Would a waste station be allowed in Riverdale or East Gloucester? The fairness questions behind Kondelin Road
The EDIC reversed its position, the city once said it saw no need, and the station is proposed in Gloucester rather than in Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex. The questions about fairness, protection and who decides.
Trust Check: Checked against public records
If the same station were proposed for Riverdale or East Gloucester, would the city allow it? And if it would not, why is it acceptable in West Gloucester? Those are the fairness questions behind the proposed construction waste station at 24 Kondelin Road. The record does not test them, because the state's siting rules, the industrial park and the site's distance from homes all pointed to Kondelin Road. But the questions show what the review measured and what it did not.
This is the fifth piece in a daily series ahead of the Conservation Commission hearing on Wednesday, Nov. 18. The full record ran Friday.
What made this site eligible
The site is in the Cape Ann Industrial Park. The decision found no occupied home, school, child care center, health care facility or senior center within 500 feet of the waste handling area and no public water supply protection zone at the site. The state Department of Public Health wrote in 2023 that no residential or other non industrial zoning lies within 1,100 feet and that the area does not meet the state's environmental justice criteria. The state's siting rules apply statewide. Where a facility may go within a city is a local zoning matter, and the City Council's special permit and the Planning Board's site plan review are still ahead.
The comparison residents are making
A question being raised is why a regional waste facility is proposed in Gloucester rather than in a town with a different income profile, and whether Gloucester gets the same protection as towns that are better off. The Census figures below frame the question. They do not show why a site was chosen.
| Measure | Gloucester | Manchester-by-the-Sea | United States |
|---|---|---|---|
| Population, July 2025 estimate | 30,627 | 5,475 | 341,784,857 |
| Median household income, 2020 to 2024 | $83,883 | $206,389 | $80,734 |
| Per capita income, 2020 to 2024 | $53,768 | $106,716 | $44,673 |
| People in poverty | 9.6% | 2.1% | 10.2% |
Source: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts, figures in 2024 dollars. Essex figures were not retrieved for this table. The record does not say whether a station was ever proposed or considered in Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex.
The company's witness testified that the station would handle about 180 tons a day normally and up to 270 at the maximum, and said the greater Cape area could sustain that. We compared that with the state average. In 2024, Massachusetts disposed of 1,710,000 tons of non-municipal solid waste, a category MassDEP says grew primarily because of construction and demolition debris. Divided by the state's 2024 population of 7,138,560, that is about 0.24 tons per resident. At that rate the four Cape Ann towns, with 46,886 residents in 2024 estimates (Gloucester 30,544, Rockport 7,099, Essex 3,771, Manchester-by-the-Sea 5,472), would dispose of about 11,200 tons a year, or about 43 tons on each weekday. The company's 180 to 270 tons a day, on a five day week of 260 days, is about 46,800 to 70,200 tons a year, roughly 4 to 6 times that.
This is our arithmetic, not a finding in the record. It uses a statewide average of all non-municipal solid waste, which includes more than construction debris, so it likely overstates what Cape Ann disposes of, and it counts disposal only, not debris that is recycled. Cape Ann may differ from the state average, and the company has not said what share would come from each town or from outside. The company's witness also said at the June 4, 2025 hearing that it would not check where customers live or limit use to Gloucester or Cape Ann. Added Nov. 15, 2026. Updated Nov. 17, 2026 to use 2024 state data in place of 2018 data.
The EDIC reversal
The Gloucester Economic Development and Industrial Corporation built and manages the industrial park. Its position changed between 2023 and 2025.
The EDIC told the state the site is neither suitable for waste services nor compatible with its plan to bring professional jobs to the Cape Ann Industrial Park. It cited a 2019 survey of park businesses.
The EDIC voted unanimously to send a letter supporting the site, with conditions. Its reasons are not in the records reviewed. At the 2025 hearings its chair questioned the city's expert about conditions such as trip reporting and leachate.
Sources: EDIC comment letter, Oct. 17, 2023 (hearing Exhibit 16); EDIC minutes, June 2, 2025.
- Aug. 2023The company files its site suitability application with the Gloucester Board of Health.
- Oct. 17, 2023EDICThe EDIC writes to the state that the site is neither suitable nor compatible with its plan for the Cape Ann Industrial Park.
- 2023The City of Gloucester tells the state its own solid waste needs are met by its municipal contract and asks the company to show a critical need.
- June 10, 2024The plan shrinks from 15,750 to 11,800 square feet and from 325 to 270 tons a day.
- May 7 to June 4, 2025Seven hearing sessions. Manchester-by-the-Sea, the EDIC and abutters take part as parties.
- June 2, 2025EDICThe EDIC votes unanimously to send a letter supporting the site, with conditions, reversing its 2023 position. Its reasons are not in the records reviewed.
- June 18, 2025The Board of Health assigns the site with 37 conditions.
What the EDIC said on Nov. 10, 2026. The board took no vote and spent about five minutes on the company, according to the city's recording and its automatic transcript. Speakers are not named on the recording, so we attribute remarks to board members. The member who chaired the meeting called the expansion "challenging" and said there is a lot of community opposition, mostly over trucks in the neighborhood. He said part of the opposition is a sense that the facility serves outsiders more than local contractors. He said the EDIC took part in the hearings as a voice for business and economic development, that the company is investing $10 million to $15 million, and that the EDIC does not want to get into operational neighborhood issues because it is a volunteer board. He said the company has not yet received its state DEP permit and still has city permits to obtain. Another member said the company would not want a limit on who can use the site. We have not seen the $10 million to $15 million figure in any filing.
If the EDIC does not want to take up operational neighborhood issues, who speaks for the neighborhood on the trucks? That question is still open.
The state health department's finding that the area does not meet the state's environmental justice criteria is one measure. EPA's ECHO profile for the one mile around the site is another: about 1,161 residents, 12 percent with low incomes, 11 percent people of color. The two measures use different areas and standards, and the record does not reconcile them.
What residents want
The city's project page links a folder of public comments from the 2025 hearings. Manchester-by-the-Sea's Board of Health, three groups of ten citizens, the EDIC and the City of Gloucester took part as parties. The record contains no survey or vote showing what residents of Gloucester, taken together, want.
The questions residents are asking
These questions come from gaps in the public record. Each stays open until the office that holds the answer responds.
What is the benefit to Gloucester?
Who can answerCity Council, the Mayor's office, the EDIC and the company
Questions- The company offered 25 cents a ton in 2025 and the board did not adopt it. If the company pays property tax and nothing more, what is the benefit to Gloucester of allowing the site?
- Is the company investing anything beyond taxes in roads, safety, cleanliness or infrastructure, or has it offered to?
- Why has the benefit to Gloucester not been addressed in the record, by the board, the city or the company?
- If the answer is nothing beyond jobs that already exist and taxes, what would justify the cost and risk to neighbors?
- The EDIC chair said on Nov. 10 that the company is investing $10 million to $15 million. What does that cover, is it in any filing, and does any of it go to roads, safety or the city?
- One EDIC member said opponents see the site as serving outsiders. Who is the station built to serve, and does the approval limit where loads come from?
Why Gloucester, and not somewhere else?
Who can answerCity Council, Planning Board, the Mayor's office and the company
Questions- Would an affluent community like Wellesley, Concord or Cambridge ever allow a private transfer station inside its borders? If not, why is West Gloucester being asked?
- Did the company look at a site in any of those towns, in Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex, or in Georgetown, which already has a large waste transfer station? Or only at property it already owns?
- What would those communities require before saying yes, such as investment, fees or infrastructure, and has Gloucester asked for the same?
- Can the company buy or lease property somewhere else, away from a wooded swamp and a one road route? Why is it proposing the site it already owns?
- Does Gloucester ask as much of the company as a wealthier town would, and do its residents get the same protection and representation?
What happens if the site is sold?
Who can answerCity Solicitor, Board of Health, MassDEP and the company
Questions- What restrictions does the city place on a future sale? Can another company buy the site and keep operating what this company does?
- Do the site assignment, the 37 conditions and the bond pass automatically to a new owner, and who tells the city?
- Could the city require that the approval end on a sale, so a new owner must apply again and show what it will invest?
- If the company will not invest in the community, what keeps the approval from being flipped to another operator?
Would it be allowed elsewhere?
Who can answerCity Council, Planning Board and the Mayor's office
Questions- If this station were proposed in Riverdale or East Gloucester, would the city allow it?
- What in Gloucester's zoning would permit it there, or stop it?
- Has the city ever decided where waste facilities do and do not belong, and has it asked residents?
Why Gloucester and not Manchester or Essex?
Who can answerCity Council, the Mayor's office and the company
Questions- Why is a regional construction waste station proposed in Gloucester rather than in Manchester-by-the-Sea or Essex?
- Do Gloucester residents deserve the same protections and the same say as residents of towns where income is higher?
- If Cape Ann contractors from other towns would use it, what do those towns contribute to the cost?
- The approval does not limit where the loads come from. Why not?
Why did the EDIC change its mind?
Who can answerThe EDIC board and its chair
Questions- What changed between October 2023 and June 2025?
- Was the 2019 survey of park businesses redone?
- Did the EDIC weigh the professional jobs it said it wanted for the park against the station?
- Why were its reasons not put in writing?
Who speaks for the neighbors?
Who can answerCity Council, ward and at-large councilors
Questions- Will the council hold its zoning hearing in West Gloucester, or at a time West Gloucester residents can attend?
- Who in city government is responsible for West Gloucester residents' health if the station is built?
- What would the city tell a family living along the truck route about what it has done to protect them?
Where this stands
Nothing here is final. Residents can write to their ward councilor, the councilors at large, the state representative and the state senator at any time. Contacts and the public steps still ahead are in the Nov. 18 piece.
The Kondelin Road series
One piece a day through the Nov. 18 hearing.
- Fri. Nov. 13The full record
- Sat. Nov. 14Who pays: cost to the city
- Sun. Nov. 15Trucks, roads and safety
- Mon. Nov. 16Water, health and the company record
- Tue. Nov. 17You are hereWhy here? Fairness and the EDIC reversal
- Wed. Nov. 18Hearing day: what can be decided
Sources
- RecordMassDEP: 2025 Solid Waste Master Plan program and policy assessment (Table 1: non-municipal solid waste disposal, 1,710,000 tons in 2024)
- RecordUMass Donahue Institute: Annual resident population estimates for Massachusetts municipalities, July 1, 2024 (state total is the sum of the 351 municipalities, 7,138,560)
- RecordMassachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth: Essex County population, 2019 estimates (Gloucester, Rockport, Essex, Manchester-by-the-Sea)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health hearing, June 4, 2025, city recording and automatic transcript (witness on 180 and 270 tons a day and on not restricting customers)
- RecordCity of Gloucester: Eastern Waste Services (EWS) Site Suitability Application for C&D Transfer Station (project page and timeline)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health: Site Assignment Decision, Eastern Waste Services LLC, 24 Kondelin Road, June 18, 2025
- RecordEastern Waste Services: Second Update on Permit Compliance, presentation to the Board of Health, May 7, 2026
- RecordWeston and Sampson: peer review update of the Eastern Waste Services traffic study, Jan. 7, 2025
- RecordWeston and Sampson: peer review of the supplemental traffic study, draft, Feb. 5, 2026
- RecordMassachusetts Department of Public Health: comment letter on the site suitability application, Nov. 21, 2023
- RecordMassDEP: Administrative Consent Order with Penalty and Notice of Noncompliance No. 00012892, Eastern Waste Services LLC, effective March 10, 2022
- RecordMassDEP, Energy and Environmental Affairs Data Portal: Essex County Recycling Center, facility 368513 (permits, inspections, enforcements), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordU.S. EPA Envirofacts: RCRAInfo facility detail, handler ID MAR000625293 (hazardous waste codes, handler types), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordU.S. EPA ECHO: Detailed Facility Report, Eastern Waste Services LLC, 24 Kondelin Rd (FRS 110071467359; RCRA ID MAR000625293), checked Nov. 11, 2026
- RecordFederal Motor Carrier Safety Administration: SAFER company snapshot, Eastern Waste Services LLC (USDOT 3063127)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health, Eastern Waste Service Subcommittee agenda, Oct. 6, 2026
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission agenda, Oct. 7, 2026
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission agenda, Oct. 21, 2026 (revised)
- RecordCity of Gloucester Solicitor's Office: Eastern Waste Services Approval Process and Permit Tracker, released by the Board of Health March 3, 2026
- RecordHiltz Waste Disposal: Essex County Recycling Center page (24 Kondelin Road)
- SourceWaste Today: MassDEP penalizes Eastern Waste Services for solid waste violations (2022)
- RecordGloucester Board of Health hearing exhibits (city Drive folder): Exhibits 1 to 36, including the Aug. 11, 2023 application, the traffic study and the Oct. 17, 2023 EDIC letter
- RecordGloucester Conservation Commission case folder for the Eastern Waste Services notice of intent, plans and public comments
- RecordGloucester Board of Health memo to the Conservation Commission on gaps in the third party review, Oct. 8, 2026
- RecordGloucester EDIC minutes, June 2, 2025 (vote to support the site)
- SourceMap data: OpenStreetMap contributors; aerial imagery MassGIS 2025
- RecordMassDEP: 310 CMR 19.000 solid waste regulations, definitions (19.006) and waste bans (19.017), as published by Cornell LII
- RecordMassDEP: Minimum Performance Standard for Construction and Demolition Handling Facilities (updated July 2024)
- RecordMassDEP: Waste Ban Guidance for Operators of Solid Waste Facilities (Oct. 2021)
- RecordMassDEP: Asbestos Information Resource Guide (June 2023)
- RecordMassDEP: Asbestos Containing Waste Material temporary storage policy (amended Dec. 2025)
- RecordU.S. EPA: Industrial and construction and demolition landfills
- RecordU.S. EPA: How should lead containing wastes from renovations be handled and disposed
- RecordU.S. EPA: Asbestos NESHAP, demolition and renovation requirements
- RecordU.S. Census Bureau: QuickFacts, Gloucester city, Manchester-by-the-Sea town and United States (2020-2024 five-year estimates, July 2025 population estimates)
Do you trust this story?
See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.