Manchester votes yes on the senior center and the $95.3 million school
Keypad counts from the recording of the Nov. 16 Special Town Meeting show every article passed, including the $7.5 million senior and community center over the Finance Committee's objection and a close 123 to 117 vote on who gets the final say on town borrowing.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
Manchester-by-the-Sea voters said yes to everything on the Nov. 16 Special Town Meeting warrant. The two big ones were the $7.5 million senior and community center, which passed 310 to 105 over the Finance Committee's objection, and the $95.35 million Essex Elementary School, which passed 289 to 86. Both now go to the Dec. 10 ballot.
The town has not posted the recording or a results sheet. The counts here are the keypad totals the moderator read out, from the meeting video. About 420 keypads voted on the senior center, the most of the night. By the last article, 220 keypads were still voting.
What happened

-
The senior and community center at 10 Church St. passed 310 to 105. The town would borrow $7.5 million, but it can spend only $100,000 of it until Dec. 10 voters say yes and at least $3 million in private money is committed.
-
The Essex Elementary School borrowing passed 289 to 86, well past the two thirds it needed. Essex approved the same borrowing an hour earlier. Both towns vote again Dec. 10.
-
A new fire engine, $1,010,927, passed 373 to 21. The engine is arriving early and would have been sold to another town without the money.
-
The closest vote was 123 to 117 on asking the state to drop one of the two ballot questions Manchester now requires for big borrowing. Critics said it makes it easier to pass debt. Supporters called the second question a duplicate.
-
Voters raised the amount the town can borrow without a ballot vote from $1 million to $2.5 million, not the $5 million the Select Board asked for.
Before the articles
The meeting opened at 7 p.m. in the Memorial School gym with keypad voting; 395 keypads voted on the first article. The town administrator recognized the police, fire, harbormaster and mutual aid crews who responded to a boat emergency off Little Egg Rock on Oct. 3, in which two people died and one person and a dog were rescued. He also thanked the harbormaster, who retires in January after nearly 15 years. Select Board Chair John Round thanked voters for turning out.
Article 1: town meeting start time
The general bylaws still said the annual town meeting starts at 7 p.m., though the town has started at 6:30 since the pandemic. The article drops the time from the bylaw and lets the Select Board set it each year when it signs the warrant. Select Board member Brian Sollosy said the date, the fourth Monday in April, does not change. Passed 373 to 10, with 12 abstaining, from the meeting video.
Article 2: paying down the water meter notes
The town borrowed short term to replace every water meter. A small charge on each water bill, based on meter size, pays the loan back over time. This article moves $192,605 from the water enterprise fund's retained earnings to pay part of the notes due Dec. 3. Select Board member Ann Harrison said the April town meeting made a similar $271,000 payment. Passed 375 to 15, with 8 abstaining, from the meeting video.
Article 3: the fire engine
The new pumper was ordered two years ago and was due in 2027. It is arriving early. Select Board member Jeffrey Delaney said $300,000 comes from the fire apparatus fund set up in 2025 and $710,927 from free cash the state certified this fall. That leaves about $2.71 million in free cash for the spring, he said. Finance Committee Chair Sarah Mellish said the engine replaces one disposed of in 2023 and filled in with a 14 year old engine bought from Lynnfield for $100. The purchase will not change the fiscal 2027 tax rate, she said, and reserves will equal 10.2 percent of the operating budget. Passed 373 to 21, with 11 abstaining, from the meeting video.
The fire chief had already thanked voters for this one on Nov. 17.
Article 4: the senior and community center
This was the long debate of the night, about 53 minutes.
The case for it. Round said the town bought two thirds of the Masonic building behind Town Hall in 2024 for $1 million as a condominium with the Masons. The plan then was a $3 million renovation paid by donations. In January the estimate more than doubled to $7.5 million, more than could be raised privately. So the building's use grew to a community center with town offices, and the financing grew to $4.5 million from the town with at least $3 million still to come from donors. The project would not start until that money is in the bank. The building would grow from 5,400 to 7,500 square feet, with a commercial kitchen and two small meeting rooms. Round said 35 percent of residents are over 60.
The case against it. Mellish said the Finance Committee supports a senior center but voted 4 to 3 against this article because of the condominium deal. The town paid the $750,000 assessed value plus $250,000 so the Masons could finish their own space, she said. Under the agreement the town and donors would spend $9 million and own two thirds. The Masons would own one third. They could sell it back to the town only at market value, a value the town's own spending would raise. She put the cost at about $100 a year per $1 million of assessed value starting in fiscal 2029.
What residents said. About a dozen people spoke. A member of the Council on Aging advisory committee said a third of residents are seniors with no place to gather. A Parks and Recreation Committee member said 7,300 people signed up for the department's programs in one year with no indoor space of its own. A retired state aging official said Manchester is the only Cape Ann community without a senior center. Parents asked for a place for middle schoolers after school. A resident said a letter of support drew 550 signatures in 14 days.
Others asked why the town could not open the building for programs now. The Council on Aging director said the kitchen would not pass a health inspection and moving in twice would cause disruption. Two residents asked whether the design had been rushed. One asked about flooding on a lot about 5 feet above sea level; the public works director said the building is designed outside the 100 year flood level. Another asked whether the town would be paying to build an addition for the Masons' own room. The town administrator said yes, the project pays for the shell of that addition, because the Masons' room is being moved out of the town's two thirds and does not fit in theirs.
A motion to end debate passed 365 to 56. The main motion then passed 310 to 105, with 5 abstaining, from the meeting video. The moderator noted it needed only a majority Monday but faces two questions on Dec. 10: a Proposition 2½ debt exclusion, which needs a majority, and a borrowing authorization under the town's 1991 special act, which needs two thirds.
Article 5: the Essex Elementary School
Sarah Stone, a Manchester member of the School Committee and co chair of the school building committee, said the committee backs the project unanimously. The school opened in 1957, and a 2023 study found its heating, roof, windows and accessibility no longer meet the need.
Andy Oldeman, the Finance Committee's representative on the building committee, walked through the numbers. The 2023 study found $21 million of needs. Repairing the school to code would cost about $53 million with no state money and buy only 15 to 20 years. Two independent estimates of the new school came within 1 percent of each other at $98.9 million; the committee cut $3.6 million to reach $95.35 million. The school is sized for 250 students in kindergarten through grade 5 plus two preschool rooms, two classrooms per grade where Memorial has three.
Why does a smaller school cost more than Memorial? Mostly timing, Oldeman said. Memorial bid in 2019; this one bids in 2028. The Essex site is nearly twice as large, with ledge, wetlands and a new playing field, and the energy code now requires more insulation and triple glazed windows.
The state pays 36.84 percent of eligible costs, up from a 31 percent base because of the district's maintenance record and the building's efficiency. But about $38 million of the budget is above the state's caps, so the grant is about $21 million, roughly 22 percent of the total. After the grant, Manchester's share is about $49.6 million, roughly $84 a year per $100,000 of assessed value. Essex's share is about $24.8 million. If both towns approve, the school opens by December 2030. If not, the state allows one revote before the district would have to start over.
Two residents asked about the 250 student size. The town administrator said the state's enrollment study sets that number and towns that push back are usually told it stands. A recent graduate recalled evacuating the old Memorial when a heater steamed on the first day of fifth grade.
Passed 289 to 86, with 5 abstaining, from the meeting video. It needed two thirds.
Articles 6 and 7: who votes on borrowing
These two go together, and the moderator took them in turn.
Manchester has a 1991 special act and a bylaw that send any town borrowing over $1 million to a ballot vote. When a project also needs a Proposition 2½ debt exclusion, voters see two ballot questions for the same project. Select Board Vice Chair Catherine Bilotta said last spring five capital projects produced 10 ballot questions.
Article 6 asks the state legislature to change the special act so the extra question is not needed when a Proposition 2½ question is already on the ballot. The moderator and a resident spelled out the effect. Today a big project needs a majority at town meeting and two thirds at the ballot. Under the usual Proposition 2½ rules it would be the reverse: two thirds at town meeting and a majority at the ballot. One resident said it should be hard to take on debt and that the room had shrunk to about 250 people against 3,500 to 4,000 registered voters. Another said the town meeting debate that night, with the Finance Committee losing on Article 4, showed the system works. Passed 123 to 117, with 6 abstaining, from the meeting video. It does not affect the Dec. 10 questions.
Article 7 raises the bylaw's $1 million line, set in 2013, to $5 million. Harrison said a million dollars does not buy what it used to, and that a fire engine like the one just approved could not wait for a ballot. A resident moved to make it $2.5 million instead, saying $1 million in 1991 is about $2.5 million today and that capital spending should be decided by everyone who pays for it. The amendment passed 203 to 33, and the article as amended passed 200 to 37, with 4 abstaining, from the meeting video.
Article 8: commercial signs
Planning Board Chair Sarah Creighton said the rewrite of Section 6.2 of the zoning bylaw does four things. It adds sign rules for the downtown districts voters created in April, which were left out by mistake. It sets sizes and types by district. It exempts common temporary signs for events, contractors and real estate. And it lets a business get a sign permit from the building inspector. A sign that does not fit the rules can go to the Planning Board at a regular meeting instead of a special permit hearing. Existing signs stay until they change. Internally lit signs remain barred for new signs, she said; the three gas stations and one market with them today are grandfathered. The historic district overlay is not touched. Passed 193 to 20, with 7 abstaining, from the meeting video. It needed two thirds.
What was decided
-
Article 1, town meeting start time out of the bylaw: 373 to 10, from the meeting video.
-
Article 2, $192,605 from water retained earnings to pay down the meter notes: 375 to 15, from the meeting video.
-
Article 3, $1,010,927 fire engine ($300,000 apparatus fund, $710,927 free cash): 373 to 21, from the meeting video.
-
Article 4, $7,500,000 senior and community center borrowing with the $3 million donation condition: 310 to 105, from the meeting video. Motion to end debate: 365 to 56, from the meeting video.
-
Article 5, $95,351,985 Essex Elementary School borrowing (two thirds needed): 289 to 86, from the meeting video.
-
Article 6, home rule petition to end the duplicate ballot question: 123 to 117, from the meeting video.
-
Article 7, amendment to a $2.5 million threshold: 203 to 33; article as amended: 200 to 37, from the meeting video.
-
Article 8, sign bylaw (two thirds needed): 193 to 20, from the meeting video.
What happens next
-
Monday, Nov. 30: last day to register to vote for Dec. 10. The clerk's office is open 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
-
Thursday, Dec. 3, 5 p.m.: last day to apply for a mail ballot.
-
Wednesday, Dec. 9: the state school building board votes on the project budget.
-
Thursday, Dec. 10, 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., Memorial School, 43 Lincoln St.: three ballot questions. Question 1 is the school debt exclusion, a majority. Questions 2 and 3 are the senior center borrowing and its exclusion; the authorization needs two thirds, the exclusion a majority. The school borrowing takes effect only if Essex's Dec. 10 vote passes too.
-
Article 6 goes to the state legislature as a home rule petition. The Select Board files it.
Where to find the records
-
Special Town Meeting report, with every article, the explanations and each board's recommendation
-
Town Meetings and Elections page, for the Dec. 10 details and the minutes when posted
-
Meeting recording, watched online
Earlier coverage: Essex town meeting says yes to the $95.3 million school (Nov. 17), every Essex article. Monday's town meetings: every article on both warrants (Nov. 15). Manchester town meeting tonight (Nov. 16). Manchester voters OK money for new fire engine, chief says (Nov. 18). Manchester keeps its AAA bond rating (Nov. 17). The senior center forum (Oct. 28). Manchester's tax impact calculator (Nov. 10).
How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the Nov. 16 Special Town Meeting online and read the town's Special Town Meeting report. Vote counts are the keypad totals the moderator announced. These are meeting notes, not minutes; the town clerk's minutes are the official record. Questions and corrections: [email protected].
Sources
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Special Town Meeting report, Nov. 16, 2026 (warrant, explanations and board recommendations)
- RecordManchester-by-the-Sea Special Town Meeting, Nov. 16, 2026, recording watched online
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Town Meetings and Elections page (Dec. 10 Special Town Election details)
- RecordTown of Manchester-by-the-Sea: Agenda Center
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.