Can a waste station beside a wooded swamp protect public health? The water, health and company record questions
The Board of Health found the Kondelin Road site meets the state's tests. Neighbors and Manchester-by-the-Sea have raised questions about the swamp that drains toward a brook and a beach, a 2022 state penalty and a federal hazardous waste registration.

Trust Check: Checked against public records
How does a waste station in a wooded area, beside a swamp that drains toward a brook and a beach, fit the job of a board of health to protect public health? The Gloucester Board of Health, which assigned the site in June 2025, found that the proposed station at 24 Kondelin Road meets the state's tests. The state Department of Public Health told it in 2023 that it did not expect adverse effects on public health and safety. Neighbors and Manchester-by-the-Sea have raised questions about water, wetlands and a company record that includes a 2022 state penalty and a federal hazardous waste registration.
This is the fourth piece in a daily series ahead of the Conservation Commission hearing on Wednesday, Nov. 18. The full record ran Friday.
What the state tests measured
The Board of Health applied the state's site suitability rules (310 CMR 16.40). These are the findings recorded in its decision.
| Test | Finding in the decision |
|---|---|
| Occupied homes, schools, child care, health care, senior centers within 500 feet of the waste handling area | None |
| Public water supply wells | Nearest mapped Zone II about 1.8 miles away; nearest interim wellhead protection area about 1.65 to 1.7 miles; nearest Zone A near Dyke's Pond about 0.6 mile |
| Private wells | One on a neighboring industrial property, 327 feet downgradient, used only for truck washing. Condition 37 bars drinking use, enforced by a recorded deed restriction |
| Area of Critical Environmental Concern | Nearest is more than two miles north |
| Priority habitat of rare species | None identified |
| Air emissions | All tipping and loading indoors, four exhaust fans, dust misting. The board found no threat to public health, safety or the environment from air emissions at the site |
| Noise | Indoor tipping and loading, white noise back up alarms, limited receiving hours. Noise testing at the nearest abutters after the station opens |
| Odor | Enclosed building, daily wet sweeping, exhaust and door conditions |
Source: Board of Health Site Assignment Decision, June 18, 2025. Distances for wells are from the applicant's filing and the company's and the city's experts as cited in the decision.
The water
The concern is the wooded swamp across Kondelin Road. The decision says evidence showed water from that swamp flows into Wolf Trap Brook, which runs into Manchester-by-the-Sea and eventually reaches the beach south of the site. Manchester-by-the-Sea's Board of Health took part in the hearings as a party. On May 22, 2025 it asked the state for further environmental review, and on June 4 it filed maps of the town's private wells and a memo on Wolf Trap Brook. The decision found the waste handling area is more than 500 feet from the town line, so Manchester's private wells do not trigger the state's well distance rule.
Where the site is
Zoom and drag. Tap a pin for details. Use Aerial to see the industrial park.
■ Mapped wetland (shaded)━ Wolf Trap Brook (dashed where it runs in a culvert)━ Truck route
The Board of Health decision describes a wooded swamp across Kondelin Road from the site. Water from it flows into Wolf Trap Brook, which runs toward Manchester-by-the-Sea. The shading and the brook come from OpenStreetMap and are approximate. The official wetland lines are in the company's wetlands filing.
- Proposed station site, 24 Kondelin Road. Inside the Cape Ann Industrial Park, about 0.6 mile along Kondelin Road from Magnolia Avenue.
- Kondelin Road meets Magnolia Avenue. Heavy trucks can only come and go to the north, because Magnolia Avenue south of here carries a 2.5 ton limit.
- Route 128 ramps on Essex Avenue. About 2.8 miles by road from the site, measured along the mapped route.
Pins and road lines: OpenStreetMap contributors; the site pin is an address lookup and is approximate. Aerial: MassGIS 2025. Facts: Board of Health site assignment decision, June 18, 2025.
Health: what was reviewed, and what the board said is missing
The Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that no residential or other non industrial zoning lies within 1,100 feet and that the area does not meet the state's environmental justice criteria. Its letter did not expect adverse effects on public health and safety. The building would be fully enclosed with filtered ventilation.
EPA's ECHO profile of the area within a mile of 24 Kondelin Road, based on the 2024 American Community Survey, counts about 1,161 residents in 437 housing units. Nineteen percent are under 18, 26 percent are 65 or older and 12 percent have low incomes. Since the decision, the city has pressed for more. On Oct. 8, 2026 the Board of Health sent the Conservation Commission a memo on gaps in the third party review of the wetlands filing, including soil testing the reviewer skipped. Soil testing under condition 20 is outstanding, and a hazardous materials and asbestos plan under condition 30 has not been approved.
The company's record
Public databases show what follows for Eastern Waste Services LLC, which does business as Hiltz Waste Disposal. We checked them on Nov. 11, 2026. A listing with no violations is a fact about the records, not a finding about the company's practices.
| Agency | What the record shows | Date |
|---|---|---|
| MassDEP (state environmental) | Administrative consent order with penalty and notice of noncompliance No. 00012892, effective March 10, 2022, for operating a solid waste facility at 24 Kondelin Road without a site assignment from the Board of Health or a state solid waste permit. The penalty was $32,337, with $20,000 payable in six installments and $12,337 suspended on condition of no further violations for a year after the last payment. The company consented without admitting or denying. The state's Energy and Environmental Affairs data portal lists the site as Essex County Recycling Center (facility 368513) with three enforcement actions: notices of noncompliance on Jan. 14, 2002 and April 18, 2017, and this order. The portal also lists seven inspections: Dec. 10, 2001; June 17, 2003 (reinspection); Aug. 15, 2005; Dec. 2, 2018; Oct. 14, 2021; June 3, 2022; and Oct. 31, 2023 (a solid waste visit with limited enforcement potential). Permit records show a solid waste permit entry (SW01-0000007) and a "determination of need for site assignment" (SW17). The portal lists no enforcement action after 2022 and no inspection after Oct. 31, 2023. The entries do not show what each notice cited. | Portal checked Nov. 11, 2026; order issued March 10, 2022 |
| EPA (federal environmental) | EPA's ECHO database has a facility record for 24 Kondelin Road (registry ID 110071467359; hazardous waste ID MAR000625293; industry code 56211, waste collection). It lists the site as an active small quantity generator ("SQG") of hazardous waste under the federal waste law, which means a registration to produce a limited amount of hazardous waste. It shows no violation in any of the last 12 quarters, no inspections, no informal or formal enforcement actions and $0 in penalties. It lists no Clean Water Act or Clean Air Act permits. The 2022 state order does not appear in it. EPA's RCRAInfo record for the site lists one waste code, F037 (a refinery oil, water and solids separation sludge), and also registers the site in the federal used oil program. | Checked Nov. 11, 2026 |
| FMCSA (federal transportation) | Interstate for hire trucking company, USDOT 3063127, authorized to haul property, with 17 trucks and 14 drivers. It has no federal safety rating. Its registration was last updated July 1, 2024, and the agency marks it outdated. | Data as of Nov. 9, 2026 |
| State transportation | We found no separate Massachusetts public record. State roadside inspections feed the federal figures above. | Not found |
Roadside inspections
inspections in 24 months, 16 with violations
Blue is the company, gray is the national average. A lower rate is better: it means fewer vehicles or drivers were ordered off the road by an inspector. 24 months to Nov. 9, 2026.
Violations
violations found in those inspections
- Vehicle maintenance30
- Unsafe driving8
- Driver fitness1
- Hours of service0
The agency lists no penalties and found no critical violations in investigations. Data as of Oct. 30 to Nov. 10, 2026.
Crashes
reportable crashes in 24 months
- With an injury1
- Tow away1
- Fatal0
The data do not say where they happened or who was at fault. 24 months to Nov. 9, 2026.
What the 2022 state order says
The administrative consent order is a signed agreement between MassDEP and the company, effective March 10, 2022. The text below is from the order. The company agreed to it without admitting or denying the facts, and agreed not to contest them for purposes of enforcing the order.
| Date | What the order says |
|---|---|
| Sept. 14, 2021 | MassDEP receives a complaint that the company was accepting, handling and transferring construction and demolition waste at 24 Kondelin Road |
| Oct. 14, 2021 | MassDEP inspects. It reports mixed construction waste from various contractors dumped on the ground in an open air upper storage yard that is neither enclosed nor covered; a pile of mixed waste of about 150 to 200 cubic yards, including wood, metal, plastic, rubber and house siding; and eight roll off containers of mixed waste |
| Oct. 14, 2021 | Facility personnel tell MassDEP the site accepts construction waste from general contractors and the general public five days a week, pushes it with an excavator into a 100 cubic yard trailer, and sends an average of two such trailers a day, five days a week, to a processing facility in Wilbraham |
| Jan. 10, 2022 | MassDEP issues a notice of enforcement conference |
| Feb. 1, 2022 | Company representatives meet MassDEP |
| March 10, 2022 | The order takes effect |
What it found. The Board of Health had not granted a site assignment and MassDEP had not issued a solid waste permit. The company operated the Essex County Recycling Center under a general permit for recycling, which allows only pre-sorted recyclable materials. The order cites two rules: operating a solid waste facility without a site assignment (310 CMR 16.01(8)) and without a state facility permit (310 CMR 19.028). It lists the company's principal offices as Clinton, Connecticut.
What it required. Stop receiving any solid waste, including construction waste, immediately and operate only under the general permit for recycling. Within 30 days, stop storing solid waste and remove all of it, including every container of mixed construction waste. Within 60 days, send MassDEP a written certification of compliance.
The penalty. MassDEP assessed $32,337. The company was to pay $20,000: $7,500 within 30 days, then five payments of $2,500 every 30 days through day 180. MassDEP suspended $12,337, to be demanded only if the company violated the order or the cited rules between the order date and one year after the last payment. Violating the order carries stipulated daily penalties of $250 a day for the first 15 days, $500 a day for days 16 to 30 and $1,000 a day after that.
The state portal lists no enforcement action after this order. The public record does not show whether the installments were paid on schedule, whether the 60 day certification was filed, or whether the suspended amount was ever demanded.
Source: MassDEP Administrative Consent Order with Penalty and Notice of Noncompliance No. 00012892, Eastern Waste Services LLC, effective March 10, 2022. The 2025 approval would allow the kind of activity the order describes, indoors and under 37 conditions.
What "active small quantity generator" means
In the federal EPA database, an Active SQG is an active small quantity generator of hazardous waste, regulated under the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, known as RCRA. EPA sorts every site that produces hazardous waste by how much it makes in a month. In Massachusetts the state environmental agency, MassDEP, runs the matching program under 310 CMR 30.000.
| Category | Hazardous waste made per month | How long it may be stored on site |
|---|---|---|
| Very small quantity generator | 100 kilograms or less (about 220 pounds) | Up to 1,000 kilograms at a time |
| Small quantity generator | More than 100 and under 1,000 kilograms (about 220 to 2,200 pounds) | Up to 180 days, or 270 if shipped more than 200 miles, and never more than 6,000 kilograms (about 13,200 pounds) |
| Large quantity generator | 1,000 kilograms or more | Up to 90 days, with no cap on amount |
"Active" means the site's registration is current in EPA's hazardous waste database. A registered small generator has to notify the government that it produces hazardous waste, renew that notice every four years, and make arrangements with local emergency responders. Hazardous waste here means wastes on EPA's lists or wastes with traits such as toxicity, ignitability, corrosivity or reactivity.
It is a classification, not a violation. The record says the site falls in the middle tier.
What the registration lists. EPA's RCRAInfo detail record for the site (handler ID MAR000625293) lists one hazardous waste code, F037. In EPA's rules, F037 is a listed hazardous waste: sludge from the gravitational separation of oil, water and solids during the storage or treatment of process wastewater and oily cooling wastewater at petroleum refineries. The same record also registers the site in EPA's used oil program, and lists its industry as waste collection. It does not say where the F037 waste came from, how much was made, when, or where it went. A construction waste hauler is not a petroleum refinery, so the code raises a question the public record does not answer.
Sources: U.S. EPA, Categories of Hazardous Waste Generators and Frequent Questions About the Hazardous Waste Generator Regulations; EPA ECHO Detailed Facility Report and RCRAInfo detail view for 24 Kondelin Road; 40 CFR 261.31. Pound figures are conversions from EPA's kilogram thresholds.
A question the EPA record raises. A hazardous waste generator registration is not a violation, and EPA shows none. It does mean the site is registered with the federal government as a place that produces hazardous waste, and the record does not say where the F037 waste came from, how much there was, when it was generated, or why a construction waste hauler's site carries a refinery waste code. The Board of Health's decision lists a hazardous materials and asbestos plan as condition 30, and that plan is still pending. Whether the board, its reviewer or MassDEP looked at the EPA registration while reviewing the plan is not in the public record.
Sources: EPA ECHO facility record; FMCSA SAFER company snapshot and Safety Measurement System profile for USDOT 3063127; MassDEP Administrative Consent Order No. 00012892 (March 10, 2022); MassDEP Energy and Environmental Affairs data portal, facility 368513 (permits, inspections, enforcements). The company's transportation figures cover all its trucks, not only trips to this site.
A question the EPA record raises. A hazardous waste generator registration is not a violation, and EPA shows none. It does mean the site is registered with the federal government as a place that produces hazardous waste, and the record does not say what that waste is, when it was generated, or why it is in the company's file. The Board of Health's decision lists a hazardous materials and asbestos plan as condition 30, and that plan is still pending. Whether the board, its reviewer or MassDEP looked at the EPA registration is not in the public record.
The questions residents are asking
These questions come from gaps in the public record. Each stays open until the office that holds the answer responds.
Public health
Who can answerBoard of Health, the Department of Public Health and MassDEP
Questions- How can a Board of Health that approves a waste site in a wooded area near water and city neighborhoods also be the body protecting public health?
- What health baseline exists for the neighborhoods near the site and along the truck route, and who will measure change?
- Who monitors dust, odor and noise after the station opens, and is the same board that approved it also the one checking?
- Why did the state health department's 2023 review come before the plan shrank in 2024 and before the 2025 hearings?
Water
Who can answerConservation Commission, MassDEP and Manchester-by-the-Sea
Questions- What would stop leachate or runoff from a spill from reaching the swamp and Wolf Trap Brook?
- Who will test the swamp, the brook and the beach, and how often?
- Why was soil testing skipped by the wetlands reviewer, and when will it be done?
- Is the stormwater treatment device sized for the storms that flood the Magnolia Avenue dip?
Cleanup and closure
Who can answerBoard of Health, MassDEP and the City Solicitor
Questions- If there is a spill, who pays for area cleanup, and is any money set aside for it?
- Is there money set aside to close the site if the company leaves?
- Who is liable if contamination moves downstream into Manchester-by-the-Sea?
The company's record
Who can answerMassDEP, EPA's regional office and the company
Questions- The federal record lists hazardous waste code F037, a refinery oil, water and solids separation sludge. Where did it come from, how much, and since when?
- Why does a construction waste hauler's site carry a refinery waste code?
- Has the Board of Health, its reviewer or MassDEP reviewed that registration, and why is it in the company's record?
- The 2022 order set $20,000 in six installments and suspended $12,337 for a year after the last payment. Were the installments paid on time, was the 60 day certification of cleanup filed, and was the suspended amount ever demanded?
- The state portal lists the last MassDEP inspection on Oct. 31, 2023. Has the site been inspected since then?
The location
Who can answerCity Council, Planning Board and the EDIC
Questions- Why a wooded site beside wetlands? Did anyone compare it with other industrial land in the city?
- Was any other site compared?
Where this stands
The wetlands filing, number 028-3129, is before the Conservation Commission on Nov. 18. The state construction permit, which brings a 30 day public comment period, is still ahead. See how to take part.
The Kondelin Road series
One piece a day through the Nov. 18 hearing.
- Fri. Nov. 13The full record
- Sat. Nov. 14Who pays: cost to the city
- Sun. Nov. 15Trucks, roads and safety
- Mon. Nov. 16You are hereWater, health and the company record
- Tue. Nov. 17Why here? Fairness and the EDIC reversal
- Wed. Nov. 18Hearing day: what can be decided
Sources
- RecordCity of Gloucester: Eastern Waste Services (EWS) Site Suitability Application for C&D Transfer Station (project page and timeline)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health: Site Assignment Decision, Eastern Waste Services LLC, 24 Kondelin Road, June 18, 2025
- RecordEastern Waste Services: Second Update on Permit Compliance, presentation to the Board of Health, May 7, 2026
- RecordWeston and Sampson: peer review update of the Eastern Waste Services traffic study, Jan. 7, 2025
- RecordWeston and Sampson: peer review of the supplemental traffic study, draft, Feb. 5, 2026
- RecordMassachusetts Department of Public Health: comment letter on the site suitability application, Nov. 21, 2023
- RecordMassDEP: Administrative Consent Order with Penalty and Notice of Noncompliance No. 00012892, Eastern Waste Services LLC, effective March 10, 2022
- RecordMassDEP, Energy and Environmental Affairs Data Portal: Essex County Recycling Center, facility 368513 (permits, inspections, enforcements), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordU.S. EPA Envirofacts: RCRAInfo facility detail, handler ID MAR000625293 (hazardous waste codes, handler types), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordU.S. EPA ECHO: Detailed Facility Report, Eastern Waste Services LLC, 24 Kondelin Rd (FRS 110071467359; RCRA ID MAR000625293), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordFederal Motor Carrier Safety Administration: SAFER company snapshot, Eastern Waste Services LLC (USDOT 3063127)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health, Eastern Waste Service Subcommittee agenda, Oct. 6, 2026
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission agenda, Oct. 7, 2026
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission agenda, Oct. 21, 2026 (revised)
- RecordCity of Gloucester Solicitor's Office: Eastern Waste Services Approval Process and Permit Tracker, released by the Board of Health March 3, 2026
- RecordHiltz Waste Disposal: Essex County Recycling Center page (24 Kondelin Road)
- SourceWaste Today: MassDEP penalizes Eastern Waste Services for solid waste violations (2022)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health hearing exhibits (city Drive folder): Exhibits 1 to 36, including the Aug. 11, 2023 application, the traffic study and the Oct. 17, 2023 EDIC letter
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission case folder for the Eastern Waste Services notice of intent, plans and public comments
- RecordGloucester Board of Health memo to the Conservation Commission on gaps in the third party review, Oct. 8, 2026
- RecordGloucester EDIC minutes, June 2, 2025 (vote to support the site)
- SourceMap data: OpenStreetMap contributors; aerial imagery MassGIS 2025
- RecordMassDEP: 310 CMR 19.000 solid waste regulations, definitions (19.006) and waste bans (19.017), as published by Cornell LII
- RecordMassDEP: Minimum Performance Standard for Construction and Demolition Handling Facilities (updated July 2024)
- RecordMassDEP: Waste Ban Guidance for Operators of Solid Waste Facilities (Oct. 2021)
- RecordMassDEP: Asbestos Information Resource Guide (June 2023)
- RecordMassDEP: Asbestos Containing Waste Material temporary storage policy (amended Dec. 2025)
- RecordU.S. EPA: Industrial and construction and demolition landfills
- RecordU.S. EPA: How should lead containing wastes from renovations be handled and disposed
- RecordU.S. EPA: Asbestos NESHAP, demolition and renovation requirements
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.