ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Tuesday, November 17, 2026Get the Morning Current

Budget and Finance

Thursday's Gloucester Budget and Finance agenda: a $510,910 FEMA grant, $425,000 for the Magnolia Reserve and a $27,530 waste station review bill

Eight items go to the committee at 5:30 p.m. Seven came from the City Council on Nov. 10. They include three grants, a snow and ice payment schedule and two requests to pay last year's bills with this year's money.

Graphic of the Gloucester City Council Budget and Finance Committee agenda for Thursday, Nov. 19, 5:30 p.m., over a photo of Gloucester City Hall. It lists all eight items, with amounts for the FEMA grant, the Magnolia Reserve grant, the harbor grant and the Weston and Sampson peer review bill.
Thursday's Budget and Finance agenda, summarized by the Current, over a photo of Gloucester City Hall on Dale Avenue. Illustration: Graphic: Cape Ann Current. Photo: Lance Fairbanks, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0), CC BY-SA 3.0

Trust Check: Checked against public records

What the committee is being asked to do

  • Take up eight items at its Thursday, Nov. 19, 5:30 p.m. meeting in the first floor Council Conference Room at City Hall, 9 Dale Ave. The agenda says the public may attend in person or by Zoom.
  • The committee is Chair Scott Memhard, Vice Chair Tony Gross and Councilor Patti-Ann Page. Seven of the eight items were on the City Council's Nov. 10 agenda and were sent here for review before any vote.
  • The agenda says items from committee reports may be combined into a consent agenda. It also says the chair's list is what is reasonably expected, that other items may come up, and that items may be taken out of order.

The eight items

Up to $947,210Three grants and one donation (items 2, 5, 6 and 7)
$27,740Last year's bills to be paid with this year's money (items 3 and 4)
1Schedule
City Auditor
Amount not listed
Adopt a 3 year Snow and Ice Amortization Schedule.
2Donation
Interim Police Chief
$100
Accept a gift from the Massachusetts Elks Association for any CIU program.
3Last year's bill
General Counsel
$210
Pay a fiscal 2026 Registry of Deeds invoice with fiscal 2027 funds.
4Last year's bill
General Counsel
$27,530
Pay fiscal 2026 invoices from Weston & Sampson for peer review of the Board of Health's Eastern Waste site application, with fiscal 2027 funds.
Kondelin Road
5Grant
Public Works Director
$510,910
Accept the revised FEMA Public Assistance grant.
6Grant
Planning Director
Up to $425,000
Accept a state LAND grant for the Magnolia Reserve Conservation project.
7Grant
Harbormaster
$11,200
Accept the 2025 CVA grant.
8Report
City Auditor
Amount not listed
Accounts with spending above their authorization, the Auditor's Report and other business.
The agenda gives one line for each item, and we have not seen the memos behind them.

What to know about each

The grants. The $510,910 FEMA grant, the Magnolia Reserve grant of up to $425,000 and the $11,200 CVA grant all arrived at the council on Nov. 10 and went to this committee, as we reported in our preview of that meeting and recap. The Magnolia Reserve grant also goes to the Planning and Development Committee, which meets Wednesday, Nov. 18 at 6 p.m. in the City Hall first floor conference room, the night before. This is the committee's review. It is not the final vote.

The snow and ice schedule. Item 1 asks to adopt a three year schedule. The agenda does not say how much it covers or for which winter. Our Oct. 5 budget story reported that City Auditor Kenny Costa told this committee on July 23 that last winter's snow and ice deficit was $6.3 million, with $233,000 in state aid so far, and that Council President Tony Gross said it would be spread over three years, about $2 million from each of the next three budgets. If this schedule is that plan, those are the numbers to compare.

Snow and ice contractors

Who gets paid to plow?

This agenda does not name the contractors behind the city's snow and ice spending. For state roads, we can show who was paid. Our Oct. 23 look at state spending in Cape Ann found that the Massachusetts Department of Transportation paid 25 Cape Ann vendors $6.6 million over six years, fiscal 2021 to 2026, to plow and treat state highways. That was about a quarter of the goods and services money state agencies sent to local businesses. The story ranks the top plowing contractors by town.
To look up any vendor by name, town and year, use our State Spending Explorer. It covers state payments only, not the city's own contracts.

The auditor's item. Item 8 covers accounts where spending went over what was authorized, and the Auditor's Report. The agenda says nothing more, and it ends with "other business."

Last year's bills. Items 3 and 4 ask to pay fiscal 2026 bills out of fiscal 2027 money. The first is $210 to the Registry of Deeds. The second is the largest dollar item that is not a grant.

Item 4: the $27,530 bill for reviewing the Kondelin Road station

Peer review means the city hires an outside engineer to check an applicant's work. Weston & Sampson reviewed the traffic study for Eastern Waste Services, the company behind the Kondelin Road waste transfer station proposal, and its engineers spoke at the Board of Health's 2025 hearings. This is the first dollar figure we have seen for what that review has cost the city.

At-large Councilor Patti-Ann Page, a member of the committee, posted a copy of the invoice summary on Facebook on Nov. 16. We have not seen the memo or the invoice in the committee's packet, so the details below are from her post. It lists work under a Sept. 26, 2023 agreement and two later amendments, with a total of $27,530:

  • $6,880 for technical review of the traffic study (Amendment No. 2, dated Sept. 16, 2025).
  • $5,950 for the May 12, 2025 Board of Health hearing.
  • $2,250 each for additional hearings on May 15, May 20, May 29, June 3 and June 4, 2025, which is $11,250.
  • $2,250 for the June 18, 2025 meeting, the day the board issued its site assignment decision.
  • $1,200 for a May 7, 2025 meeting held by video.

Page wrote that the firm was hired by the city to work on its behalf, and asked what the firm concluded about the railroad underpass and other difficult traffic patterns. We have an answer for part of that. The firm's draft review of the company's second traffic study, dated Feb. 5, 2026, found that large trucks take up the lane under the railroad bridge on Magnolia Avenue, and that transfer trailers fully cross the lane even at 10 miles an hour. It accepted the company's proposed fixes, which are signs and a 10 mile an hour advisory speed, not a posted limit. The details are in our Nov. 13 record of the project.

The agenda does not say whether Eastern Waste Services will repay the city. We did not find a payment condition for peer review in the documents we read for our earlier stories. It also does not say why these are fiscal 2026 invoices when most of the hearing dates on the summary are in spring 2025, or whether more review bills are expected.

Our Nov. 14 story on who pays if the station leaves debris on a city road found that the Board of Health set a $10,000 yearly cleanup bond with no cost estimate behind it. The board discussed a quarterly fee of 25 cents a ton on June 12, 2025 and did not adopt it. Item 4 adds a new line to that picture. Host community agreements in other towns cover different things, such as a per ton fee, road work or air monitoring. Our coming explainer lists what we confirmed elsewhere, and it does not claim that any of them cover a town's review costs.

Questions to ask Thursday

  • Grants: What does each grant pay for, does the city have to match any of it, and when must the money be spent?
  • Snow and ice: How much does the schedule cover, and for which winters? Is it the $6.3 million deficit, and who were the contractors paid for plowing?
  • Auditor: Which accounts went over their authorization, and by how much?
  • Last year's bills: Why are items 3 and 4 listed as fiscal 2026 invoices, and when was the work billed?
  • Item 4: Will Eastern Waste Services repay the city for the review? Is more peer review billing expected, and what did the reviewer conclude about the Magnolia Avenue railroad bridge?

Cape Ann Current corrects errors promptly. Send corrections to [email protected].

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.