ListenPodcastShare information
Cape Ann CurrentKeeping Cape Ann current.

Free public information for Gloucester, Rockport, Essex and Manchester-by-the-Sea, in plain English

Sunday, November 22, 2026Get the Morning Current

Town news

Gloucester weighs a data center ban. Lowell shows what's at stake

An order to prohibit data centers in every Gloucester zoning district goes before the City Council on Tuesday, and Essex has voted to allow none until 2028. Lowell's 11 years next to one raise questions about noise, generators, water, electricity, taxes and who gets a say.

Downtown Lowell from the air, with red brick mill buildings and a tall smokestack along the Merrimack River and a green steel bridge crossing it
Downtown Lowell and the Merrimack River in April 2026. The data center sits in the Sacred Heart and Back Central neighborhoods south of downtown. File photo: Quintin Soloviev via Wikimedia Commons

Trust Check: Checked against public records

Gloucester could become the next Massachusetts community to ban data centers. An order from City Councilor Dylan Benson is on the City Council's agenda for Tuesday, Nov. 24. It would add "Data Center" to the short list of uses that are not allowed anywhere in the city.

Essex has already acted. On Nov. 16, Town Meeting voted to allow no data centers until Jan. 1, 2028, while the Planning Board works on permanent zoning.

No data center has been publicly proposed in Gloucester, Rockport, Essex or Manchester-by-the-Sea. Local officials are deciding now what should apply if one ever is.

Lowell shows why the details matter. A data center opened there in 2015 on an old pasta plant site with homes on every side. Since then it has drawn neighbor complaints, lawsuits, a fight over more diesel generators and a citywide pause on new data centers. It also brought jobs, tax money and a company that says it stores data for hospitals, universities and police departments.

Where Cape Ann stands

Data centers and Cape Ann zoning, as of Nov. 21, 2026
What the zoning says todayWhat comes next
GloucesterBan proposed, not passedThe use tables do not name data centers. A use that is not expressly allowed is already prohibited, but nothing on the books says which listed category, if any, a data center would fall under.Tuesday's agenda marks the order to be sent to the council's Planning and Development Committee and to the Planning Board. Public hearings come after that.
EssexNone allowed until Jan. 1, 2028Town Meeting added a definition of a data center and a temporary stop on Nov. 16. Both passed, the stop by more than two thirds.The Planning Board has said it will bring permanent zoning to one of the next two town meetings. The Attorney General reviews every town bylaw.
RockportNothing specificThe table of permitted uses does not name data centers. The bylaw has no line that says an unlisted use is banned.Nothing is proposed. A change would need a Planning Board hearing and a two thirds vote at Town Meeting.
Manchester-by-the-SeaNothing specificAny use that is not listed is prohibited, and data centers are not listed.The Planning Board added data centers to its list of topics on Nov. 9 after a notice from Beverly. Nothing has been formally proposed.

Sources: Gloucester City Council agenda for Nov. 24 and the Gloucester Zoning Ordinance; the Nov. 16 Essex Town Meeting; the Rockport and Manchester-by-the-Sea zoning bylaws; the Nov. 9 Manchester Planning Board meeting. Why these four: they are the communities the Current covers. Missing: no data center application has been filed in any of them, so there is no project to measure against these pages.

"Not named" does not mean "allowed." In Rockport, a project still has to fit a use the table permits, and the building inspector makes the first call on that. In Manchester-by-the-Sea and Gloucester, the zoning already says an unlisted use is out. What a ban by name adds is certainty. Nobody has to argue later about whether a data center counts as research, manufacturing or a warehouse.

Is the Essex vote in force? Under state law, a town's zoning change counts from the day Town Meeting votes. The town clerk has 30 days after the meeting ends to send it to the Attorney General, who has 90 days to review it. If she turns it down, the old zoning is treated as if it had stayed in place all along.

Our Nov. 19 story has the longer comparison, including what other Massachusetts communities have voted: Cape Ann and data centers: lessons from Sutton's $16 billion fight.

Gloucester has a ban on the table

The agenda line is one sentence. It reads: "CC#2026-025 (Benson): Amend Sec. 2.3.8 'Uses prohibited in all districts' by ADDING Item #4 'Data Center.'"

That section of the Gloucester Zoning Ordinance has three items today:

  1. Any building or use the ordinance does not expressly permit.
  2. Any building or use the building inspector finds may create a safety or health hazard.
  3. Billboards.

Data centers would be the fourth.

What happens Tuesday, and what does not

The City Council meets at 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. 24, in Kyrouz Auditorium at City Hall. The agenda has a Zoom link for watching from home.

The order is listed with the other councilors' orders on the consent agenda. Next to it the agenda says "Refer P&D & PB." That means it is set to be sent to the council's Planning and Development Committee and to the Planning Board. It is not set for a vote on the ban itself, and it is not a public hearing.

Read the agenda.

What it takes to pass

Gloucester's zoning ordinance and state law lay out the same steps for any zoning change.

  1. The council sends the proposal to the Planning Board within 14 days.
  2. The Planning Board and the council, or a council committee, each hold a public hearing. Those must happen within 65 days after the board gets the proposal. Notice runs in a newspaper two weeks in a row, the first time at least 14 days ahead.
  3. The council cannot vote until the Planning Board sends its recommendation, or 21 days pass after the board's hearing with none.
  4. Passing takes two thirds of the whole council. That is six of nine votes.
  5. If the council does not vote within 90 days of closing its hearing, it has to hold a new one.

The council can adopt the proposal, reject it, or change it and then adopt it.

One date matters more than it looks. Under state law, a zoning change does not reach a building permit or special permit issued before the first hearing notice is published. A permit issued after that notice has to follow the change if it passes.

What two words leave open

The agenda shows two words, "Data Center," and no definition. Gloucester's zoning has no definition of a data center today. The only place it mentions computers is a line that allows a home office.

That leaves real questions for the hearings.

  • What counts? A hospital, a school, a bank and City Hall all keep computer servers. So do many businesses. The agenda line does not say where a company's own server room ends and a data center begins.
  • Is there a size cutoff? None is shown.
  • Are small rooms exempt? None is shown.

Other places have answered these in writing. Essex added a definition on Nov. 16 that describes a data center as a facility used mainly to store, process and send digital data. Lowell's two drafts, described below, carve out an "accessory data room" that serves only the business in the building. It can take up no more than 20 percent of the building or 2,500 square feet, whichever is smaller. Lowell's planners wrote that zoning should not sweep in a school, hospital or business that keeps its own small server room.

Gloucester's council could add a definition before it votes. Whether it does is one thing to watch.

What about a data center that is already here? None is known to exist in Gloucester. On Nov. 4, a company laying fiber optic cable for Applied Materials was asked at a city meeting whether a data center was coming. It said no. How state law treats a use that is already running when a ban passes is covered in its own section below.

How to follow it. Watch Tuesday's meeting in person or on Zoom. The hearings at the Planning Board and the council are where residents can speak, and both will be posted on the city's meeting calendar. The council's next regular meeting is Dec. 8.

What happened in Lowell

How it started

In 2015 the Markley Group, a Boston company, bought the old Prince pasta plant in Lowell and turned it into a data center. Pasta making there ended in the 1990s, and most of the plant sat empty for years after. The Planning Board approved the plan that July, and the City Council backed it with a tax agreement. Lowell had no zoning written for data centers.

The building sits in the Sacred Heart and Back Central neighborhoods. The land is zoned for light industry, and homes sit all around it. One neighbor told NBC10 Boston that nobody knew what a data center was when it came to Lowell.

For years the building drew little notice. Then demand for computing grew, and the site grew with it. The company added backup generators and cooling equipment and bought more property nearby.

Where the data center is

Zoom and drag to see the building, the rail line and the homes around it. Tap a pin for what is there.

The data centerCity Hall and the forum site

Pins: street addresses located with OpenStreetMap. Aerial: MassGIS 2025. Parcel lines are not drawn.

Lowell's data center at a glance
Source
OpenedBought and approved in 2015, on the former Prince pasta site at 1 Markley Way. The state says it has run since 2016.Bisnow; MassDEP fact sheet; Yale Law School clinic case page
BuildingAbout 352,000 square feet on about 14 acresWBUR, July 29, 2026; GBH News, Aug. 11, 2026
PowerAbout 50 megawatts by published reports, the largest data center in Massachusetts. The company does not give out the site's actual power use. The Sutton plan is about 900 megawatts.Bisnow, March 2026; WBZ-TV, June 22, 2026; Town of Sutton memo
Zoning when it openedNothing written for data centersBisnow
JobsAbout 100 at the Lowell siteCommonWealth Beacon, March 17, 2026
TaxesAbout $12 million in net taxes to the city expected over 20 years, or about $600,000 a year on averageCommonWealth Beacon
Tax breakA city tax agreement and personal property tax exemption estimated to save the company $77 million over 20 yearsGBH News, Aug. 11, 2026
Backup generatorsThe counts differ by source. The state's fact sheet says one approval covers 11 generators, 7 of them installed, a second application adds 8, and it gives the total as both 19 and 27. The residents' lawsuit says the permit allows 27 generators and 16 cooling towers. The company's chief executive told WBUR there are 23 on site, two not yet wired. Each generator is 3,000 kilowatts. A judge has blocked 4 that were not installed.MassDEP fact sheet; Conservation Law Foundation, April 30 and Aug. 10, 2026; WBUR, July 29, 2026
Generator testingAbout five minutes a week for each generator, plus a two hour test once a yearMassDEP fact sheet
Water60,000 to 120,000 gallons a day over the past year, the company's figure. WBZ-TV said it matched water bills the station obtained.WBZ-TV, June 22, 2026
Who it servesHospitals, universities and police departments, the company says, for cloud computing and data storageNBC10 Boston, July 16, 2026

Why Lowell: it is the one Massachusetts community with a large data center already running next to homes. The yearly tax figure is our division of the 20 year total. Generator counts differ by source because some units are approved but not installed. Missing: the site's yearly electricity use.

What neighbors say

The complaints are about living next to the machinery, not about the computers inside. These are the neighbors' accounts. No agency finding on them is cited in the reports and state papers behind this story.

  • Noise. Cooling fans run on the roof and on the ground. One neighbor told The Harvard Crimson that cooling units about 100 feet from back doors wake people at night.
  • Diesel. The backup generators burn diesel fuel. A man who grew up next to the site told WBZ-TV that an exhaust stack stands 84 feet from his home and that a test filled the house with the smell of fumes.
  • Growth. The site kept adding equipment. The residents' lawsuit says the state never weighed how new exhaust adds to the pollution the neighborhood already has.
  • Cameras. Security cameras ring the property, and some neighbors say they feel watched. In a video a photographer posted in June, a neighbor who said they have lived beside the site for about eight years said a company camera points at their home 24 hours a day.

That man helped start a resident group, Honest Future for Lowell, and is a plaintiff in the lawsuit against the state permit. "The people of Lowell do not want this data center," another resident told GBH News at a rally outside City Hall in July. The Current does not name private residents.

A company still buying

WBZ-TV reported in June that the company has been buying homes and land near the site in hopes of expanding, including an old power plant up the road. At the city's June 29 forum, one resident said the company had become one of the larger landlords in the area. Another said it had bought a gas burning power plant on Tanner Street and had not said what it plans to do there.

Lowell's 360 day pause blocks any new or larger data center for now, whoever owns the land. It does not stop a company from buying property. No city document we read lists what the company and its affiliates own.

Videos shared online this fall also claim the cameras around the site use facial recognition. Nothing the city or the state has published says what the cameras can do, and the company's public statements do not address it. Neither of Lowell's two zoning drafts covers cameras.

What the company and its workers say

Markley says its Lowell site is not one of the giant buildings driven by the artificial intelligence boom. It says the site stores data for hospitals, universities and police departments, and that the generators are there in case the power goes out.

The company told the state it has never lost power and has never had to run the generators for a long stretch. It says it added sound barriers along the property line, changed the landscaping to dampen noise, raised the generator stacks and paid for testing of sound and exhaust. The state's fact sheet says those tests showed the site stayed within state standards. It does not give the results.

In a statement to Agence France-Presse in October, the company said it serves more than 600 clients in Massachusetts. It said its generators run only for five minute tests each week and produce about 44 decibels of sound. It said it tests its water twice a year for the bacteria that cause Legionnaires' disease and has planted 2,000 trees. Some neighbors back the company. A contractor who lives a few streets away told the agency he is grateful the company rebuilt an abandoned site.

A company vice president told WBZ-TV in June that neighbors were exaggerating. The company told GBH News in August that the people against the site are a small but vocal minority. After a visit from NBC10 Boston in July, the company started a website and a Facebook page to talk with neighbors.

Workers showed up too. At the March council meeting, union electricians in "Stand with Markley" shirts told councilors the data center built their careers. A Markley worker told the Crimson that at least a third of the staff live in Lowell. A company executive told CommonWealth Beacon that a pause could slow new hiring and called the vote part of "a national wave."

Generators, noise and a court order

The sharpest fight in Lowell is over backup power. The company asked the state for eight more diesel generators, which would bring the total to 27, along with 16 cooling towers. Each generator is rated at 3,000 kilowatts.

Who decides. The city controls zoning. The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, called MassDEP, controls air permits for the generators. Lowell says so on its own data center page: the city does not regulate air pollution. So when Lowell paused new data centers in March, the generator permit kept moving at the state.

How often they run. The state's fact sheet says each generator is tested about five minutes a week, plus a two hour test once a year. They are allowed to run in a power outage. The state's general limits for emergency engines allow up to 100 hours a year of testing and upkeep. A permit can set tighter terms.

How noise is judged. MassDEP's long standing noise policy treats a source as a problem when it raises sound more than 10 decibels above the usual background. Both MassDEP and local officials, such as a board of health, can enforce the state noise regulation. A city can also write its own number into zoning. Lowell's Option 1 draft would allow only 3 decibels above background.

What is claimed

  • Residents say the state approved the air permit without weighing their objections or the pollution the neighborhood already carries.
  • They say the state and the company signed an agreement in September 2025, out of public view, that let generators go in while their appeal was still open.
  • A second lawsuit, a proposed class action filed May 27, 2026, says noise from the generators and cooling towers keeps neighbors from sleeping and has cut property values.
  • The company says it did every study the state required and that the permit was properly approved. A lawyer for the state told the judge that "the department followed the rules."

What has been decided

  • MassDEP approved the permit in 2025. A state hearing officer found the residents had no standing to appeal, and the commissioner upheld the permit.
  • On Aug. 10, 2026, Superior Court Judge C. William Barrett paused the installation of four generators that were not yet in place. Four installed under the 2025 agreement were not removed.
  • The judge found the residents were likely to show the state wrongly shut seven of them out of its appeal process. He wrote that this "deprived the plaintiffs of a meaningful review of their claims."
  • That order is an early one, made while the case goes on. There is no final ruling, and no court has found that the generators break pollution or noise limits.

Has the site been cited? The reports and state papers behind this story show one penalty. The noise lawsuit says MassDEP fined the company $500 in July 2023 for failing to file a required emissions report. None of them shows a regulator finding that the site broke a noise or air pollution limit.

The company went to court too. It sued the city over the pause, and GBH News reported the two sides reached an agreement that lets expansion plans filed before the pause go forward.

Lowell and its data center, 2015 to now
What happened
2015CityMarkley buys the former Prince pasta site. The Planning Board approves a data center in July and the City Council approves a tax agreement. Lowell has no data center zoning.
July 2025StateMassDEP approves an air permit that allows up to eight more diesel generators. Residents appeal three weeks later.
September 2025StateMassDEP and the company sign an administrative consent order. Four generators are installed under it while the residents' appeal is open.
December 2025StateA state hearing officer recommends that the permit stand. The department's commissioner later agrees.
January 2026CityThe City Council first backs a pause on new data centers.
March 10, 2026CityThe council votes 10 to 0 for a 360 day pause on new or larger data centers, with a possible 180 day extension. It is the first in Massachusetts.
April 30, 2026CourtResidents sue the company and the state in Middlesex Superior Court. Their lawyers call it the first lawsuit in Massachusetts against a data center expansion.
May 27, 2026CourtNeighbors file a proposed class action against the company over noise.
June 25, 2026StateGov. Maura Healey stops taking applications for state sales tax breaks for data centers "until we have strong protections in place."
June 29, 2026CityCity planners hold a public forum on data centers at the Butler School. Questions and answers from the forum are on the city's website.
July 29, 2026CourtA judge hears the residents' request to stop the generator work while the case goes on.
Aug. 10, 2026CourtJudge C. William Barrett pauses four generators that were not yet installed. Four already installed stay.
Sept. 8, 2026StateThe governor signs Executive Order 658, which sets conditions on state permits for data centers over 25 megawatts.
September 2026CityPlanners post two zoning drafts: Option 1 (Sept. 8) allows a small "green computing center" by special permit with strict limits. Option 2 (Sept. 15) bans data centers in every district.
Late January 2027CityThe city's schedule calls for a Planning Board hearing in early January and a council hearing and vote in late January. The pause runs out in early March 2027 unless the council extends it.

Sources: City of Lowell ordinance, planning department memo and Zoning Ordinance Drafts page; MassDEP fact sheet; WBUR, July 29, 2026; GBH News, Aug. 11, 2026; Conservation Law Foundation, April 30 and Aug. 10, 2026; Yale Law School Environmental Justice Law and Advocacy Clinic; WBZ-TV, June 26 and Aug. 11, 2026; Bisnow and CommonWealth Beacon, March 2026. The last row is the city's plan, not something that has happened. As of Nov. 19, the city's agenda center listed no council committee meeting on the two drafts.

What this means on Cape Ann. A zoning ban or a pause is a local tool. A generator's air permit is a state decision, and it can keep moving after a local vote. Distance from homes, a noise number and limits on generator testing are things a community can put in its own zoning, as Lowell's draft does, but only before a project is approved.

What Lowell is writing now

During the pause, Lowell hired planning consultants and a law firm. In September the city posted two drafts for the council to choose between. Both start from the same idea: a data center is its own kind of use, not an office or a warehouse, and none is allowed by right anywhere in the city.

Option 1: allow a small one, with limits

Dated Sept. 8, 2026. A "Tier I green computing center" could get a special permit from the Planning Board in four districts: institutional, office park, light industry and general industry. Anything bigger, or anything that misses one condition, is a "Tier II general data center," banned everywhere.

Size cap15 megawatts of connected load, counted from the electrical drawings at full build out, no matter how the site is split up or phased
Distance from homes1,000 feet from the edge of any residential district, for the building and every generator, cooler, fuel tank and substation
CoolingClosed loop or river water only. No cooling that uses up water by evaporation. No drinking water for cooling. Water used up: 1,000 gallons a day at most
NoiseNo more than 3 decibels above the usual background at the property line or the nearest home, checked by sound studies before and after construction
GeneratorsBackup power must come from batteries or fuel cells. A diesel generator is allowed only for the life safety systems the building code requires, never to run the computers, with capped test hours reported each year and no tests between 5 p.m. and 7 a.m. or on Sundays
LeavingA plan and money set aside to take out all equipment and generators if the site shuts down

Option 2: ban them citywide

Dated Sept. 15, 2026. Data centers would be a prohibited use in every one of Lowell's 20 zoning districts. The only computing allowed would be an "accessory data room" inside another business.

Accessory data roomNo more than 20 percent of the building or 2,500 square feet, whichever is smaller, and no more than 500 kilowatts (400 under Option 1)
Who it servesOnly the business on that lot. It may not sell storage or computing to anyone else
Cooling and powerDry cooling only, no water used up, and no fossil fuel generator beyond the building's own standby unit
The existing siteNeither option removes it. The city says an existing data center can stay unless it stops for two years or changes

Both drafts are marked "for review before adding to redline," meaning the council has not voted on either. Source: City of Lowell Zoning Ordinance Drafts page, Option 1 (rev. 3) and Option 2 (rev. 6). No newer draft was posted as of Nov. 21, 2026.

Electricity: how much, and who pays

Data centers come in very different sizes, and size drives almost everything else.

A megawatt is a measure of how much power something draws at once. A server room inside a hospital or an office might draw a few hundred kilowatts, a fraction of one megawatt. Lowell's drafts cap that kind of room at 400 or 500 kilowatts. The Lowell data center is about 50 megawatts by published reports. The campus proposed in Sutton is about 900.

Across the country, data centers used about 4.4 percent of all electricity in 2023, by the estimate of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, a federal research lab. The lab projects 6.7 to 12 percent by 2028.

New England is not there. ISO New England, which runs the regional power grid, said in May that only two large new power users were in formal study in all six states. Together they could draw 285 megawatts at most. The grid operator has said data centers have not been a driver of wholesale power costs in this region so far.

Who pays for new lines and equipment? Lowell's page says the company asking for service pays for local grid upgrades, and that electric rates are set by the supplier and the state Department of Public Utilities, not the city. CommonWealth Beacon reported that National Grid upgraded 199 utility poles to carry more power to the Lowell site. Who paid for that work was not reported.

Can costs land on other customers? It has happened elsewhere, and the evidence is mixed. In the 13 state power market that includes Virginia, the market's independent monitor tied about $9.3 billion in higher power supply costs in one yearly auction to data center demand. A 2026 study by the consulting firm E3 found no evidence that data centers had been subsidized by other customers under the rate setups in place up to now. Neither finding is about Massachusetts.

The state is writing its own answer. The governor's order tells the Department of Public Utilities to keep working on rates for very large power users, with the stated aim of keeping grid upgrade costs off everyone else. On Sept. 24 the department told National Grid, Eversource and Unitil to list every data center request over 1 megawatt in their queues. The companies also have to give the cost of the upgrades each one would need. And they have to show how that cost would be split between the customer and other ratepayers. Those filings were due Oct. 23.

What this means on Cape Ann. National Grid is the electric company here. A data center would be a private project, but the lines and substations that feed it are shared. The questions to ask early are how many megawatts, what upgrades that would take, and who pays.

Water: it depends on the cooling

Computers make heat, and the heat has to go somewhere.

  • Evaporative cooling uses up water. It turns into vapor and does not come back.
  • Closed loop cooling recirculates the same water or coolant and uses up little.
  • Air or dry cooling uses fans and little or no water, but more electricity.

Water taken in is not the same as water used up. A plant can draw a lot and return most of it, or draw less and lose it all to evaporation. That is why Lowell's Option 1 draft bans evaporative cooling and caps the water actually used up at 1,000 gallons a day.

Nationally, data centers directly used up about 17 billion gallons of water in 2023, by the same federal lab's estimate. The biggest sites account for most of it. Many smaller ones use far less.

In Lowell, the company told WBZ-TV it used 60,000 to 120,000 gallons a day over the past year, and the station said water bills it obtained matched. The reports do not say what kind of cooling the site runs, and nothing the city has posted says whether water or sewer lines had to be upgraded for it.

What this means on Cape Ann. Water is tight here in dry years. Rockport has been under a total ban on outdoor watering since Sept. 18, and the state declared a water supply emergency there on Nov. 10. The town's last posted reading before that put its reservoirs at 55.8 percent full. Rockport plans around 680,000 gallons a day for the whole town. The Lowell site's reported range is about 9 to 18 percent of that. That is a comparison of two real numbers, not a forecast of what any project here would use.

Each community has its own supply. Rockport's reservoirs are Cape Pond and Carlson's Quarry. Gloucester runs on six reservoirs. Manchester-by-the-Sea uses a pond and wells. Essex runs on wells. The questions for any proposal are what kind of cooling, how many gallons on the hottest day, and where the water comes from.

Jobs, taxes and the trade-offs

The case for a data center is mostly about money: taxes on an expensive building and its equipment, construction work, and a new use for an empty site.

Lowell: what is documented and what is not
What is knownSource
BenefitJobsAbout 100 people work at the site. A union official told WBZ-TV that 80 to 100 trade workers can be on site during big projects.CommonWealth Beacon; WBZ-TV
BenefitTaxesAbout $12 million in net taxes to the city expected over 20 years. The report does not name where the estimate comes from.CommonWealth Beacon
BenefitAn empty plant put to usePasta making ended in the 1990s and most of the plant sat empty for years.GBH News; NBC10 Boston
BenefitServicesThe company says it stores data for hospitals, universities and police departments.NBC10 Boston
CostTax breakThe city's tax agreement and personal property tax exemption are estimated to save the company $77 million over 20 years.GBH News
CostState tax breakA 2024 state program offered a 20 year sales tax exemption to data centers that keep or add 100 jobs. The governor stopped taking applications on June 25, 2026.WBZ-TV; Executive Order 658
Not answeredTaxes actually paidNo year by year figure from the city is in the reports.
Not answeredGrid workNational Grid upgraded 199 poles for the site. Who paid is not reported.CommonWealth Beacon
Not answeredCity costsNo count of city spending on inspections, public safety, planning consultants or lawyers tied to the site has been published.
Not answeredHome valuesThe noise lawsuit claims values fell. No independent study has been published.ClassAction.org

Why these rows: each is a dollar or jobs claim made about the Lowell site. The $12 million and $77 million figures both cover 20 years and come from news reports, not from a city audit. Missing: an independent review of whether the site has been a net gain for the city. None was found.

Tax money coming in is not the same as money left over. To judge a project, a city needs both sides: what it will collect, what it gives up in tax breaks, and what it will spend.

What this means on Cape Ann. If a developer ever comes to Gloucester or a neighboring town, officials can ask for the numbers in writing before any vote. That means the assessed value and the yearly taxes, with and without any tax agreement. It means permanent jobs counted apart from construction jobs. And it means who pays for power, water and road work.

What the state requires now

Gov. Maura Healey signed Executive Order 658 on Sept. 8, 2026. It applies to data centers with peak electricity demand above 25 megawatts that are built after that date, and to existing ones that expand by 25 megawatts or more.

For those projects, the order says:

  • State agencies may not issue permits unless the developer shows it meets the state's standards on air quality, public health, water use and community engagement.
  • The developer must have a community benefits agreement, reviewed by the state's Office of Environmental Justice and Equity. The governor's office described the order as requiring local approval before state permits.
  • The project must line up enough new clean electricity to match what it uses in a year, or pay into a fund that goes back to ratepayers. MassDEP has until Dec. 31, 2026 to set up that payment.
  • Operating sites must file yearly reports. Water limits and reporting details are still to be written by state agencies.
  • State agencies may not sign nondisclosure agreements about these projects, except as the law provides.

Some of this took effect the day it was signed, including the limits on permits and nondisclosure agreements. Much of the rest needs agencies to write the details, and most of that has no deadline.

What it does not do. The order sets nothing for a data center at or under 25 megawatts. It does not change local zoning or take a zoning decision away from a city or town. It is an executive order, so a later governor could change or end it.

One deadline matters for Cape Ann. The order tells the state to publish a guide for cities and towns on data center development by Dec. 31, 2026. Gloucester's hearings could run past that date, and Essex's Planning Board is writing permanent zoning with a 2028 deadline. Both could have the guide in hand.

If a ban passes, what happens to one that is already there?

A zoning ban looks forward. State law, Chapter 40A, Section 6, says a zoning change generally does not apply to a building or use that already lawfully exists.

In plain terms:

  • New data centers: a ban stops them.
  • One already running lawfully: it can generally stay. Lowell tells its residents the same thing about the Markley site.
  • Growing or changing it: the new zoning does apply to a change or a substantial extension of the use. The local permit board has to find that the change would not be substantially more harmful to the neighborhood than what is there now.
  • Shutting down: a community's zoning can end the protection for a use that has been abandoned or not used for two years.
  • Generators and air permits: these are state decisions either way.

This is a summary of the statute, not a ruling on any property. How it applies to one site depends on that site's permits and history.

For Gloucester, with no data center known to exist, a ban would mostly decide the future. The Lowell lesson is about timing. Lowell said yes first and is writing its zoning 11 years later, and neither of its drafts can remove what is already built.

Ban, moratorium or conditional approval: What choices do communities have?

Three approaches, side by side
What it doesWhat it does not do
BanNames data centers as a use not allowed anywhere. Ends any argument over which category they fit.Does not remove a lawful existing site. Gives up whatever taxes and jobs a project might bring. Needs a clear definition so ordinary server rooms are not caught.Proposed in Gloucester. Lowell's Option 2. Holyoke and Salem have passed bans.
MoratoriumStops new projects for a set time while permanent zoning is written.Does not last. The Attorney General has warned that a pause cannot be stretched out without end. Does not touch state permits for a site already there.Essex, until Jan. 1, 2028. Lowell, 360 days from March 10, 2026, with a possible 180 day extension.
Permit with conditionsAllows a data center only by special permit, with limits written into zoning.Takes the most work to write and to enforce. Limits only bind what the zoning spells out.Lowell's Option 1. Mansfield capped data centers at 2 megawatts.

Sources: Gloucester City Council agenda for Nov. 24; Essex Town Meeting, Nov. 16; City of Lowell moratorium ordinance and zoning drafts; our Nov. 19 story for Holyoke, Salem, Mansfield and the Attorney General's letter on moratoriums. Why these examples: each is a recorded vote or a posted draft. Missing: proposals still pending in other Massachusetts communities.

Lowell's Option 1 shows what conditions can look like in zoning. It has a size cap, a distance from homes and a noise number checked by sound studies. It limits backup generators and when they can be tested. It caps the water used up and requires money set aside to take the equipment out. A local board can also ask for traffic plans, energy studies and emergency plans as part of a special permit.

Some things are not local. Air permits for generators belong to MassDEP. Electric rates and who pays for grid upgrades belong to the Department of Public Utilities and the utility. Wetlands are reviewed locally under state law.

None of the three is right for every place. A ban is the simplest to write and the hardest to fine tune. A permit system keeps the door open and puts the weight on the details. A pause only buys time.

Questions Cape Ann residents should be asking

  • What is a data center, in writing? Does Gloucester's order come with a definition? Does it leave room for a hospital, school or business to keep its own servers?
  • Is there a size line? Lowell's drafts draw one at a few hundred kilowatts for a server room and 15 megawatts for a small center. The state draws one at 25 megawatts.
  • What would a ban give up? No one has put a project or a tax figure in front of Gloucester. What would the city want to know before closing the door for good?
  • If not a ban, which limits? Distance from homes, noise, generators, water and cleanup money can all be written down ahead of time.
  • What about Rockport and Manchester-by-the-Sea? Is zoning that does not name data centers clear enough, or should each town say yes or no by name?
  • What will Essex write? Its stop ends Jan. 1, 2028. Will the permanent zoning be a ban or a permit system?
  • Will the state's guide change anything? It is due Dec. 31, 2026.

The decisions ahead

Lowell's experience makes one point clearly. The time to settle noise, water, generators and growth is before a project is approved. After that, a city is mostly working around what is already there. Lowell's does not prove that every data center causes the same problems. Sizes, cooling systems, sites and state requirements all differ, and the Lowell site was approved in 2015 under none of the limits now on the table.

On Tuesday, Gloucester's City Council is set to send a proposed ban to its Planning and Development Committee and the Planning Board. Public hearings and a vote that needs six of nine councilors come later. Essex has until Jan. 1, 2028 to replace its stop with something permanent. Rockport and Manchester-by-the-Sea have not proposed anything.

Earlier coverage: Cape Ann and data centers: lessons from Sutton's $16 billion fight (Nov. 19), with the longer comparison of local zoning and votes in other communities. Nondisclosure agreements and Cape Ann officials: what the law allows (Nov. 20). Essex and Manchester town meeting results (Nov. 17). Manchester Planning Board, Nov. 9 (Nov. 11). Data centers and plate reader cameras on Cape Ann (Nov. 8). State declares a water supply emergency in Rockport (Nov. 10).

How we reported this: from the Gloucester City Council agenda for Nov. 24 and the Gloucester Zoning Ordinance. We read the state zoning law, Executive Order 658 and the Department of Public Utilities directive that followed it. From Lowell we read the moratorium ordinance, the planning department memo, the two zoning drafts and the forum questions and answers. We also used the state's fact sheet on the air permit and published reports by the outlets named above, and we watched the recording of Lowell's June 29 forum. This story was first published Nov. 21, 2026 and was rewritten later that day to lead with Gloucester's proposed ban. Questions or corrections: [email protected].

Sources

See something wrong? Email [email protected]. Read our standards and corrections policy.