security fence and perimeter trees. A neighbor has since said the neighborhood does not support the project and that the letter was withdrawn. The public file through Oct. 15 holds no written withdrawal. Three city councilors wrote as private citizens.

Said on Oct. 1
"I can tell you definitively and commit on the record that we're not going to build a bulk fuel plant there. That plan is, it was an old plan, it's off the table, that's not going to happen."
Attorney for Energy North, Planning Board hearing, Oct. 1, 2026
Still in the filing

190,000 gallons

of tanks described in a 2023 geotechnical report for Energy North: 80,000 gallons of heating oil, 20,000 of diesel and three 30,000 gallon propane tanks. The report is Attachment B of the application filed Aug. 13, 2026.

Nothing is in writing from the company on what it will do instead.

What people asked about

ContaminationThe junkyard and landfill history, fill of unknown origin, dust if the ground is opened, where excavated soil would go, and whether the city should test.
Fuel storage safetyFire, explosion, evacuation on narrow streets, train vibration, tanker trucks and vapors. Eleven of the 17 letters name the tanks.
Unknown useApproving a road and lots with no named use, and the point that review is happening in pieces.
Traffic and trucksA study built on nine trucks a day, winter tanker traffic, and a road shared with the apartments, bank, YMCA and shopping center.
Stormwater and wetlandsAn infiltration basin in fill with a shallow water table, and overflow to unnamed downstream drainage.
Environmental justiceA state designated environmental justice neighborhood with no analysis filed, and the city's earlier promise of no more development after Gloucester Crossing.
Hours, noise, light, odorNo stated operating, construction or delivery hours.
Property values and insuranceHome values and the cost of coverage near fuel storage.
Notice and processTwo abutters said they never received the city's notice. Others asked for written answers and for the hearing to stay open.
AlternativesDeclare the land unbuildable until cleanup, add a pedestrian path to Gloucester Crossing, or use a different site such as the Blackburn Industrial Park.
Support with conditionsOne committee backs redevelopment if there is no Sargent Street connection, a security fence and perimeter trees.

What the applicant said

Energy North's attorney and consultants responded that contamination would be handled under the land use restriction, a licensed site professional and a MassDEP plan. They said no wetland would be altered, stormwater would slightly reduce peak flows, and traffic from a light industrial build out would be minimal. The attorney also said the company will not build a bulk fuel plant. Nothing is in writing.

The Planning Board then voted unanimously to order an outside peer review. The Conservation Commission voted 4 to 0 on Oct. 7 for its own.

The one question

Most comments circled the same point: what will be built? The application does not say. Part 5 asks whether the Planning Board can do anything about that.

Questions from residents and neighbors

These are the questions residents and neighbors can ask, drawn from what was asked on Oct. 1 and in the letters. Part 7 has the questions for every group.

Residents and neighborsHomes on Gale, Sargent and Millett streets and nearby · 10 questions
  1. What use is planned, and will it be in writing before any approval?Part 1
  2. How will dust and soil be controlled near homes during construction?Part 3
  3. What hours will construction, deliveries and operations run?Part 4
  4. Which streets will trucks use?Part 1
  5. How were abutters notified, and will anyone who missed notice be renoticed?Part 4
  6. Who tests nearby soil and groundwater, and where are the results posted?Part 3
  7. What conditions would make this acceptable to the neighborhood?PositivePart 4
  8. Could part of the site become a pedestrian path to Gloucester Crossing?PositivePart 4
  9. What would a fence, trees and buffer look like along the homes?PositivePart 4
  10. Where can I read the record and send a comment?Part 6

Mark your calendar

The wetland case is expected on Dec. 2. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda continues its hearing to Dec. 3.

Dec.2
Conservation Commission: Haffner Way
Wednesday, 5:30 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well
Dec.3
Planning Board: Haffner's Way subdivision hearing (continued)
Thursday. The city has not yet posted the time or place.

Dates and times come from the City of Gloucester calendar and agendas, checked Nov. 17. The Conservation Commission's revised Nov. 18 agenda asks to continue the Haffner's Way case to Dec. 2, and the city calendar lists a Conservation Commission meeting that day at 5:30 p.m. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda (5 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well, second floor conference room) lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." The city had not yet listed a Dec. 3 meeting, time or place. Call the Planning Division at (978) 325-5230 or check the city calendar before you go. End times are placeholders. Our guide to what to ask is Part 7.

Update, Nov. 17, 2026: The city posted the Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda. It lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." Anything in this story that says the board takes up the case on Nov. 19, or that its date is not yet posted, is out of date.

What we don't know yet

  • Whether the Planning Board will take more public comment at the next hearing.
  • Whether written answers to the questions in the letters will be posted.
  • Whether the two abutters who said they missed notice will be renoticed.

Correction: An earlier version of this story gave the place of the Planning Board's Nov. 19 Haffner's Way hearing as Gloucester City Hall, and said the dates came from a community group's post. The city has not yet posted the Nov. 19 agenda, which will give the place. The dates and times come from City of Gloucester agendas, and the story now says so. (Nov. 14, 2026)

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.