Gloucester woods once slated for 26 homes likely to be conserved
Greenbelt plans to buy the 94 acres next to Ravenswood Park, and most of the $2 million is lined up. The 26 home plan approved in 2023 never got its wetlands permit. Three city votes remain.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
The 94 acres of woods off Magnolia Avenue where 26 homes were approved in 2023 are now likely to become conservation land instead. Essex County Greenbelt, a land trust, plans to buy the property. City and state records show most of the roughly $2 million is in place, and a city official said Nov. 16 that the sale should close within weeks.
The land was on two city agendas on Wednesday, Nov. 18. The Conservation Commission agenda listed the housing plan's wetlands filing with a request to put it off until Dec. 16. The City Council's Planning and Development Committee agenda listed a review of a $425,000 state grant for the conservation purchase. Here is what has happened so far.
Nothing is final. The housing plan is still an open filing at the Conservation Commission, where it has sat for three years without a decision, and three city money votes are still ahead.
The two efforts carry different names in city records. The housing plan is listed by its street numbers, 171 and 281R Magnolia Ave. The conservation plan is called the Magnolia Reserve. They cover the same four lots, about 94 acres next to Ravenswood Park.
Where things stand
- The Planning Board approved 13 duplexes, 26 homes in all, on Oct. 5, 2023. It has nothing on this land before it now.
- The Conservation Commission opened its wetlands hearing on Nov. 15, 2023. The filing has been on about 70 of its agendas since. It was discussed at length at six of those meetings and put off at the rest. No permit has been issued.
- City assessor records show the four lots sold on Sept. 22, 2025 for $1,000,000 to a company formed six days earlier. Three weeks later, a representative told the commission he had recently bought the land and would probably withdraw the 26 home plan and bring back a smaller one.
- In May 2026, Essex County Greenbelt, a land trust, asked the commission to back its plan to buy all 94 acres. The commission voted yes.
- The state awarded Gloucester a $425,000 grant for the project in October. The Community Preservation Committee has penciled in $300,000 more and votes Dec. 14. The City Council still has to accept the state grant.
- The wetlands filing is still open. The commission's Nov. 18 agenda lists a request to move it to Dec. 16.
The land: four lots, about 94 acres
Zoom and drag. The shaded lots are the ones in both the housing plan and the conservation deal. Switch to Streets to see Magnolia Avenue and Western Avenue.
Magnolia Reserve land, about 94 acres
Lot lines and acres: MassGIS property tax parcels, fiscal 2026. Aerial: MassGIS 2025. Streets: OpenStreetMap contributors. The pin marks the middle of the lot where the homes were planned, not a surveyed spot.
What the Planning Board approved
The applicant was How-Mag LLC, for Howland Development Co. of Wilmington. It filed its plan on Oct. 31, 2022. The board's hearing opened that December and ran, with many delays asked for by the applicant, until Oct. 5, 2023. That night the board closed the hearing and approved the plan and its waivers by a unanimous roll call. It adopted the written permit on Dec. 7, 2023.
The plan is what the city calls a cluster development. That means the homes are grouped close together on a small part of the land, and the rest is left open. The decision text in the board's file describes it this way:
- 13 two family buildings, 26 townhouse style homes with three bedrooms each, sold as condominiums
- Four of the 26 homes set aside as affordable, as the city's housing rules require
- One dead end road from Magnolia Avenue, about 1,735 feet long. The city's limit is 500 feet, so the board granted a waiver. It granted 10 waivers in all.
- City water, sprinklers in every home and one shared septic system. There is no city sewer there.
- More than 80 percent of the land left as open space with public trails, protected forever by a legal promise called a conservation restriction
Board members pressed for two things during the hearings: affordable homes and a permanent promise to protect the open land. The applicant's team said it was talking with Greenbelt and the Trustees of Reservations, which owns Ravenswood Park, about holding that promise.
The permit came with a clock. The decision text says it lapses two years after it is issued if the work has not begun in a real way, unless there is good cause. A state law signed in November 2024 added two years to most local building and land permits that were in effect in 2023 or 2024.
The Board of Health's part
The city's Board of Health reviewed the project in the spring of 2023. The question was whether the applicant had to do a water quality study that city rules require for subdivisions. The rules allow an exemption when a project has more than two acres of land for each home. The board's septic subcommittee voted 3 to 0 on May 25, 2023 to grant it, with conditions sent to the Planning Board. The full board approved it on June 1.
The applicant told the board there would be no pesticides or weed killers, that wastewater would be treated to cut nitrogen before it reached the leach field, and that the stormwater and septic systems would drain to different watersheds.
One step was left open. The Planning Board's decision says the Board of Health must approve a final septic design before any building starts.
Three years at the Conservation Commission
The Conservation Commission enforces the state and city wetlands laws. A builder who wants to work near a wetland, stream or pond files a Notice of Intent, and the commission decides whether to allow the work and under what rules.
Much of the debate has been about a cedar swamp beside the planned road. The applicant's own wetland scientists told the commission the swamp works as a vernal pool. That is a pool that fills in spring and has no fish, so frogs and salamanders can breed there. They reported finding wood frog and spotted salamander eggs.
That finding raised three questions the commission never settled.
How close can the stormwater basins be? The plan puts three basins between the road and the swamp to catch and filter rain running off the pavement. State stormwater rules call for such basins to be 50 feet from a wetland and 100 feet from a vernal pool that the state has certified. The swamp is not certified. The applicant's lawyer said the 100 foot rule applies only to certified pools. Commission member Peter Vetere, now the chair, said he could not vote for a project that did not meet that standard. The conservation agent said the basins did not meet even the 50 foot setback in several places.
Is the stream a river? A stream that flows all year gets a 200 foot protected strip on each side under state law. One that dries up does not. The applicant said the stream on the land dries up. Photos offered as proof were taken in September 2024, and the state later said a drought began that month, so the commission would not accept them.
What happens to the wildlife? On Feb. 21, 2024, the commission voted 6 to 0 to hire an outside reviewer. That firm, BSC, raised concerns about the plan to rebuild habitat next to the swamp. The applicant added steps such as weekly checks by scientists during breeding season.
The applicant did win one vote. On Jan. 17, 2024, the commission approved 5 to 0 its study of other ways to lay out the project.
The last full discussion of the 26 homes was on April 2, 2025. It ended with the stream question still open.
A sale, and a change of plans
City assessor records list all four lots under a new owner, Magnolia Reserve of Gloucester LLC, with a sale on Sept. 22, 2025 for $1,000,000. The city's record for the lot at 171 Magnolia Ave. shows How-Mag LLC had bought it in December 2019 for $700,000.
The new owner is a limited liability company. State records show it was formed on Sept. 16, 2025, six days before the sale. Its filing gives its business as "to purchase, sell, hold, develop and lease real and personal property." It lists an office in Newton and a manager with a business address in Deerfield Beach, Florida. The company filed its first annual report with the state on Nov. 12, 2026.
On Oct. 15, 2025, a representative of the project told the commission he had recently bought the land. He said he would probably withdraw the 26 home proposal and pull the homes farther from the wetland. He asked the commission to rule only on the stream. Members said his July photos did not meet the state's rules for proof and did not vote. The filing has been put off at every meeting since.
The plan to conserve it instead
On May 20, 2026, Greenbelt told the commission it wants to buy all 94 acres and open them as a new conservation area with marked trails. The land touches Ravenswood Park, other Greenbelt land and city land. The state lists it as important habitat for rare species.
Under the plan, Greenbelt would own the land. The city would buy a conservation restriction on it, and the Conservation Commission would hold that restriction.
Planning Director Gregg Cademartori told the commission the city tried to protect the same land with partners about 15 years ago and failed. Commission member Dave Sargent thanked him for not giving up on it. Vetere noted that the wetlands filing was still open and that the applicant was likely the seller. Cademartori said he believed the filing would be withdrawn if the purchase came together.
The commission voted to support the purchase, the restriction and the grant requests.
Where the $2 million is coming from
Greenbelt's own list, read Nov. 18, 2026. Tap a column heading to sort.
| Source | Amount | Status | Who decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mass Audubon Catalyst Funds | $500,000 | Awarded | Mass Audubon |
| Foundation support | $500,000 | Requested | A foundation Greenbelt does not name. The Community Preservation Committee chair said Nov. 16 that it is approved. |
| State LAND grant | $425,000 | Awarded | The Commonwealth of Massachusetts awarded it Oct. 7. The City Council must vote to accept it. |
| Gloucester Community Preservation Act money | $300,000 | Requested | Community Preservation Committee, Dec. 14, then the City Council |
| Greenbelt fundraising | $275,000 | Ongoing | Donors |
Source: Essex County Greenbelt project page; Commonwealth of Massachusetts grant announcement, Oct. 7, 2026; Gloucester Community Preservation Committee meeting, Nov. 16, 2026. Dollars as listed. The lines add up to $2,000,000. The city's application lists a project cost of $2,021,600.
Greenbelt says it has until December 2026 to raise the money. The Community Preservation Committee's chair said on Nov. 16 that Greenbelt expects to close on the purchase within a couple of weeks, as the Current reported from that meeting.
Every board with a part in it
Who has what in front of them
Search, pick a status, or tap a column heading to sort.
| Board | Its job here | Status | What is next |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conservation Commission | Wetlands permit for the 26 homes. It would also hold the conservation restriction. | Open | Nov. 18 agenda lists a request to continue to Dec. 16 |
| Planning Board | Cluster development special permit | Decided | Approved Oct. 5, 2023. Nothing on this land has been on its agendas since Dec. 7, 2023. |
| Board of Health | Water quality exemption and septic review | Decided | Exemption granted June 1, 2023. A final septic design would still need approval before building. |
| Community Preservation Committee | $300,000 toward the conservation restriction | Open | Vote Dec. 14 |
| City Council Planning and Development Committee | Review of the $425,000 state grant | Open | On its Nov. 18 agenda |
| City Council Budget and Finance Committee | Review of the $425,000 state grant | Open | On its Nov. 19 agenda |
| City Council | Final votes to accept the state grant and to spend Community Preservation money | Open | After the committees report |
| Open Space and Recreation Committee | Advice to the city | Decided | Backed the conservation project in May and sent a letter of support in June 2026 |
| Zoning Board of Appeals | None found | No filing | No filing for this land appears in its 2023 to 2026 agendas or minutes |
| Massachusetts state agencies and departments | Wetlands file number and stormwater comments, rare species review, LAND grant | Decided | Grant awarded Oct. 7, 2026 |
Source: City of Gloucester agendas, minutes and Planning Board file, 2022 to Nov. 18, 2026; Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Status as of Nov. 18, 2026.
Four years, date by date
Pick a board to follow one thread, or search for a word.
| Date | Board | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 31, 2022 | Planning Board | Cluster plan for 26 homes filed |
| Dec. 15, 2022 | Planning Board | Public hearing opens |
| Jan. 19, 2023 | Planning Board | Revised plan adds a sidewalk. Members ask for affordable homes and review nine waivers. |
| May 25, 2023 | Board of Health | Septic subcommittee votes 3 to 0 for the water quality exemption |
| June 1, 2023 | Board of Health | Full board approves the exemption |
| Sept. 7, 2023 | Planning Board | Members press for a permanent conservation restriction and affordable homes |
| Oct. 5, 2023 | Planning Board | Plan and waivers approved, unanimous |
| Nov. 15, 2023 | Conservation Commission | First wetlands hearing. Members question the basins, the stream and wildlife. |
| Dec. 7, 2023 | Planning Board | Written special permit adopted, unanimous |
| Jan. 17, 2024 | Conservation Commission | Study of other layouts approved, 5 to 0. Vernal pool question left open. |
| Feb. 21, 2024 | Conservation Commission | Outside review ordered, 6 to 0 |
| April 2, 2025 | Conservation Commission | Outside review discussed. Stream question unresolved. Continued 3 to 0. |
| Sept. 22, 2025 | Assessor record | Four lots sold for $1,000,000 |
| Oct. 15, 2025 | Conservation Commission | Representative says he will probably withdraw the 26 home plan and bring a smaller one |
| May 12, 2026 | Open Space and Recreation Committee | Greenbelt presents the conservation project |
| May 20, 2026 | Conservation Commission | Votes to support Greenbelt's purchase and a city held restriction |
| Aug. 17, 2026 | Community Preservation Committee | Hears the request for $300,000 |
| Oct. 7, 2026 | State | $425,000 LAND grant announced |
| Nov. 10, 2026 | City Council | Grant sent to two committees for review |
| Nov. 16, 2026 | Community Preservation Committee | $300,000 penciled in at a first pass |
| Dec. 14, 2026 | Community Preservation Committee | Scheduled vote on this year's grants |
| Dec. 16, 2026 | Conservation Commission | Date the applicant asked for the wetlands filing to be heard next |
Source: City of Gloucester minutes and agendas; MassGIS property tax parcels; Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Votes are as recorded in the boards' minutes.
What to watch
The 26 home plan and the conservation deal cannot both happen. If Greenbelt closes on the land, the open wetlands filing would have no builder behind it. If the money or the sale falls through, the filing is still alive and the stream and vernal pool questions are still unanswered.
Three public dates come first: the council's two committee reviews of the state grant this week, the Community Preservation Committee's vote on Dec. 14, and the Conservation Commission's Dec. 16 meeting.
What the records could not answer: The city and state records the Current read do not give the price Greenbelt has agreed to pay or name the date of the sale. They also do not say whether the 2023 special permit is still in force.
Earlier coverage: Gloucester CPC pencils in $1.38 million in grants, two at zero for now (Nov. 18), on the $300,000 request. Thursday's Gloucester Budget and Finance agenda (Nov. 17) and the Nov. 10 City Council recap (Nov. 13), on the $425,000 state grant, which the Current previewed Nov. 8. Gloucester boards today (Nov. 18), which listed both meetings.
How we did this: Cape Ann Current read the minutes and agendas of the Planning Board, Conservation Commission, Board of Health and other city boards from 2022 to Nov. 18, 2026, the Planning Board's file on the project, state assessor data and the state's grant list. Votes are as the boards' minutes record them. Questions or corrections: [email protected].
Sources
- RecordCity of Gloucester: Conservation Commission agendas and minutes, Nov. 15, 2023 to Nov. 18, 2026 (NOI 028-2976)
- RecordCity of Gloucester: Planning Board agendas and minutes, 2023
- RecordCity of Gloucester Planning Board file: Cluster Development Special Permit decision text for Magnolia Reserve, December 2023, and the plan set revised through Sept. 13, 2023
- RecordCity of Gloucester: Board of Health and Septic Review Subcommittee minutes, February to June 2023
- RecordCommonwealth of Massachusetts: LAND, PARC and Conservation Partnership grant awards, Oct. 7, 2026
- RecordEssex County Greenbelt: Magnolia Reserve project page
- RecordMassGIS: property tax parcels, Gloucester, fiscal 2026 (lots 198-20, 199-13, 206-9, 199-11)
- RecordCity of Gloucester: City Council packet, Sept. 22, 2026 (Open Space and Recreation Committee report)
- RecordSecretary of the Commonwealth, Corporations Division: Magnolia Reserve of Gloucester, LLC (ID 001914883), certificate of organization Sept. 16, 2025 and annual report Nov. 12, 2026; How-Mag LLC (ID 208072280)
- RecordCity of Gloucester assessor: property record for 171 Magnolia Ave. (ownership history)
- RecordMassachusetts Acts of 2024, Chapter 238, Section 280 (permit extension)
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.