ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Sunday, November 22, 2026Get the Morning Current

Town news

Nondisclosure agreements and Cape Ann officials: what the law allows

The state bars its own permitting agencies from signing nondisclosure agreements with data center projects. No such rule covers Gloucester, Rockport, Essex or Manchester-by-the-Sea. Here is what an agreement like that can and cannot hide, the case for and against, and where campaign money rules fit in.

A fountain pen rests on the signature page of a printed contract, with blank lines for a signature, a name, a title and a date. Other contract pages are spread out around it.
The signature page of a sample contract. File photo, not an agreement signed on Cape Ann. File photo: Blogtrepreneur via Wikimedia Commons

Trust Check: Checked against public records

A question came up in Sutton this month that has not been asked out loud on Cape Ann. At a packed meeting about a proposed $16 billion data center, a Select Board member asked whether anyone in town government had signed a nondisclosure agreement with the developer.

Read what happened in Sutton and what it means for Cape Ann.

This story looks at the same question here. Can a mayor, a councilor, a select board member or a town administrator sign a secrecy agreement with a private company? What could it hide, and what could it not?

The short version

  • No state law stops a local official on Cape Ann from signing an NDA with a private company.
  • The state bars its own permitting agencies from signing them for data center projects. That order does not cover cities and towns.
  • An NDA cannot beat the public records law, the open meeting law or the public hearing a zoning change needs.
  • One agreement signed by the City of Gloucester is public. It is with National Grid and has nothing to do with a data center.
  • In other states, NDAs have kept large projects quiet for a year or more. Five cases are below.

What an NDA is

A nondisclosure agreement, or NDA, is a signed promise to keep something private. Developers often ask local officials to sign one before they share a plan. A Virginia research team looked at 31 proposed data center projects and found NDAs tied to at least 25 of them, NPR reported in August.

In Sutton, a Select Board member asked at the Nov. 10 meeting whether the town was under any NDAs. The answer from the table was no.

25 of 31proposed data center projects in Virginia had NDAs tied to them, a university research team found.
54NDAs signed by elected officials in Louisiana since early 2024, at least, found through records requests.
4 of 7major data center projects in Wisconsin where local officials signed NDAs.

Sources: NPR and the Gulf States Newsroom, Aug. 27, 2026 (Virginia and Louisiana); Wisconsin Watch, Jan. 27, 2026 (Wisconsin). The Louisiana count covers all kinds of projects, not only data centers.

What the state order covers. Executive Order 658 says that for Massachusetts state agencies and departments that issue permits, "the use of non-disclosure agreements with a data center project is prohibited, except as otherwise provided by law." The order does not mention cities, towns or local officials. The governor's office told Bloomberg Law the ban was a precaution and that it knew of no such agreement signed by a state agency.

What that means here. No state law stops a mayor, a city councilor, a select board member or a town administrator from signing an NDA with a private company. In the public meeting records we keep for Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, the term does not appear on any agenda, in any minutes or in any meeting packet from 2023 to now. In Gloucester, one such agreement is on the public record. A nondisclosure and data use agreement between the City and National Grid, dated Jan. 22, 2025, is printed in the City Council Budget and Finance Committee packet for Aug. 21, 2025. It covers things like customer information and details of the electric system. It has nothing to do with a data center.

What an NDA can and cannot do in Massachusetts. Three laws still apply to any city or town, signed paper or not.

What an NDA can keep private

  • The early part. Private talks between a company and one official or a staff member, before anything reaches a board.
  • True trade secrets. A narrow exception in the records law covers trade secrets a company hands over by choice.

What an NDA cannot do

  • Beat the public records law. Records a city or town holds are presumed public. In 2015 the state's highest court ruled, in a case from Weston, that an agreement to keep something private cannot by itself beat the Public Records Law.
  • Close a meeting. A board must talk and vote in public, except in closed sessions the law allows for a short list of reasons.
  • Skip a zoning hearing. A zoning change needs a public hearing and a public vote.

NDAs between developers and local officials: the case for and against
Who makes it
ForThey are a normal first step. Companies look at many sites at once and do not want rivals to know where.State economic development officials in Oklahoma and Louisiana; the University of North Carolina School of Government, describing what companies say
ForA new campus can move a public company's stock price. Secrecy keeps local officials clear of insider trading rules.Wes Cummins, chief executive of Applied Digital, to NPR
ForCompanies share more, and share it sooner, when they know it will stay private.Louisiana's economic development secretary, to NPR
ForA ban could force trade secrets into the open.Republican lawmakers in Pennsylvania, debating a bill to bar local officials from signing
AgainstResidents learn of a project after the key talks are over.Residents and open government groups in Louisiana, Minnesota and Wisconsin
AgainstThe agreements can be written so wide that they cover almost anything, not just trade secrets.Eric Bonds, the Virginia researcher, to Bloomberg Law
AgainstElected officials answer to voters, and an NDA limits what they can tell them.Residents quoted by NPR
AgainstBig projects get done without them. A Louisiana parish president said he landed a $10 billion data center with no NDA.Kenny Havard, West Feliciana Parish president, to NPR

Sources: NPR and the Gulf States Newsroom, Aug. 27, 2026; Bloomberg Law, Sept. 17, 2026; University of North Carolina School of Government, June 26, 2026; Pennsylvania Capital-Star. Governors in Pennsylvania and Delaware have also acted against NDAs, and lawmakers in New Jersey, Michigan, Oklahoma, Kentucky and Ohio have filed bills. One more fact cuts both ways: Sutton said it had no NDA, and residents still saw the plan one day before the first meeting. A ban on NDAs does not by itself mean early notice.

Where NDAs have led to a fight

None of these five places is in Massachusetts. In each one, residents learned of a large project after local officials had agreed to keep quiet about it. In each one, the officials said they followed the law.

Louisiana, 2026

Boyce: a $3.6 billion data center

At least five state senators, the parish assessor and every member of the board that worked out the deal signed NDAs. The project went by code names. The board approved it in April at a public meeting with little discussion.

At a town hall in June, residents asked to see an environmental study. They were told it would not be released.

What came of it: Site work has started. The board's director told NPR that NDAs are legal and that economic development needs them.

Wisconsin, 2023 to 2025

Beaver Dam: 14 months of quiet

The city's development corporation signed an NDA in December 2023 with a company nobody had heard of. The City Council later voted 12 to 0 on an early agreement for the site. The agenda and the minutes did not say data center.

The public was told 14 months after the NDA was signed. The company behind it was Meta. The project is about $1 billion.

What came of it: The data center is being built. The corporation's leader told Wisconsin Watch the city was as open as it could be. A state lawmaker filed a bill in January to ban data center NDAs in Wisconsin.

Wisconsin, 2024 to 2026

Menomonie: a rule changed, then changed back

The city signed an NDA in February 2024. Two months later the City Council changed a land use rule so that warehousing included data centers. A $1.6 billion plan was made public in July 2025.

What came of it: The mayor put the plan on hold in September 2025. In January 2026 the council passed a data center zoning rule that undid the earlier change.

Alabama, 2026

Bessemer: released after a threat to sue

The mayor and the city attorney signed an NDA over a proposed $14.5 billion data center. It barred the city from releasing six kinds of information, including who the developers were, site plans and studies.

What came of it: The city released the agreement after months, once environmental groups threatened to sue over public records, Inside Climate News reported in July.

Maine, 2025

Wiscasset: a town manager signs one

The town manager signed an NDA in August 2025 with a party interested in town land for a data center. The town's lawyer advised that he could sign, and the select board was told. The NDA barred both sides from even saying it existed without written approval. The select board met twice behind closed doors on the inquiry.

What came of it: The town released a copy with the other party's name blacked out after the local paper asked. The manager said the NDA was not for backroom deals and that any real proposal would go through public permitting.

Sources: NPR and the Gulf States Newsroom, Aug. 27, 2026; Wisconsin Watch, Jan. 27, 2026; Inside Climate News, July 13, 2026; Wiscasset Newspaper, Oct. 21, 2025. Why these five: each has a signed agreement that became public and a result on the record. Wisconsin Watch also reported that in one New Mexico county, staff worked on a $165 billion data center under an NDA that kept the county's own elected officials from knowing. Missing: no count exists of how many local NDAs are signed with no dispute at all.

The other side of the ledger is West Feliciana Parish, Louisiana. The parish president there signed no NDA for a $10 billion data center and put the water, power and land agreements on the parish website. Residents there still have concerns about water, power and noise, NPR reported. They do not have to guess at the terms.

Could a bylaw or ordinance ban them?

The state has already drawn this line for itself. The governor's order tells state permitting agencies not to sign NDAs with data center projects. A city or town can very likely do the same for its own officials. Here is why, and where the limits are. This is a summary, not legal advice, and no court or Attorney General ruling on a local NDA ban turned up in our reporting.

Towns and cities make their own rules. Under the Home Rule Amendment to the state constitution, a community can adopt any bylaw or ordinance that does not conflict with state law. No state law gives a local official a right to sign a secrecy agreement, so a ban would have nothing to clash with. Communities already set rules on who may sign a contract for the town and on what terms. An NDA signed for the town is a contract.

How it would pass. In Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea it would be a general bylaw, passed by a majority at Town Meeting and then sent to the Attorney General for review. It is not zoning, so it would not need a two thirds vote. In Gloucester it would be an ordinance passed by the City Council. A select board or a mayor could also adopt it as a policy with no town meeting at all. That is how the state did it. A policy is quicker to adopt and easier for a later board to undo.

What a local rule could reach. It could bar anyone from signing an NDA in the name of the community or in an official role. It could require that any request to sign one be reported at the next public meeting. It could say that an NDA signed against the rule does not bind the community.

What it could not reach.

  • What a person signs as a private citizen, outside the job.
  • Secrecy that state law already requires or allows: trade secrets a company hands over by choice, personnel and medical records, a lawyer's advice, and the closed sessions the Open Meeting Law permits.
  • Some employees. Discipline of union workers runs through their contracts, and school staff answer to the school committee.

No Massachusetts city or town turned up in our reporting with a rule like this on its books. Lawmakers in New Jersey have proposed barring local governments there from signing NDAs, Bloomberg Law reported.

The ethics question: officials who approve, manage and inspect

A secrecy agreement means something different depending on the job. An official who later votes on a project, runs the review or inspects the work owes a duty to the public. An NDA is a promise made to the company. The question is what happens when the two pull apart.

Massachusetts has a conflict of interest law, chapter 268A, that covers every local official and employee, paid or unpaid, elected or appointed. It does not mention NDAs. But several of its rules bear on them.

The ethics questions, by job
The question an NDA raisesWhat state law already says
Officials who approvecity councilors, select board and planning board membersCan a member who knows things the other members and the public do not still cast a fair vote? Can that member answer a neighbor's question at a hearing?An official may not act in a way that would lead a reasonable person to think someone can improperly influence them. Filing a written public disclosure is the usual cure. Boards must deliberate in public.
Officials who managemayor, town administrator, planning and development staffStaff often hear a plan first. If they have promised silence, when do the elected boards find out, and who decides?Records a city or town holds are presumed public, and a private agreement cannot by itself change that. An official may not use the job to give anyone an unwarranted advantage of substantial value.
Officials who inspect and enforcebuilding, health, fire and conservation staffCould a promise of secrecy stop an inspector from reporting a hazard, a violation or a complaint?An NDA cannot cancel a duty the law places on an inspector. Inspection reports and enforcement orders are public records, with narrow exceptions.
Anyone with a stakean official, a family member or an employer with money in the dealIs the secrecy hiding a personal interest?A local employee may not take part in a matter in which they, their immediate family or their business has a financial interest. No gifts worth $50 or more because of the job.
Everyone who signsWhat happens to information the law itself keeps private?An official may not improperly disclose confidential material learned on the job or use it for personal gain. That rule exists with or without an NDA.

Source: Massachusetts General Laws chapter 268A, sections 19 and 23; the Public Records Law; the Open Meeting Law. The State Ethics Commission gives free, confidential advice to any public employee who asks before acting. Missing: the commission has published no opinion on NDAs with developers that turned up in our reporting.

The case that NDAs are an ethics problem. Critics say the trouble is not the secret itself but who is left out. A few officials know the size, the owner and the terms for months while the people who will vote, and the neighbors, do not. By the time a plan is public, they argue, positions are set.

The case that they are not. Economic development officials say early talks could not happen without them. A company weighing several towns will not share its plans if a competitor can read them the next day, and they say land prices can jump once a name is known. They note that an NDA does not change who votes, and that every approval still takes place in public.

A middle path some places use. Limit an NDA to true trade secrets and set an end date. Require that the signing be reported in public right away. Bar anyone who will vote on or inspect the project from signing at all.

Where campaign money fits in

Secrecy matters most when you cannot tell who is asking. That is where the campaign finance law comes in. It is built on one idea: the public gets to see who gives money to the people who decide.

  • A company cannot give to a candidate. Massachusetts bars contributions to candidates from corporations, limited liability companies and partnerships.
  • People can. One person may give a candidate up to $1,000 a year. That includes a company's owners, executives and lawyers, giving in their own names. Campaign reports list the names.
  • A name is the key. If the public does not know who is behind a plan, nobody can check the donor lists against it. An NDA can keep that name private during the early talks.
  • Town Meeting is a gap. The state's campaign finance office says the law does not cover money spent mainly to sway a vote at a town meeting. In Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, zoning is decided at Town Meeting. A company could pay for mailers or ads before a zoning vote there and file no report. A bill on Beacon Hill, House 806 and Senate 506, would require a report from anyone who spends $1,000 or more to sway a town meeting vote. The House gave it a first approval and the Senate version went to the Ways and Means Committee.
  • No list of local lobbyists. The state's lobbyist registry is built for people paid to lobby the Legislature and state agencies. A bill to register people who lobby city officials would cover only cities of more than 150,000 people. It was sent to study in March.
  • Gifts are limited either way. The conflict of interest law bars a public employee from taking anything worth $50 or more that is given because of the job. That holds with or without an NDA.

Who decides zoning, and where the money records are, as of Nov. 17, 2026
Where campaign reports are filedRule on NDAs with private companies
GloucesterCity CouncilCandidates for mayor file with the state Office of Campaign and Political Finance. Candidates for City Council file with the City Clerk.None in state law. One utility data agreement with National Grid is on the public record.
RockportTown Meeting votersCandidates for town office file with the Town Clerk. Money spent to sway a Town Meeting vote is not reported.None in state law. No mention in meeting records since 2023.
EssexTown Meeting votersCandidates for town office file with the Town Clerk. Money spent to sway a Town Meeting vote is not reported.None in state law. No mention in meeting records since 2023.
Manchester-by-the-SeaTown Meeting votersCandidates for town office file with the Town Clerk. Money spent to sway a Town Meeting vote is not reported.None in state law. No mention in meeting records since 2023.

Sources: Massachusetts General Laws chapter 55 and guides from the Office of Campaign and Political Finance; chapter 40A, section 5; Cape Ann Current public meeting records for the four communities, 2023 to Nov. 17, 2026. Why these four: they are the communities the Current covers. Missing: this table does not cover what each community's own bylaws or ordinances say about NDAs.

What it adds up to. For residents, Sutton showed the simplest check: ask in public whether anyone has signed one, and ask who the company is. For officials, the choice to sign or to refuse is theirs under today's law, and the records and meeting laws apply either way. For a builder, the lesson from other states is that secrecy early can cost trust later.

Earlier coverage: Cape Ann and data centers: lessons from Sutton's $16 billion fight (Nov. 19). Data centers and plate reader cameras: what each Cape Ann community has on the books (Nov. 8).

How we did this: Cape Ann Current read the governor's order, state law, court and state agency guidance, the public meeting records of the four communities and the reports listed below. It also watched the Sutton Select Board meeting of Nov. 10 online. The Current takes no position on nondisclosure agreements or on any community's rules. Questions and corrections: [email protected].

Later coverage: Gloucester weighs a data center ban. Lowell shows what's at stake (Nov. 21).

Sources

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.