ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Tuesday, November 17, 2026Get the Morning Current

Know Before It's Decided

Haffner's Way, Part 5: Can the Planning Board limit what gets built on the Sargent Street site?

Use is set by zoning, not by a subdivision vote. There are still four routes to limit what gets built, and none has been used. Here is what each one would take.

Illustration of a fence line and a checklist, labeled Haffner's Way Part 5.
Four routes that could limit use on the Sargent Street site. Cape Ann Current illustration

Trust Check: Checked against public records

4routes that could limit the use
2002land use restriction already bars homes, schools and daycare
0use limits proposed so far
Ybulk storage is allowed by right in General Industrial
c.41 §81Mstate subdivision control law
City Councilsets zoning

Residents have asked whether the Planning Board can ban fuel storage, hazardous materials or data centers from the Sargent Street site. This fifth report explains what the law and the city's own rules appear to allow. We are not lawyers and this is not legal advice. Confirm with the city solicitor.

The short answer: a subdivision decision is mostly about the road and lots, not the use. Use is set by zoning. But there are routes to limit it.

What a subdivision decision covers

Massachusetts' subdivision control law exists for the safety, convenience and welfare of the public. A board can attach conditions only as its own regulations allow (see sections 81Q, 81R and 81U of Chapter 41). That generally means access, drainage, utilities and road design, not which businesses move in.

What the zoning table says about General Industrial

The land is zoned General Industrial. Gloucester's use table, Section 2.3 of the Zoning Ordinance, says what is allowed there. The site's bylaw index holds the ordinance's use rules, but its copy of the table itself was cut off in the export. We read the table from a public reproduction of the ordinance and checked its columns against the rest of the ordinance, including the Board of Appeals' role over fueling uses in General Industrial in Section 1.8.4. Confirm the entries with the Planning Office before relying on them.

Use in the tableGeneral IndustrialWho decides
Bulk storage, warehousing (2.3.5, no. 6)Allowed by rightNo special permit. Planning Board site plan review still applies to new buildings.
Fuel or ice establishment, other than gas stations (2.3.4, no. 18)Allowed by rightNo special permit.
Manufacturing, processing or research (2.3.5, no. 3)Allowed by rightNo special permit.
Storage of toxic or hazardous materials or wastes incidental to industrial operations on site (2.3.5, no. 7)Special permitCity Council (symbol CCS)
Trailer truck park, freight or transportation terminal (2.3.5, no. 5)Special permitCity Council (symbol CCS)
Motor vehicle service, fueling, storage or repair (2.3.4, no. 11)Special permitZoning Board of Appeals (symbol SP)
Any housing (2.3.1)Not allowedExcluded

The table has no row for a bulk fuel terminal or tank farm by name. The nearest rows are "Bulk storage, warehousing" and "Fuel or ice establishment," both allowed by right in General Industrial. The ordinance's definitions, as reproduced on the same public copy, describe outdoor bulk storage as including bulk storage of liquids in tanks, other than underground tanks that serve a principal use. If that definition governs, fuel tanks on an industrial lot could fit a by right category with no special permit. Which row applies is for the Building Inspector to decide, and a ruling can be appealed to the Board of Appeals under Section 2.2.4. We have not seen a ruling.

Storing toxic or hazardous materials is different. Where it is incidental to industrial operations on site, it needs a City Council special permit. The table does not say whether fuel counts as hazardous under that row. The table also has no row for a data center. A use not expressly allowed is prohibited (Section 2.3.8), but the Inspector could sort a data center under a listed category such as manufacturing, processing or research. We have not seen a determination.

Rules that apply either way. Any new industrial building over 2,000 square feet needs Planning Board site plan review (Section 5.8), and the Board may impose conditions it considers appropriate. The performance standards in Section 4.4 say noise, vibration or odor should not normally be perceptible more than 400 feet from the premises in General Industrial, or more than 100 feet inside a residential district. A neighbor's letter in the file adds that storing flammable liquids or propane needs a license from the city's licensing authority with the fire chief's endorsement (Chapter 148, Section 13).

The Watershed Protection Overlay. If the site lies inside this overlay, Section 5.10.4 prohibits storing or selling petroleum and other hydrocarbons beyond ordinary residential use, storing hazardous materials, and junk and salvage yards, and it bans underground petroleum storage outright. The overlay follows the city's Public Water Supply Watershed Boundary Maps, kept at the Planning Office, and we have not matched the site to them. An owner can ask to show that a property does not drain to the public water supply (Section 5.10.3). If the overlay applies, it would bar fuel storage. If it does not, the table above governs.

Four ways use could be limited

  1. The applicant volunteers a limitEnergy North could record a deed restriction or put a written statement in the record. That would bind future owners only if it is recorded.
  2. The City Council changes the zoningOnly the Council can change the table of uses or create an overlay. The Planning Board makes recommendations.
  3. Site plan review or special permit conditionsWhen a building is proposed, Planning Board site plan review applies to new industrial construction over 2,000 square feet, and the Board may impose conditions it considers appropriate. That comes later, lot by lot.
  4. The 2002 land use restrictionIt already bars homes, schools, daycare and recreation, and requires paved areas to stay intact. It limits uses that disturb the cap. It does not name fuel storage.

What this means for the hearing

The Board can ask Energy North whether it will volunteer a recorded limit, and it can ask the city solicitor what conditions its rules permit. Residents can ask for either at the next hearing. A statement from the company's attorney is not binding unless recorded.

Questions for city officials

These are the questions for the Building Inspector, Planning Office, Health, Fire, licensing, the Assessor and the City Council. Part 7 has the questions for every group.

City officialsInspector, Health, Fire, licensing, Assessor, Council · 10 questions
  1. Building Inspector: how would a fuel tank farm or a data center be classified under the use table?Part 5
  2. Which uses in General Industrial need a City Council special permit?Part 5
  3. Planning Office: is the site inside the Watershed Protection Overlay map?Part 5
  4. Fire Department: what access and response plan would a larger industrial use require?Part 1
  5. Health Department: what did its Sept. 10 letter ask for, and has the applicant answered?Part 2
  6. Licensing: would storing flammable liquids or propane need a Chapter 148 license?Part 5
  7. Assessor: how are the parcels classified, and what would added value mean for the tax base?PositivePart 1
  8. City Council: would it consider a zoning limit for this district?Part 5
  9. Planning: will an environmental justice review be done for this neighborhood?Part 4
  10. What would a state supervised cleanup deliver for the neighborhood?PositivePart 3

Mark your calendar

The wetland case is expected on Dec. 2. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda continues its hearing to Dec. 3.

Dec.2
Conservation Commission: Haffner Way
Wednesday, 5:30 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well
Dec.3
Planning Board: Haffner's Way subdivision hearing (continued)
Thursday. The city has not yet posted the time or place.

Dates and times come from the City of Gloucester calendar and agendas, checked Nov. 17. The Conservation Commission's revised Nov. 18 agenda asks to continue the Haffner's Way case to Dec. 2, and the city calendar lists a Conservation Commission meeting that day at 5:30 p.m. The Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda (5 p.m., Rose Baker Center for Aging Well, second floor conference room) lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." The city had not yet listed a Dec. 3 meeting, time or place. Call the Planning Division at (978) 325-5230 or check the city calendar before you go. End times are placeholders. Our guide to what to ask is Part 7.

Update, Nov. 17, 2026: The city posted the Planning Board's Nov. 19 agenda. It lists the Haffner's Way subdivision hearing as "to be continued to December 3, 2026." Anything in this story that says the board takes up the case on Nov. 19, or that its date is not yet posted, is out of date.

What we don't know yet

  • Whether the site lies inside the Watershed Protection Overlay, which would bar petroleum storage.
  • How the Building Inspector would classify a fuel tank farm or a data center under the use table.
  • Whether the use table text we read matches the city's current version.
  • Whether the Board's current rules allow conditions tied to use.
  • Whether the company will put its position in writing.

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.