ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Thursday, November 19, 2026Get the Morning Current

Know Before It's Decided

Manchester Essex School Committee heard how the $95.3 million Essex school budget was set and split 3 to 2 on its own minutes Oct. 6

The committee's building committee representative explained how a $98.9 million estimate was trimmed to the budget sent to the state, the two elementary schools presented their first shared improvement plan, and members debated how much detail their summary minutes should carry.

The brick front entrance of Manchester Essex Regional Middle High School under a blue sky, with young trees along the walk
Manchester Essex Regional Middle High School in a 2020 photo. The School Committee met in the school's learning commons Oct. 6. File photo: Trevorwelsh / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Trust Check: Checked against public records

The Manchester Essex Regional School Committee got its first full look Oct. 6 at how the Essex Elementary School project budget was set, two weeks before it voted to borrow the money. The committee also approved its Sept. 15 minutes on a split vote after a debate over how much its new summary style minutes leave out, from the posted minutes.

What happened

  • The committee's representative on the Essex School Building Committee explained how two cost estimates came in at $98.9 million and were trimmed to a budget of $95,351,985, the figure sent to the state and later approved for borrowing. (Read what the committee decided Oct. 20.)
  • The Sept. 15 minutes passed 3 to 2 with one member abstaining, from the posted minutes. Two members said the summary minutes miss what members actually said.
  • Essex Elementary and Memorial School presented one shared school improvement plan for the next two years, the first time the two schools have written a single plan.
  • The district needs about $20,000 for asbestos work at Essex Elementary and an estimated $20,000 to $30,000 to replace the copper phone lines that connect elevators and alarms to a monitoring center, because the phone company is ending that service.
  • Six of seven members attended. Nadia Wetzler was absent.

How the school budget was set

Theresa Whitman, who sits on the building committee, said two independent cost estimates for the new school were reconciled within 1 percent of each other and came to $98.9 million for the building as designed. The building committee then went through a list of money saving options. It accepted changes to building materials and landscaping and removed a bump out on the gym along with half the bleachers, which Whitman said saved about $3.6 million, as said on the recording. (Read about the Oct. 13 schematic design vote.)

Three bigger choices went to the full building committee. It kept the mechanical, electrical and plumbing system it had already chosen. It kept the rounded roof, which Whitman said looks like a ship's hull, after a community survey split about evenly on it; a flatter roof would have saved about $195,000, as said on the recording. A playground reduction of just under $90,000 was put off for a later decision. About $781,000 in other possible cuts stayed in the budget for now, from the posted minutes. (See how the building committee looked for cuts in September.)

Whitman said there is no large piece left to cut: the remaining non reimbursable space is small, and the cost is what a school building costs today. She asked every member to help explain the project before the Nov. 16 town meetings. A member who had been at a Manchester-by-the-Sea board meeting the night before said the committee has its work cut out for it there, because board members want to understand what drives the price before they ask voters to approve it.

Members proposed a shared schedule of town board meetings so that at least one Essex member attends Manchester meetings and one Manchester member attends Essex meetings. Superintendent Pam Beaudoin said a one page set of talking points, frequently asked questions, new renderings and a project booklet were being prepared, and that a financing meeting with the towns' advisors that week would produce the numbers people were asking for: what the project means for each town's annual budget and for a household. Community meetings were set for Oct. 8 in Essex and Oct. 13 in Manchester. (Read our write-up of those meetings.)

The minutes debate

The committee has been using computer generated summary minutes while its reporting secretary position is empty. Jake Foster said the Sept. 15 draft captured presentations well but reduced the committee's own discussion to a line or two, left out a point about school culture and rarely named who said what. Lindsay Banks said shorter minutes are easier for people to read, and the recordings carry the full dialogue. Whitman suggested testing different levels of detail and letting members add what they think is missing.

The Sept. 15 minutes passed 3 to 2 with one abstention, from the posted minutes: Kate Koch-Sundquist, Banks and Sarah Stone voted yes, Whitman and Foster voted no, and Chris Reed abstained. Members who see something missing were asked to send wording to Beaudoin before each meeting. No decision was made on filling the secretary position.

One plan for two elementary schools

Essex Elementary Principal Kim Provost and Memorial School Principal John Willis said their goals had grown so close that they wrote one improvement plan for both schools. Over the last two years the schools hired a math coach and a literacy coach they share, set up a shared team to help teachers with struggling students, added a library teaching assistant so each library is staffed, and gave teachers time to observe one another and schools in other districts.

Essex now has a before school program, Morning Movers, that takes children at 7:15 a.m. Memorial expanded its RISE program to two classrooms with a second teacher and five more teaching assistants. Both schools have calm or sensory spaces. A first family literacy and math night drew about seven parents, so the schools plan to fold that work into events families already attend.

The next two years follow the priorities set by the schools' accreditation review: mapping the curriculum, agreeing on shared beliefs about learning, and connecting the district's Vision of the Graduate to elementary classrooms. Fifth grade has finished its first year of the state's Investigating History curriculum, and grades 3 and 4 are starting it with grant funded training. A district committee is reviewing elementary math materials, with classroom testing planned for spring and a possible new program in the fall of 2027. A universal screener for social and emotional learning has not been chosen. The agenda listed a fiscal 2027 outlook with this item; the presentation covered goals, not budget figures.

Members asked how the coaching would narrow the gap in math results between the two schools and how the new building would help teaching. Provost said small group work is hard in the current building and described the value of flexible classrooms, project rooms and outdoor learning space.

Curriculum review and buildings

Heather Leonard, the director of curriculum and instructional technology, reviewed this year's curriculum review cycle. Kindergarten through grade 2 teachers are using Mystery Science with common materials, grades 3 to 5 reordered their science units, the middle school is preparing to pilot an OpenSciEd unit and the high school is revising its science units. Two review reports, on history and social science and on science, technology and engineering, will be posted on the district website.

Finance Director Michelle Cresta said the district is hiring a facilities manager and returning to a dedicated management job after a combined hands on and management role did not work. Summer work included 13 steam traps at Essex Elementary, exhaust fans, plumbing, reroofing the storage barn, woodwork at the middle high school entrance and resurfaced tennis courts. The three year asbestos inspection found pipe insulation at Essex Elementary to wrap or remove, at a combined cost of about $20,000; Memorial and the middle high school are certified free of asbestos. A state inspection of the pedestrian bridge found panels and concrete to repair, with the cost still unknown.

What was decided

  • Voucher 1021: approved, unanimous, from the posted minutes.
  • Minutes of Sept. 15: approved 3 to 2 with one abstention, from the posted minutes.
  • High school day trip to the 9/11 Memorial in New York: approved, unanimous, from the posted minutes.
  • Background check policies, first read: accepted, unanimous, from the posted minutes. The committee adopted them on second read Oct. 20.
  • School Committee newsletter: approved for distribution, unanimous, from the posted minutes.

What happens next

  • Oct. 20: the committee voted 7 to 0 to borrow up to $95.3 million for the school. (Read that report.)
  • Nov. 3: the committee reviewed the Essex Elementary booklet and first quarter spending. (Read the Nov. 3 notes.)
  • Nov. 16: special town meetings in Manchester-by-the-Sea and Essex vote on the borrowing; Dec. 10: ballot votes in both towns.
  • Nov. 17 at 6 p.m.: the committee's next regular meeting, in the middle high school Learning Commons.

Where to find the records

Earlier coverage: the Oct. 6 agenda preview (Oct. 3); how the $33.7 million district budget fits together (Nov. 4).

How we did this: Cape Ann Current watched the meeting online and checked every vote and name against the committee's approved minutes and the agenda. These are our meeting notes, not the committee's minutes.

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.